5th grader Stephanie's friend Josh asks Stephanie if she wants to go out with him and the rest of the baseball team to a pizza parlor and just hang out. With D.J.'s help, Stephanie makes the mistake of thinking that this will be more than just hanging out. Stephanie thinks this is going to be her first date.
Meanwhile, Joey invites his boss, Alison Axelrod, over for dinner, and he may end up ruining dinner because he becomes a nervous wreck whenever he is around her.