Episode Fan Reviews (15)

Write a Review
9.2
out of 10
Average: Superb
194 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate Now!
  • This is one of the best episodes of the season.

    10
    "Perfect"
    I was really happy with this episode. It was a great twist having Melinda be pregant. It really shocked me. It also really shocked me when at the end she wasn't pregnant anymore. It was interesting how once she didn't get to have the baby she actually seemed really sad. I was suprised that Delia's date didn't show up. I am expecting that that issue will be brought up again. It was a great cliffhanger involving Delia's life. I was really pleased about the light humor between Melinda and the Proffesor since the show in general is very serious. This relationship makes the show a little more light-hearted at times. This episode had a great plot.
  • Touching. The kind of episode I want to see

    10
    "Perfect"
    A ghost who keeps being reincarnated and doesn't want to be born again. Melinda definately had a challenge with this one. He didn't seem to know who he truly was. Melinda was getting really sick with this one. When I heard that she might be pregnant I was excited for her. The end of course was the best part of this show. Jim loves Melinda and would be proud to be the father of her children. She really needed him there for her. She was not pregnant in the end but she did manage to cross Eric over when he learned to really love and know what it means to do so. Especially when he said that he would come back to be her son because of her.
  • Melinda meets a ghost who seems to have multiple personalities and does not want to cross over.

    9.7
    "Superb"
    This was a very powerful and moving episode. Melinda tries to help a ghost who has been reincarnated at least 4 times, but he does not want help, nor does he want to be reincarnated again. The ghost, Eric, seems to be following Melinda's college friend, Holly, who is expecting and due any day. Eric says he will do anything he has to not to be born again. Holly is rushed to the hospital in labor. Melinda sees Eric in the operating room, but cannot go in. When Holly's little girl is born, Eric is still there to Melinda's surprise. Then she has a realization that Eric may be attached to her, to be reincarnated through her baby. Eric hears how Melinda and Jim will take care of him and love him and offers to stay, for her. Through this selfless act, Eric sees the light and his fathers. Melinda wants him to go to the light. Later at home, Melinda and Jim find out together that they are not pregnant and neither one knows how to feel about it. I cried like a baby myself.
  • This has to be the best and saddest episode yet!

    10
    "Perfect"
    OMG this yas to be the absolute best and saddest episode of Ghost Whisperer that they have every made. I absoulutely loved it. I have to say that I was crying the enire time. Like when Eric was going to go through one more life for Melinda. And then I was so happy when Melinda thought the was prenant and then once again at the end when the pregnancy test came back negative I was crying my eyes out. I also can't believe that Tim stood Delia up, he was so sweet at the beginning, how could he do that. If I could I would watch it over and over again, it was just so good and yet so sad.
  • Awsome Episode.

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode was soooo great I was cocnfused about Eric at first but then I was very happy when Melinda thought she was pregnant. Then I was sad when she wasent I thought that it was sweet at the end when Eric Said that he would come back to be her and Jim son.
  • Saddest episode so far.

    10
    "Perfect"
    WOW...that was such a great episode. I cried so much in this one. It was as sad as the finale. I mean at first we meet Eric, Mel wants to help him, and then there are suddenly 4 of them and everyone looks the same. We also meet a friend of Mel Holly, who is pregnant and Eric wants to hurt her. He should be reincarnated in Holly's baby and he don't want to because it'll be his 5th time and he's just too tired to live another live. He was quite unlucky in his "lives" but then Holly has a babygirl and that means Eric isn't reincarnated. After that Mel finds out Eric is supposed to reborn as Mel and Jim's child. She thinks she's pregnant but in the end we learn that she's not pregnant. That would be so great if she was but...a reall GREAT Episode. CBS keep it up like this:)
  • I loved this episode! It's the saddest episode so far!!

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode was so sad! I wanted Melinda and Jim to have a baby.

    I think they will be great parents. They are a great couple and they treat each other so well. It was sad that Mel wasn't pregnant and when the spirit of Eric crossed over that was sad too. I liked how he said that he would go through another life for her and Jim but she told him to go. To cross over and be at peace. To be with his family on the other side. All five families.

    I hope Mel and Jim have a baby soon and yup I just love this episode and wanted to comment on it!!
  • I think this was one of the most moving episodes so far...

