The crew goes on-line and Fry experiences the Internet of the future for the first time. After going to some filthy chat rooms, they decide to play a video game. While in the game, Leela sees Alkazar, a male cyclops, but Fry blasts him before Leela finds out anything. Fortunately, Alkazar wrote down Leela's screen name and e-mailed her coordinates to his home planet.
Once she gets there, Alkazar tells her that he is the last surviving male cyclops and that she seems to be the last surviving female. Alkazar isn't exactly what Leela hoped for when she finds out he's a rude, demanding slob. However, she accepts his marriage proposal because she wants to keep the species alive. Meanwhile, Fry falls into the dungeon while trying to see what's in the forbidden zone.
The day of the wedding, Fry breaks out; he and Bender go see what's in the forbidden zone. They find four identical palaces, each more identical than the next! They go to one of the palaces and notice that instead of one-eyed statues and paintings, everything has five eyes. Just before Leela is about to say "I Do", Fry returns with some uninvited guest. There were four other alien women that Al was planning on marrying. It turns out Alkazar was a shape-shifter and had tricked all five women.