Episode Fan Reviews (13)

Write a Review
9.3
out of 10
Average: Superb
187 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate Now!
  • This one was great, what an ending, those arms!!

    9.6
    "Superb"
    This one starts at a movie session, a guy falls down a Jim helps him, meanwhile Melinda sees a ghost after him, a woman, Colleen.

    It appears to be a stalker case, she is stalking him. His name is Shane and he is an attorney, Melinda talks to him and offers to help. Colleen died by falling down the stairs and breaking her neck.



    Along the episode the things change...



    It turns out that Colleen was the one being stalked, Shane was following her, he pushed everyone out of her life. The only person left was a detective who she asked for help, Campbell.

    Meanwhile, Shane finds another woman to spy, Melinda. He tries to do the same things, messes with Delia, makes a call so Jim isn't home and breaks in. When Melinda got home he was outside and the house had a romantic mood. All the phones were out. Jimmy realized it and run home.

    Then Melinda and Colleen teamed up to take Shane down. It's revenge time!!!.

    They steal some files from his computer and send them to his partners at the firm. Everyone found out who he was... They are free.



    The only but is that he killed himself so when Delia leaves and Melinda goes to the basement to find something, he is there. Jim calls but she already knew. He started to walk towards Melinda but two arms came out the wall and grabbed him. She is safe.



    I think it was her father...lets wait to see
  • Omg...what an ep! You really need to get up the nerve if you want to watch it!

    10
    "Perfect"
    Well...what can I say? It was so scary! I mean I think the most episodes are creepy but this one, this one was especially nerve-wracking! It started all well...Mel and Jim go out, they meet a guy, Shane who is stalked by his dead "girlfriend", Mel sees her and wants to help! But then Melinda discovers the truth behind this "nice" Shane...not like they assumed before...not Colleen is the stalker, Shane is! And he even took photos of her body when Colleen fell down those stairs, and hung them up at his office!



    And this part when Mel comes home and thinks Jim made a romantic dinner and stuff and learns that it was Shane and sees him standing outside and he tells her Jim won't come home...I was freaking out! Really...I was almost shaking...it creeped me out so much! Then Mel grabed this big knife to protect herself in case Shane comes in...OMG...it was so scary! Thank god Jim realized that the phone line was dead and rushed home and came on time! When Mel started to cry I wanted to cry too, because I felt so sorry for her!:(



    Delia was great in this episode...though Shane caused many problems for her she was still on Mel's side!:)



    And the end...I really want to know who "saved" Mel from this stalker-ghost...her dad? or maybe someone completely different?



    STAY TUNED!:)
  • This was an intense episode lots of suspense had me wondering what would happen next. First off let me say this episode broke the help the ghost of the week mode. Here just getting the answer to the ghost hanging around wasn't

    9.0
    "Superb"
    This was an intense episode lots of suspense had me wondering what would happen next. First off let me say this episode broke the help the ghost of the week mode. Here just getting the answer to the ghost hanging around wasn't enough. Next Melinda had a flesh and blood threat that was way worse than anything the ghost had to offer. To top things off they ended the show with what appeared to be the ghost saving Melinda but may have been them just building more power for an attack. Good episode top notch to convince anyone to give the show a chance.
  • So awesome!

    10
    "Perfect"
    I loved this eppy so much!! It was so suspenseful when Shane was all around Melinda's house! It was about a woman, Colleen, who was killed, and she had a connection to this guy, Shane. Shane said Colleen was a stalker and really weird. Melinda goes to learn more about her so she goes to her apartment and finds restraining orders against Shane! Shane was the stalker! So then Shane starts to stalk Melinda and follows her to work and even tries to get Deliah mad at her, and the cops can't do anything bc he is a lawyer and they have nothing to get him with. So Melinda goes to Colleen, the victim, for help and they get the info from his labtop! They get him, and Melinda tells the cop friend, Campbell, who Colleen liked, about everything, and Colleen crosses over I assume since they didn't show it. But then, Shane, who was in jail, overdoces! And now he is stalking Melinda again! But then some arms come out of the wall and grab Shane and pull him downwards. Creepy episode, but it was great! 10/10
  • Amazing episode!!!!!!A great dose of adventureness too!!!!

    10
    "Perfect"
    Wow this episode was GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!I loved having more of a mystery episode where you were always wondering what was going to happen next. JLH did a great job on this episode especially when Shane was in her house-well sort of. There were more Jim and Mel moments too which is good. OMG I loved when Jim came rushing back for Mel after he realized what Shane had done and then Mel sort of collapsed into his arms and YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY NO PAYNE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I thought it was absolutely hilarious when Mel went into Shane's office acting like she was going out with Shane and had left a little "something" behind I was LMAO!!!!!!!!!!! I kinda wished the ghosts from "below" didn't drag Shane away I think it would've been better for him to stay at least one more episode but it was still a great episode!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Great episode. Better than some of the past storylines that we've seen.

    9.1
    "Superb"
    I for one enjoyed many aspects of this episode. I find myself enjoying the suspense of the show lately and this episode did not fall short. I was on the edge of my seat wondering what was going to happen next. Overall, I really liked how it turned out in the end, especially the last few scenes. I really liked the fact that the ghost was helping Melinda and not just her helping the ghost. But I must confess that the ride to these scenes was not as smooth as it could have been. I guess this is what was intended, but within minutes I hated Shane's character. After less than a minute, Colleen's neck-cracking started bugging me. I thought that they were supposed to be a pure soul or something, yet she had this physical ailment. I mean, yes other ghosts have had some sort of problem (like naked man..lol) but I just can't think of any that have had a "physical" problem. I think this episode was definitely supposed to show us that Melinda isn't all tears and kindness and helping others, she has another side to her that is strong and independent and willing to take control when need be. She is definitely alot stronger than people give her credit for. I think it's been so long since we've seen that side of her, that some have forgotten that it was even there. Overall, I have to say that I liked the episode, even if I'm being a bit critical of it. It was good, and I hope to see more episodes like this one. ~518~H~E~A~V~E~N~
  • This episode was extreamly scary!!

