Game of Thrones

Season 2 Episode 6

The Old Gods and the New

50
Aired Sunday 9:00 PM May 06, 2012 on HBO
SUBMIT REVIEW

Episode Fan Reviews (9)

8.8
out of 10
Average
353 votes
  • The Old Gods

    6.5
    There were some dull parts in this one, but there was another strong, suspenseful ending and if they can keep this up every week they'll continue keeping me as a loyal fan.
  • Unnecessary small flaws can't prevent it from being this season's best episode yet

    9.0
    It's clearly best to watch "The Old Gods and the New" without knowing what to expect from it, so I won't get any specific with the plot and I'll limit myself to saying: it's awesome. The first Game of Thrones episode to be directed by Emmy winner David Nutter (who later went on to direct the undisputable #1 of all GoT episodes "The Rains of Castamere") is an important turning point in season two, as everything points in the direction of war due to the events in this episode.



    In the Winterfell story part, things start to go down right from the beginning. And that is actually my problem with it: that it happens right at the beginning. I'm convinced that I'm not alone with the opinion that the breathtaking intensity overshadowed the whole subsequent scene which is a well-written argument between Jon Snow and Qhorin Halfhand that should definitely not be overlooked. I'm being extra harsh on this subject and say that this is really bad editing because the Winterfell scene would've worked palpably better if used as the finale of an episode (either this one or the one before it). And while not as huge, the same applies for the King's Landing riots, however in this case, the next scene features Emilia Clarke even more feisty than usual and will gain your attention right away even if you can still hear your heart beating as a response to what just happened. But I guess I really can't judge too hard considering the vast amount of things happening, with a lot of them differentiating from the source novel quite a lot. And in this case, I have to say that I enjoyed the version of Benioff and Weiss more than George R. R. Martin's.



    Besides those two scenes, which genuinely affected me, I had two other favorite moments in "The Old Gods and the New": the great suspense that comes up when Lord Baelish visits Tywin Lannister at Harrenhal who, as we know, is not aware of having the youngest Stark daughter as his cupbearer, and what happens beyond the Wall after the aforementioned Jon Snow scene. Introducing Rose Leslie as a new guest cast member, we meet the wildling Ygritte who is able to lift up the show's sex appeal (yeah, that fairly diminished with Brienne of Tarth) even though she has like half a dozen layers of clothes on. The first scene with here features one of this episode's logical goofs, but I connived at that as well since what follows is an icy pursuit that is one of the simplest but also most entertaining action sequences in season two thus far. But topping anything else is the bedtime scene with Jon and Ygritte and what I reckon to be the show's loveliest love story initiates. Not on the same level, but still surprisingly adorable to watch was Robb Stark continuing his flirtation with field nurse Talisa (sex appeal still rising). In the meantime, Jaqen H'ghar climbs higher and higher on the ladder of Game of Thrones' most awesome characters and the climactic situation at Qarth reaches a new apex with a shocking crime.



    You see? The plot is really fascinating in this one and the small flaws can't ultimately mar the entertainment I had while watching "The Old Gods and the New". Outstanding performances by Sophie Turner (Sansa Stark), Peter Dinklage (Tyrion Lannister), Emilia Clarke (Daenerys Targaryen), and newbie Rose Leslie additionally help it to become this season's best episode yet.
  • A Lesson in Dishes Best Served Cold (Book and Show Spoilers to Follow)