    9.1
    "Superb"
    In this episode we touch briefly on the subject of Jim and Melinda having a child. I'm amazed by Jennifer's acting. Her tears always are for real. That said, this was one of the most moving, Delia being left at the theatre with no date and the chance that Melinda might have the reincarnated baby. I am happy that the Professor is in it more and more. I like his character very much. He is fun and I'll be interested to see how his character grows. Payne and Melinda work well together. Although how he comes to know so much about that which he cannot see is beyond me! It's all in his books, obviously!
  • This is the best episode ever. (Spoilers)

    10
    "Perfect"
    Oh My God this episode is so amazing its by far the best yet i was crying the whole time. ive watched this episode like 4 times now an I love it so much. David Rogers who plays Eric (And Johnny, Oscar And Richard) is a really good actor and plays Eric and the others so well. The end was really sweet and sad when Eric says that he will go through another life for Melinda to be her and Jim's child. And i can't believe that Tim stood up Delia he seemed so nice i hope he has a good reason.
  • Absolutely incredible!

    10
    "Perfect"
    This was just a sensational episode of Ghost Whisperer, in my opinion, and it was also very emotional and quite sad. The episode certainly was very powerful, and I was quite cpaptivated throughout it.



    The storyline behind this one was accurate and very well written, and the story was easy to follow, while still being exceptional and intensely powerful.



    The case that Melinda was working on certainly did get weird at various points, but I think that everything was well explained, and I highly enjoyed it.



    I would highly recommend this episode, and this is one of my favorite episodes that I have seen!
  • I was actually glad melinda wasnt pregnant, because, seriously, i love this show, and if she was pregnant, they would have 2 act like she is pregnant and who would watch a show seeing a big pregnant girl running around seeing dead people. great episode.

    10
    "Perfect"
    Melinda is very inspiring and she thinks she is pregnant. This is a very good episode and i think it is the best soo far of the season. but im sure the season finale will be the best. Im glad she wasnt pregnant because it would probably make the viewers not view anymore. lol. but anyways i love htis show and you should watch all the episodes. Jennifer Love Hewitt is the perfect role for Ghost WHisperer. I miss andrea being on the show but the replacement is good. Not as good, but good. Lol, but I will give the show a 9.8, because its such a good show.
  • This episode was really painful to watch because I wanted Melinda to be pregnant and then that Tim guy stood up Delia

    9.8
    "Superb"
    This episode reminded me exactly why I Tivo Ghost Whisperer every week. This is really one of CBS\'s best series and doesn\'t get the credit and recognition it deserved. This was probably one of the best, if not my favorite episodes, since the series began last year. It was really one of those episodes that really made me want to reach out and comfort Melinda and Jim, when her pregnancy test came back negative and do the same for Delia when she was stood up on her date.Because I\'ve said for a while now that I really like the character (and Melinda really needs someone since Andrea died)and I think Delia deserves more story line.



    Overall amazing episode A+ -r.d.w.
  • Melinda thought she was pregnant.

    9.8
    "Superb"
    So that was probably one of my favorite episodes EVER!! I can\'t believe she isn\'t pregnant!! That made me SO mad!! Though she was really sweet at the end. And she was REALLY upset when the test came out negative, I think she was frightend about having a child, but I think she was more happy than sad, so I think in the upcoming episode \"The Cradle Will Rock\" it\'s going to be about her bein ready to have a child, nd I am SO happy, and I love how Jim is supportive of what she wants to do, and I love the whole romance of this episode. So I think it\'s only a matter of time before she does get pregnant.
  • Aw damn! Melinda isn't pregnant!!!

    9.4
    "Superb"
    How can they do this?!



    I was so sure and sooo happy that Melinda was pregnant!

    How can she not be?!

    Now i sooo sad for Jim, i mean he always has to be the supportive husband/ the understanding one/ the coping one/ he always has to be there for Melinda... when is she going to start being there for him?

    He soo much wants to have a child with her; he would follow her to the ends of the earth, i just think he is too much of a good guy/husband, and this episode once again proves that he gives and he gives...and Melinda just takes and takes!
  • Melinda and Jim had a negative pregnacy test!

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode was to me one of the best episodes of the season thus far. I loved every part of it.



    Delia and Tim: I like that she decided to open herself up to someone else and that she made the effort to move forward. However, I dont like the fact that Tim didnt show for the theater date.



    Melinda and Jim: I loved...loved the fact that the writers made it seem like Eric would be their son and that Melinda was finally pregnant. I personally was thinking that the writing on jim\'s back had something to do with their baby...i guess we have to wait and see about that one. Overall this was such a well written episode. I cant wait for the next episode!
More
Less