    9.3
    "Superb"
    This episode I think was the scariest in the whole series! After i watched this episode I kept looking behind me to make sure there wasn't anybody there! i really enjoyed the Mel and Jim scenes. My favorite scene was when the stalker came to Mel and Jim's house and tried to come in and Jim came home right in time and saved her. I really enjoyed how Melinda and the ghost proved that he was a stalker and got him fired from his job and everything else. At first i was confused when the stalker was in the basement and then I was like OMG he is dead! I did not see that coming. Oh and also at the end were he was reaching out for Melinda i was like OMG and then those arms sucked him in! WOW it was crazy! I wounder who's arms that was that sucked him in and I wonder what happened to the stalker!
  • A man with a stalking past.

    8.9
    "Great"
    Melinda must help a ghost that even in death seems terrified of the man who stalked her in life. She also had a crush on the police detective who stood by her during all the stalking. For a bit I wondered if the detective was repsonisble for the death but he seemed too kind hearted. The coolest part of the show was the ending when the stalker, who now favors Melinda commits suicide to be with her by haunting her! As he approaches her, hands come out of nowhere and take him through the wall! It was creepy and cool!
  • Melinda tries to help a ghost (Coleen) who was stalked by her boss Shane. Melinda tries to help but Shane starts to stalk her.Melinda tries to stop him but Shane keeps coming back. When Melinda stops him he tries to stalk her in a more permanant way.

    10
    "Perfect"
    A brillient and excieting episode I've watched 100 times. This is probably my second favourite Ghost Whisperer episode. (First being "Love Never dies".)This episode kept me stuck to the couch and its probably the reason I bought Ghost Whisperer season 3. I hope another episode can live up to this one. The episode was Scary, Funny, Exciting, Suspenceful (i think?). The acting by Jenniffer Love Hewitt was so beliveable. Not like sometimes (no offence). But the greatest part no doubt was when Melinda asked the receptionist can she go in and Shanes face once he realised he was caught. But I cant't help thinking the writers didnt get enough out of Shane. I hope they someday have a Melinda vs. Shane Rematch



    10/10
  • Wow! Perhaps the best one that I have seen!

    10
    "Perfect"
    This amazing episode was quite simply perfect. It was flawless. It was so intense, so interesting, and it was quite frightening as well.



    I really enjoyed the storyline. They wrote it very well, and I think it was perhaps the best one I have seen. It was highly gripping, and I was captivated with every single moment.



    I thought it was so good, and I think that this hwhole show it just great! I would highy recommend this show, and partticularly this episode. Such as this episode was, the whole show is amazing!



    I would highly recommend this particular episode because it was suspenseful, intriguing and highly suspenseful! It was very frightening, and I can't wait for the next one! Keep it up, Ghost Whisperer!
  • How nice….Melinda paired with the ghost to seek for revenges!

    10
    "Perfect"
    I really love to see Melinda worked with the ghost to get revenges and finally got the bad guy into the justice. I really wish to see some episode like this again. Eventually, this episode surely proved that human is more scary and dangerous than ghosts. We used to see Melinda faces all her ghosts' problems with no fear but this time was different. Shane Carson, The stalker attorney was extremely frightening to her, even the ghost was also afraid of him (sometimes).



    The show did a very good job at the end. Bad people should be dragged into miseries (if the laws could not directly hurt them).



    I hope that Shane Carson went straightly to hell and could not come back to hurt or cause any problems to Melinda again.
  • Nice change of pace...

    10
    "Perfect"
    "No Safe Place" is dead on, I actually felt nerved racked while watching. which is unusually cause I never feel that watching Ghost Whisperer. Possibly due to the fact Mel would always be safe for another day, but this episode really twisted it up with a living stalker.



    The acting was all across excellent, Jen truly felt Emmy nom worthy. I am still astonished at how such a simple storyline has become one of the series strongest. Adding the fact that it was also a tie-in into the over arch mythology of "Dark Spirits." I wonder who pulled Shane away, Mel's father? Or possibly that red-eyed ghost underground? Guess we will find out next week!



    The lack of Payne was rather a breath of fresh air, no offense but he takes a lot of the actual suspense from an episode. Not that he was not a great addition to the series but once in awhile it is nice to have things changed up a bit. I did however like seeing Jim around, in a way his character was put to a means rather then someone for Mel to lean on, which he still was but with a backbone. Delia, also nice to see. Who actually showed more of her defensive side towards aiding Mel, defiant plus on character growth from skeptical Delia in "Delia's First Ghost."



    Overall, a much recommendation from myself to any other that would like to get into Ghost Whisperer.
  • Wow! What a great ending!

    10
    "Perfect"
    This was a terrific episode. Scary. Twists and turns. One of the turns was Melinda first telling the ghost that she needed to leave the revenge behind and go to the light. Well then Melinda started getting stalked, and she no longer wanted the ghost to just leave the revenge behind any more. That made me laugh. The episodes this season have been somewhat lighter and back to the way they were in season one. The difference is though that they are somewhat scarier this season than the first season. This episode certainly was. I loved it and highly recommend this episode.
More
Less