A Tale of Poes and Fire

Season 3, Episode 17, Aired
EDIT

Episode Summary

The Independence Inn hosts a gathering of the Edgar Allan Poe Society, but a fire forces Lorelai to relocate the guests to her own house and those of her friends, and leaves her spending the night at Luke's, where she reveals a previously secret dream. Sookie and her staff invade Luke's to prepare breakfast, and gets into a culinary groove with Luke after a rocky start. Questions arise about Jess' attendance at school when he becomes Wal-Mart's Employee of the Month and Luke discovers he's working overtime. Lorelai and Rory start picking up on unfriendly vibes from Nicole and Lindsay. Rory visits Paris, who is hiding from the world, and prompts her to rejoin the land of the living. Invited to inspect the damage to the inn, Lorelai discovers it is far worse than she had believed. After making extensive pro-con lists in an effort to decide whether to attend Harvard, Yale, or Princeton, Rory has a heart-to-heart with Lorelai and chooses Yale.moreless
9.3
out of 10
EPISODE RATING: Superb
259 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate It
  • A fire at the inn forces Lorelai to put the quests up in at the Gilmore house. A brilliant episode, the end was shocking ... what will happen now?

    9.8
    "Superb"
    I wasn't expect the inn to be that badly damaged, I wonder what they'll do about it. I thought it was a good way to bring certain characters together, Luke and Lorelai, Sookie and Luke. Them cooking together was great, we've never seen them bond before. Lorelai told Luke about her dream from the start of the season, they have great chemistry.

    Rory having three college choices was good and it was nice to see Lorelai respect whatever she wanted which is obviously Yale, liked the end when Lorelai had done up the wall with Yale stuff and the Kirk t-shirt. I'm sure Richard will be thrilled.

    As for Paris, she'll get in somewhere else no doubt, what Rory said to her was nice and I'm glad there friendship is remaining strong. Funny how she was watching the soaps 'I don't deserve general hospital!'. Jess being the employee of the month was funny, especially how Luke reacted. I doubt he is going to school, he isn't very convincing.

    Babette and Miss Patty were funny, when Patty was answering the phones, hilarious. Plus Babtette messing with the computer. The fake boyfriend of Lane is perhaps falling for her, should be interesting. Lindsey is being a bit harsh, I mean Rory is being nice to her. How good was it that Luke spoke about Lorelai on his first date with Nicole.

    This was a brilliant episode, very sad that the inn basically burned down but we did found out about Rory's college!moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    1 0
  • Definitely a classic! A must see!

    9.7
    "Superb"
    This is one of those episodes where you can just watch it over and over again without getting bored. There is plenty of Luke and Lorelai, Rory and Lorelai, Rory and Jess, Rory and Lane, seeing all of the townspeople, etc, etc. My favorite part of this episode has to be when Lorelai has to spend the night at Luke's place. It's so awkwardly amazing. You can really see their romance blooming. There are also many funny parts in this episode. Rory and the sock puppets, for example. But don't take my word for it - watch this episode! You won't be disappointed.moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    1 0
  • This is sad...

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode started well...
    Rory got accepted in Harvard, Yale and Princeton and now they are doing Pro and Con list to decide which school she is choosing...
    Jess is employee of the month...
    The Poe society is staying at the inn and everything is going well. Those looks to Lorelai and Rory from Dean and Luke's dates were cold lol, they are so jealous lol

    There is a fire at the inn and Lorelai needs to put plan B in action: create a new inn with phones and internet, provide meals for the guest and accommodation.

    Here is when you see the beauty of a small town, people know each other and they offer to help Lorelai and Sookie. It's great.

    They manage to find everyone a place to stay, Lorelai is the only one without a bed lol thank God for Luke...

    The thing I like most in this episode is the help, the fact that everyone contribute to arrange space for the guests and they didn't complained...

    When Lorelai slept at Luke's, she told him that dream she had where they were married, expecting a baby and all... That was sweet. At the kiss part she froze up...I wish they were together....

    Oh and the decision is made, Rory is going to Yale.
    I've seen more advanced episodes and with all the Harvard talk I didn't understand how she ended up in Yale but now I know.

    The inn is a wreck... the fire did a lot of damaged. I thought it would be OK, they would get the things out, open it that day and everything would get back to normal...

    Guess not, they have to start from scratch...moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    0 0
  • Rory has a choice to pick a college to go to.

    10
    "Perfect"
    Rory has got accepted to 3 different school of her choice. Harvard, Princeton and Yale. So she sits down and writes pros and cons for each university. In the end her mom tells her that she would like her to go to Yale and that is the school Rory wants to go to as well. Jess wins Employee of the Month at Wal-Mart and Luke goes to his award ceremony and his boss talks to him and makes Luke suspect that Jess is working a 40-hour week and not going to school. Lorelai's inn catches on fire and so they have to find rooms for all their guest until they can get all their stuff out of the Inn. This leaves Lorelai and Rory without a place to sleep so Rory sleeps at Lanes and Lorelai crashes at Lukes. She tells him about a dream that she had. They were married and she was having twins. End of episode.moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    0 0
  • Rory has a choice to pick a college to go to.