    9.5
    A superior offering of Game of Thrones this week as we see Theon take Winterfell. He's clearly out of his depth in doing so. Luckily Maester Luwin was able to send off a raven to Robb Stark for aid though. The execution of Ser Rodrik may have gone against the books but did certainly offer a fitting end to his path as well as a fitting beginning to Theon's eventual fall. Osha really shone this episode proving duplicitous as can be and where her loyalties surely lie having to (gag) sleep with Theon to earn his trust and then killing that other Ironman in a moment of passion very brutal. A real scene stealer this week was Arya continuing her service as cupbearer to Tywin Lannister. As one of Tywin's flunkies Ser Amory Lorch screws up and accidentally sent troop movement messages to one of the Houses loyal to the Starks instead of his intended since he can't read. We also got a bit of a backstory from Jaime having to learn to read and how he is dyslexic. Catelyn returns to Robb's camp where he learns of Theon's betrayal and contemplates marching back North to retake Winterfell since a King needs to have his castle to be a King. He continues ogling the Lady who treats the wounded and the dead and Catelyn tells him that he can't follow his heart since he has taken up the crown and owes the Freys his hand of marriage. Arya, after stealing a message detailing Stark military movements, gets caught by Amory Lorch and he rushes to go tell Tywin. Arya manages to find Jaqen and tells him to kill Lorch and he does so in the nick of time. But now there is surely wind of an assassin in Harrenhal due to the dart found in his neck. In King's Landing while seeing Myrcella off to Dorne Cersei promises Tyrion that she will take someone dear to him in a very venomous Cersei-esque casual way as if she were talking about the weather. While on the way back to the Red Keep someone throws a cow pie at Joffrey and he orders all of the people executed which incites a riot. Many don't make it out alive. As the Lannister troops scramble to get Cersei and Joffrey and Tyrion away from the chaos many don't make it out. The High Septon is town limb from limb (literally) and Sansa gets engulfed in the crowd. Once they reach a safe haven Tyrion asks for Sansa and orders people to go find her. He also gives Joffrey a much needed pimp slap for being an idiotic king and a mad one. Sansa's almost rape scene made me rather squeamish since it didn't occur in the books but the Hound saving her was fitting since he did protect her in the book. The Hound telling Tyrion that he didn't do it for him shows that Clegane is indeed a force to be reckoned with and has his own agenda aside from protecting Joffrey. Jon and the other Rangers north of the wall look for Wildlings before night fall and find a small encampment and kill off the few wildlings there. But one turns out to a red headed woman and Jon says he'll deal with her on his own so Quorhin and the others leave him to it. The wildling's name is Ygritte and she gives Jon the slip almost but he chases her down but they get separated from the others. They agree to lie close to each other to stay warm but no fire so as to not attract any attention. She teases Jon with hip gyrations and she lies that she's not doing anything meaning that there is probably something there and she can lead them to Mance Rayder and his army. In Qarth Dany visits the richest merchants of the city and promises them triple repayment in exchange for ships. All of them say no especially the spice king who says that he markets in practical ways and not in promises although he does not doubt her intentions. Infuriated, and without Ser Jorah, she confides and speaks to Xaro about her needing to conquer the Seven Kingdoms but how can she do that without ships. He asks for marriage again and shows that he is most persistent. A twist is thrown in when they return to Xaro's estate though and she finds that most of her khalasar is dead and her dragons have been stolen but by whom we don't know. Very interesting change since it didn't happen in the books and the Mother of Dragons truly has nothing without her dragons and almost no khalasar she really is rendered powerless this season. Osha retreating with Bran and Rickon was a good "almost tricked us" kind of way that made us think she almost turned sides but her recognizing Bran's dream and trying to self preserve herself was very wildling of her. Also another really great scene was Littlefinger arriving in Harrenhal to talk to Tywin and their talk of Renly's passing and what needs to happen to win the war and how the Tyrells can be the key to their victory now that Renly is gone. Excellent offering and Peter Dinklage continues to astound with his superb take on Tyrion and hopefully will sweep another Emmy for the show's benefit. But sadly no Stannis or Davos this week but they got enough last week so I guess that's ok.
  • And welcome to King's Landing! We hope you enjoy your stay...

    9.0
    Season 2 of Game of Thrones has been a bit iffy when it comes to how the show relates to the book. Some people don't care about this. Some understand that the show doesn't have to copy the book word for word. Others, however, more notably the crazed book fanatics, get upset at any deviation from the books, only to tune in again next week.



    This episode is no different. As a matter of fact, I actually LIKE the changes they made from the books in this episode. Well, except for Jon's storyline, but in Qarth I thought stealing Dany's dragons was a great way to lead her to the climax of her story in the House of the [censored for spoilers]. Let's face it, Dany is extremely boring in Book 2 with nothing to do but get eaten by the sharks in Qarth. No badass Khal Drogo to guard her and no Viserys to treat her poorly. She shined in season 1. But in season 2 she is put on the backburner because season 2 is all about the war in Westeros.



    So making stuff up to make her story more intersting is actually better for the drama of the TV series. I like it. What I don't like is the changes they made to Jon. For him it all starts out fine. They raid the Wilding camp, some nice fight scene for a few seconds, and then Jon captures a wildling woman...but that's where it starts to change. In the book, Jon decides to be merciful and let her go. In the show...we don't know what the hell he's thinking. He swings the sword, but doesn't kill her. She runs away, but he follows with intent to kill her. He captures her, and still doesn't killer. WTF is he doing? Horrible scene in the show, awesome in the book. (Though Ygritte is pretty hot).



