Episode Fan Reviews (18)

Write a Review
9.3
out of 10
Average: Superb
246 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate Now!
  • So... lots of 10s, huh?

    4.5
    "Poor"
    Come on.



    Really, guys, come on.



    I mean, I can see how this series has an audience. There are juicy bouncy bits all over the place, and the half-baked modern pop supernatural mythology does have a fan base.



    But 10? The climax of the whole episode is a big Deus ex Machina, the final revelation comes from nowhere and characters change sides for no reason whatsoever.



    The main character is so stupid that can't think to text her husband when her cel connection drops, which would have solved the issue. And I was only thinking about that because I couldn't care less about the fate of the kids she was supposed to protect. Maybe because they didn't have any dialogue, but rather a series of statements of their problems which were completely out of character.



    But, hey, maybe I'm wrong. Maybe it's a 10.



    The problem with reader reviews is they're made by fans for fans. How this got 10s and Lost's last few seasons received complaints from fans I honestly can't understand. Let's at least acknowledge care and production values, even if we're in denial about the merits of the product. Let's at least stay around 9.5 instead of claiming the episode is a perfect gem of storytelling. It is not.
  • Loved this episode!

    10
    "Perfect"
    After waiting THREE weeks for the finale I was trying to remember what happened.

    It didn't take long though. At the start I was confused by the kids but then I started figuring it out! And I think Gabrelle following Delia all that time was to distract Melinda from what she should of been focusing on...obiously!! I can't believe, I mean hey I'm just guessing here but I think Gabrelle is Melinda's brother and what was up with her Dad? Saying "No" when the kids brought her back to life? I thought he would of been happy but I saw it coming, her coming back to life I mean! What would they do with Ghost Whisperer without Melinda?

    I can't wait till next season!
  • I really thought she died!

    10
    "Perfect"
    I'm really glad the children were able to bring Melinda back to life. I know something special was up with those kids, but to bring people back from death I didn't see coming. That is really awesome. But Melinda saw her father and he told her about an unknown brother of hers. She watches Gabriel, is he really her brother. How did that happen. Is she the good one and he the bad one. Was it to bring balance into the world, Melinda as Gods helper and Gabriel as the devils? This was a well written ending for season two! Loved it!
  • Was about Melinda finding the fith sence...

    10
    "Perfect"
    Wawh ... the show was amazing. I thought that somthing would happend to Dehlia or Jim but not to Mel.Than kind of shocked me, but good writing. And the drawing that the Children drew.. Thant was kind of cool but freaky... And the message from the mans wife.. that was a litle puzzel but as allways that was figured out. ........I thoght that the show was an exitemennt til the end and I just cant wait ti September 28... Itwill be an exelennt show.. And than we will se wat is going to happend with the ghost's..



    The Underneath ..!



    28th september
  • omg i love it so much

    10
    "Perfect"
    wow this episode is so amazing i just cant believe it, it is so gd i cnt wait 2 find out what happens next season what a brilliant way 2 finish the season i bet this has got everybody really looking forward 2 the next season i no i am lol. This is a really well written episode and all the actors in it are amazing i love them all
  • OMG what an amazing episode.

    10
    "Perfect"
    I loved this episode by far! it took a wee while to get into it but once you were it was amazing in my opinion. I liked the writers trying to trick us into believing that Delia was 'death of a loved one' and it acctually was Melinda. I kinda of saw it coming though. As the writing was on Jim's back which meant death of a loved one for him. I found that cleaver. The last half hour though was breath taking so much drama to take in, in so little time , I loved it. Melinda died, saw her father , found out she had a brother, came back to life! I mean woohoo a lotof information to take in. So her dad is dead, he kinda seems evil to me and also hinting that Gabriel is her brother! that its self has many question within it. But over all I loved it and cannot wait until the third season to find out the answers.
  • Omg...I thought it will be Jim or her mom...But I never exected Mel to die...Thank god the kids were there and saved her...BUT THE MOST EXCITIN' THING IS: SHE HAVE A BROTHER!!!O_o

    10
    "Perfect"
    Oh yeah...I loved this ep so much...When I saw that only 4 mins were left and Mels still dead I couldn't move from my seat...It shocked me so much!! And poor Jimmy...he was so worried!!!The writers did it really clever...A lighning!! Really good idea.I thought they kill Mel and don't make another season one time but they make another season and I'm very very happy about it...
  • OMG! I didn't love it, but did enjoy it! A LOT!