    10
    "Perfect"
    Rory has got accepted to 3 different school of her choice. Harvard, Princeton and Yale. So she sits down and writes pros and cons for each university. In the end her mom tells her that she would like her to go to Yale and that is the school Rory wants to go to as well. Jess wins Employee of the Month at Wal-Mart and Luke goes to his award ceremony and his boss talks to him and makes Luke suspect that Jess is working a 40-hour week and not going to school. Lorelai's inn catches on fire and so they have to find rooms for all their guest until they can get all their stuff out of the Inn. This leaves Lorelai and Rory without a place to sleep so Rory sleeps at Lanes and Lorelai crashes at Lukes. She tells him about a dream that she had. They were married and she was having twins. End of episode.moreless

    DO YOU AGREE?

    0 0

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

See All
  • Trivia

    ADD TRIVIA
    • When Lorelai tells Luke about the dream from episode 1 of this season, "Those Lazy-Crazy-Hazy Days", he asks if they were married. She tells him yes, however, in the dream you can clearly see that she's not wearing a ring. Edit
    • We learn that Rory is going to Yale. Edit
    • Lorelai tells Luke about the dream she had about him in "Those Lazy-Hazy-Crazy Days." Edit
  • Notes

    ADD NOTES
    • German episode title: "In Schutt und Asche", meaning "In Ruins". French episode title: "Le Corbeau Et L'Incendie", meaning "The Crow And The Fire". Edit
    • Kelly Bishop (Emily) and Edward Herrmann (Richard) do not appear in this episode. Edit
    • The shirts Kirk made in this episode bear a close resemblance to the black shirts with the words 'a film by Kirk' written in lower-case white letters which were created by some Gilmore Girls' fans on the net after "Teach Me Tonight" aired. Edit
  • Quotes

    ADD QUOTES
    • Lorelai: Ooh, sorry, I have to get up super early tomorrow. Luke: No problem. What time? Lorelai: Six. Luke: I get up at quarter to five every morning. Lorelai: Why in the world would you get up that early? Luke: I don't know, to run my business? Lorelai: Well, change businesses. (she lies down on bed) Ooh, wow, total déjà vu. Luke: Really? Lorelai: It's the alarm clock. I had a dream once that you set eighteen alarm clocks to get me up, which is not a bad way to get me up. Luke: Where were we? Lorelai: We were, um, at my house. I got up, I went downstairs for coffee, and you talked to my stomach. Luke: Why on earth I do that? Lorelai: Well, because I was pregnant. Twins. Luke: Mine? Lorelai: What am I, dream tramp? Of course yours. Luke: We were married? Lorelai: Um, yeah. Did I not mention that? Luke: No. You know, you shouldn't drink coffee when you're pregnant. Lorelai: Uh, true. Luke: It's probably why Rory's a caffeine addict. Lorelai: Right, you're right. Luke: Dream go beyond that? Lorelai: No. Um, you talked to my stomach and then you ki- well, no. Luke: Oh, okay. Well... night. Lorelai: Yeah, night. Edit
    • (Lorelai gives her room to some guest and she is without bed) Lorelai: How much room do you take up on that couch there, Fred Junior? Junior: Pretty much all of it. Lorelai: That's what I figured... Edit
    • (While sitting at Miss Patty's, enduring a tediously done rendition of Poe's "The Raven") Lorelai: At least if I had brought a flask, we could have played the nevermore drinking game. Rory: Oh, maybe this is what drove Poe to the bottle. Lorelai: His own work. Edit
  • Allusions

    ADD ALLUSIONS
    • Paris: I was flipping through Harvard class schedules when you were still delighting to the adventures of Gumby and Pokey. Rory: I was more a Pee Wee Herman kind of Gal. Gumby, a green guy, and his sidekick Pokey, an orange horse were on Gumby Adventures,a Saturday morning show done with clay. It was one of the earliest children's shows on TV Pee Wee's Playhouse was another show for kids around the late 80's, featuring Paul Reubens playing his signature character (with the goofy sexual overtones bowdlerized, of course). When he was involved in a scandal over publicly whacking off in a XXX movie theater, the show quietly disappeared. Although he last appeared as the character in 1992, there is supposedly a movie being made. Edit
    • Lorelai: (to Rory, who is entertaining little kids with a sock-puppet show) Hey, Shari Lewis, how's the show going? Shari Lewis (1933 - 1998) was a puppeteer who created the character Lamb Chop out of a sock puppet, which became a classic children's character in the late 50s. When TV Guide did a celebrity recipe's section, her entry was a recipe for lamb chops. Edit
    • Paris: I've been totally Howard-Hughesing it. Aviator and industrialist Howard Hughes (1905 - 1976) suffered from obsessive-compulsive disorder and experienced bouts of withdrawing from the world. At times he was rumored to have let his hair grow to shoulder length and his nails into claws as a result of his fear of scissors. There were times when he was also rumored to be dead because no one had seen him except a couple members of his staff in a preposterously long time. Hughes was the subject of the Leonardo DiCaprio vehicle, "The Aviator" and the movie "Melvin and Howard" was peripherally related to him as well. When he died in 1976, his estate was estimated as worth 2.5 billion dollars. Edit
More
Less