    The real meat of this episodes happens in King's Landing and Winterfell. King's Landing is total mayhem when a riot breaks loose thanks to Joffery deciding to kill a man for throwing a piece of cake at him. Seriously, if there's one change they should have made that they didn't, it's killing Joffery in this episode. Lol, I HATE him sooo much, he deserves a good spanking. Well, he got one, from Tyrion, (<3) but I think he should have gotten more than that.



    Winterfell, *** goes down. Theon comes out of nowhere, kills Ser Rodrik, takes the castle, and everything goes crazy from there. Osha shows of the goodies (she's hotter than I thought she would be) and womanizes Theon into bed, only to use her womanly powers to take Bran, RIckon, and Hodor out of the castle.



    One thing I am worried about, however, is the changes they are going to make to the Winterfell storyline.



    [Book Spoilers Ahead]



    Specifially with a character named Reek. Pretty sure Roose Bolton says his bastard at the Dreadfort can raise an army and retake Winterfell. In the book, this bastard Reek is in Winterfell already, and joins Theon. I really hope they don't ruin the huge twist at the end of the book in Winterfell like this. But we will see.



    [End Book Spoilers]



    Anyway, great episode. Some nice action scenes north of The Wall and in King's Landing, but the changes of the book bring this one down to a 9, as opposed to a 9.5. It's not that I'm such a fan of the book that ANY change is bad (again, I like Dany's change), but the changes happening in most of the storylines I just don't agree with. Arya being Tywin's cupbearer is a change that makes for some interesting scenes, but again, nothing too great. Dany's twist...well we'll see where that goes. Jon and Winterfell's changes gave this episode a grade less than the past two episodes, 4 and 5, which I consider the best of the season, but this too was great.



    Season 2 is now entering the final act. Tease for what I expect to happen next week: Arya will be more badass than ever with her final kill choice, Theon and "The Little Lord" will play Cat and Mouse, and King's Landing will try to recover from the unrest building inside. I cannot wait to see how they play out the final 4 episodes, which IMO will get better and better. (ESPECIALLY EPISODE 9)



  • The Old Gods and the New

    9.0
    The Good:

    -"Theon, did you hate us the whole time?"

    -"Strike hard and true, Jon Snow, or I'll come back and haunt you."

    -"...I want you to know what it's like to love someone, to truly love someone, before I take her from you."

    -"We've had vicious kings and we've had idiot kings, but I don't know if we've ever been cursed with a vicious idiot for a king."

    -"...Don't you understand? I'm no ordinary woman; my dreams come true."

    The Bad:

    -The show seems to be straying from the books more and more.
  • Out with the old...

    9.0
    There are some choice, killer scenes in this week's episode of GoT; some of the very literal, decapitation-y kind, while others reserved for verbal showdowns, ''The Old Gods and the New'' is yet another cracking offering from season 2.



    The hour begins with a light-hearted back and forth between...er, actually, we're very much in decapitation territory. Theon manages to fall even further into darkness, totally blind to his own incompetence, his words not getting him anywhere with anyone at casa Stark, bullied into taking action, ''the iron price''. Even though his actions are deplorable, and the fact he's about as noble as a hairy armpit, his character had been molded as a somewhat tragic, pathetic figure, that we kinda rooted for beforehand. And even after he wormishly hacks off sir what's-his-head's, er, head, we see a boyish part of him crumble under pressure and guilt. Having said that, he's still a total ass-hat and I very much look forward to bad things happening to him.



    Considering that was just the BEGINNING of the episode, it's fair to say that this was bracing stuff. And kinda weird. You know what I'm talking about. Yeah, that's right -- Tonk. Nekkid. I'll never watch Harry Potter the same way again.



    The character stuff this week was nothing short of perfection. Right down to the brief scene with Cersei threatening that one day she hopes Tyrion falls madly in love, just so she can snuff that away from him like he did her daughter. But it was the scenes involving Arya and Tywin Lannister that take home the gold this week. Their interaction is just SO damn good. She's the daughter he never had and he is the strong father-figure she is in desperate need of. When Lord Baelish entered the scene, things got very intense very quickly. Did he recognize her? My spider senses tell me yes. He'll either use this knowledge to his advantage with Cersei or else with Cat, to win back her affection. Or he'll manipulate them both for his own personal gain.