    8.0
    "Great"
    Is not my favorite ep, but i got to confess... i so did not coming that end!



    I always thought Jim was going to be the next sign! I thought he was going to die! So to me it was a surprise!



    And now we all have this thing! This curiosity to know what's going to happen! For sure i'll be watching the new season.



    Is it true that Melinda will get a romance? Not really, but something to ruin their relationship??



    Well, let's wait and see!
  • Oaky...I obviously don't quite agree with anyone else. I hated this episode. It was slow and jerky. The surprises were straight out of the soap opera handbook and at least one thing is just plain is disgusting.

    6.0
    "Fair"
    Oaky...I obviously don't quite agree with anyone else. I hated this episode. It was slow and jerky. The surprises were straight out of the soap opera handbook.



    Yeah, Melinda dies. Big Whoop. She didn't stay that way for more than a couple of minutes. Melinda has a brother. The only whoop is that her brother hit on her (was it only last episode when Gabriel told her to leave Jim and go with Him?). That's just gross.



    Clearing up the issues is just a visit to her annoying mother. Now, her mother will beat around the bush and whine about her headaches, and then not tell Melinda anything for a while. Then, suddenly, she'll show up at the doorstep and reveal all. I hope it doesn't surprise anyone.



    So, will someone please explain to me, why was this a world shattering event? I was expecting Night of the Living Dead, or some big cataclysm. Instead, a phallic/cross symbol for the spirit world was hit with lightening and Melinda sacrificed herself for some dopey kids. Next episode, the ghost of Fonzi comes back and has to jump over a pen of sharks to go into the light, or Gabriel and Wide Brim will take over the world.
  • This was a Good Episode Actually it was Above Good, but below great

    9.5
    "Superb"
    Things seem to happen like you would expect it.



    Seems to me like the guys and gals sitting down came up with a script out of there first attempt, i admit that i too came up with the same idea's and knew pretty much what was gonna happen.



    But the Brother thing was a great twist, and maybe it was about time that melinda had an opponent that really can test her...



    Looking forward to Season 3, and my Girlfriend may need a few more tissues.



    Marc
  • whoa...what a season finale! There almost got me...for a minute there i actually thought that they were going to kill Melinda, and next season would be about her helping the dead cross over as a dead herself! What great writing!

    9.6
    "Superb"
    Melinda: It wasn't about me protecting them. It was about them protecting me.



    Jim: What happened?



    Melinda: I think I have a brother.



    Jim: What?



    Melinda: I .. I think I have a brother.



    Jim: Mel, what are you talking about?



    Melinda: He said I have a brother.



    Jim: Who said this? Who told you you had a brother?



    Melinda: My father.



    wow! you know before this episode i never thought about Melinda's father...must less brother! Unbelievable! She has a brother...and is a mere coincidence that around the same time she finds out that she has a brother, she meets a guy(Gabriel) that shares her abilities?



    One thing is for sure....i can't wait until next season!!!
  • All I can say is WOW!!

    9.7
    "Superb"
    This was such a great episode. I can't believe we have to wait tell fall to see season 3 but at least they got renewed! Anyways back to the episode if you haven't seen the episode you proubly don't want to read the rest of this because I might give big things away. I can't believe that Melinda died then came back after this guy said that she has a brother and then Melinda waking up and saying that her father was saying all of those things man to much for me to handle. I can't wait to find out what happens and I'm glad no one died!
  • I loved this episode, it was one of the best so far and a great season finale.