    I wasn't exactly thrilled by Dany's storyline this week, or this season, if I'm being honest. The teasing of her dragons can only carry her lack of, er, ANYTHING useful for so long. I mean, right now, she literally has nothing going for her (in terms of bartering with other characters and a storyline worth caring for): her people are dead and her dragons are gone. And what good is a subplot about dragons without dragons! Get 'em back, Dany. Grow 'em big. And kill the shit out of Geoffery. Thankyouplease.



    The little king that cried ''kill them all!'' is up to his classic tricks again. Fight cow dung with a massacre. I think we can all firmly agree that this was the best part of the episode, if only for the too brief a moment when Tyrion wallops him across the face. It was no 3-hit combo like last time, but it'll do. And poor Sansa! She's kind of like the Kenny of Westeros. She seems to come to harm every other episode! Thankfully, the Hound was about to gut her would-be rapists just in time. Good stuff!



    We got the most action we've seen from Jon Snow this week, as he shivers and grinds against a fiery red-head wildling. I don't have much to say on this really, but is Jon part wildling? Did I just ask a really stupid question? Oh look over there, is that Sansa getting hit? *flees*



    It's not like we witnessed another fully grown smoky, shadow demon claw its way out of a mad priestess' woowoo and kill a king in cold blood, or anything. So it wasn't THAT good. But in terms of character interaction, it was definitely on level with a smoky, demonic shadow BABY clawing its way out of a mad priestess' vajaja.
  • The Old Gods and the New

    10
    The Old Gods and the New was a perfect and superbly entertaining episode of Game of Thrones. I really enjoyed watching because the character depth and development were phenomenal and it was awesome to see how every thing played out. I liked that someone hit Joffrey with some sort of vegetable or fruit or maybe even horse dung, just kidding but that would have been hilarious! The actors all play their parts so well and the story lines really hold their own. I loved all aspects of this episode, every thing was done right, or as I would do it myself. I won't go into details but there was a lot of significant cues as to what lies ahead. It was awesome to see Bran escape with two Dire Wolves at the end leaving four in play all together. I was surprised that Ghost didn't find John as he was lost with a hostage. The scenes with Twyin and Arya were awesome and my heart raced as Lord Peter Balish entered the chamber. It was scary when Sansa was almost raped in the chaos following the riot toward King Joffrey, blah! I couldn't hardly believe what Theon did in Winterfell. I really feel for Daenerys after her Dragons are stolen. She is absolutely my favorite character and though I haven't read the books at this point I am rooting for her! I loved all of the development and the over all production of this episode. This episode was outstanding because it truly had a little bit of everything, and I certainly didn't mention it all. I look forward to watching what happens next!!!!!!!!!
  • A Romantic Comedy, Westeros style

    9.0
    And not a moment too soon, considering how nerve wracking was the execution of Ser Rodrik. If the audience ever forgot Bran and Rickon were only children, their desperate screams and cries remind us all that they are just kids, forced to witness their guardian being slain by a coward in front of them.



    In Game of Thrones, babies are the ones who suffer the most, from the youngest Starks to Daenerys's little dragons, taken from their mother's side with a nepharious purpose that includes to kill every Dothraki who stood in the way. Those children may not be human, but their screams were as human as Bran's or Rickon's and so was their mother's despair.



    Leave it to Arya to bring us from the darkest corners of Harrenhal to the emotional tone of a romantic comedy as she seeks Jaqen H'ghar to kill the next mark; a man must not be rushed, these things are all accomplished in due tim...Now! And Ser Armory Loch falls dead to the ground, just like that.



    And so, the set up for age appropiate Jon & Ygritte and Robb & Larisa began, with a timing that has nothing to envy to the best romantic comedies set in modern times, as antagonistic as Arya's scenes with Tywin Lannister, as poignant as Sansa's scenes with the Hound, as enjoyable as Tyrion scenes with Shae, Ned's Stark older boys start playing the only kind of game in which you only win by fall.
  • 2x06 "The Old Gods and the New"

    9.0
    Cliffhanger! Poor Dany... She doen't deseve that! Poor Starks... They dont deserve that! A lot of bad things are happening to good people and Joffrey's still alive.
Monday
No results found.
Tuesday
No results found.
More
Less