    10
    "Perfect"
    Ok the main word that describes the episode is "wow" I mean seriously, I did not expect the ending. (spoilers coming ahead) I had pretty much figured that Kirsten would be the "gifted kid" from last years accident and that her father would appear in teh finale, but I was in totaly shock about her having a borhter. I mean seriously, completely out of no where! I also had suspisions about her dieing, but the way they did it was so sad. I was practically crying when Kristen was saying that that was her vision and she was sorry, and the look on Jim's face made me cry even more. I really loved the episode and I am so glad that we get another season, this just helps to prove that I can't live without my Ghost Whisperer every friday.
  • Great Finale!!

    10
    "Perfect"
    Unfortunately, I have only been watching this show since mid-season of Season 2 and completely hooked ever since. I definately have alot of catching up to do. I love the twist and turns of each episode that keeps you guessing until the very end. I can't wait until Season 3, in the meantime I have to go out and find Season 1 in order to get caught up.



    I wonder what is Melinda's dark side abilities that her father mentioned and what she will do with her crazy and evil brother?



    Great season finale and I will continue to be a loyal viewer.
  • Oh Melinda…You’ve got a “Brother”!

    9.0
    "Superb"
    It was not like I expected. Death of the Love One did not mean Jim or Delia but Melinda herself. Anyway, I'm glad that she came back and none of the main characters died like in the first season.



    It was good to see Delia more open with Melinda’s gift. Hopefully, she could help Melinda more in the third season since Professor Payne might be on sabbatical. Surprise! Melinda has a brother! How could it possible? After watching this show for two years, I always thought Melinda’s gift came from her mother’s family only. But this episode made me wondered, maybe Melinda’s father also had something to do with it. Too bad that we have to carry on our curiosities until the next season!....Can’t wait!
  • Great example!

    9.3
    "Superb"
    Melinda indeed comes and saves the day with her ghost

    Abilities as she is on a mission to help missing

    Children all in the meanwhile why she tries to stop the

    Mayor of the town from having a dedication. Also a male

    Ghost is trying to prevent her from doing good things but

    You know she will come out on top!
  • Revealing episode

    9.9
    "Superb"
    I really really enjoyed this episode although i don't think it was as good as the first season finale..the Andrea twist was incredible, I still miss her character so much :(. I thought the plot twist this finale was pretty good. I always wondered when her dad was going to come into play with it..and now Richard. woah. lol Wonder when her mum will come back into it. It'll be interesting to see where they take it in season 3. wow season 3? that word has come around so quickly, I remember it like yesterday watching the pilot episode. haha. Great show.
  • Can't freaking wait till fall.

    10
    "Perfect"
    Oh damn, this was good. I have to admit the beginning was a bit slow but it improved quite fast, and I am not saying that the beginning was boring, in fact, it was quite interesting though.



    I can't think clearly, yet, but oh my god!



    The girl from last year's finale! Melinda herself being the one ending up dead!!!!! That came as quite the shock, wow. Awesome. And it was such an awesome idea, so we actually saw it from the point of view of the ghosts. O_o And um, huh? Melinda has a brother? Her father is dead -- and apparently -- evil? Or isn't he? Seemed like he was blocking the lights...he wasn't the brim man from the season one finale, was he? Mhhh omg. So many questions. Who's Mel's brother? Gabriel? I think they made us think it's Gabriel just so make a twist next season...but it would all make sense with Gabriel is her brothers... with the balance-thing and all...arghs. Thinking about it gives me headache.



    I'm so so so glad that neither Jim, Delia nor Payne ended up dead *omg sighing relieved*



    How does it come that Melinda didn't know anything about having a brother? Another question. Arghs!



    I was seriously getting a bit teary when Mel said that she's not ready yet and just thinking about how terrible Jim and Payne will feel and how much she will miss her husband and omg :( Though, I would have found it amazing when they wouldn't have revived her before next season and seeing some episodes (or at least one) out of the point of view from the dead Melinda. But I am also satisfied with this cliffhanger and having her revived before the episode ends.



    What else wanted her father to tell her? Arghs. Can't freaking wait till fall. O_o
More
Less