Episode Fan Reviews (12)

Write a Review
9.4
out of 10
Average: Superb
261 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate Now!
  • Dean and Jess get into a fight.

    10
    "Perfect"
    I would have to say that every time i watch re-runs of Gilmore Girls this one has to be my favorite. I love how Jess is so angry at Rory and she doesn't even know what she did. She runs off crying and here comes Dean to the rescue. He runs after Jess and starts punching him. We then see Lane calling her mom and telling her that she is in a band and that she is in love with Dave and she is drunk at that very second. Lorelai offers Luke and Nicole a room at the Inn for helping out with the after-fire of their place. She is there to turn down the room and when she sees that it is them that is using the suite she is uncomfortable with the situation. After the fight with Dean Jess runs off without a word to Rory. End of episode.
  • The teens go to a party where Lane's band has a gig. Lorelai goes to another boosters meeting. Another great one.

    9.8
    "Superb"
    The fight between Dean and Jess was a long time coming and it was entertaining how it came about. Jess and Rory get heated when they fall onto the bed kissing, Rory says no to sex and Jess outbursts at Rory, who bursts into tears. This does show how much Dean cares for Rory, I wonder how Lindsey felt about this, she seemed nicer to Rory in the episode though.



    It was nice of Jess to care about the prom so much because of Rory and I guess him being annoyed was expected. Lane being drunk was funny, loved how she called Mrs Kim and admitted everything, that should be interesting. Dave and her should get together soon.



    I'm glad Max has finally gone from the show, I was getting sick of him. His scene in the classroom was funny though. I also liked the whole Lorelai looking after money for the boosters thing, it was amusing. There was loads of great small things here too, like the opening scene with the Gilmore's first Friday night off in a few years.



    Great episode again.
  • another great one fight and all

    9.4
    "Superb"
    First Friday without going to dinner to Emily and Richard's house. They without anything to do and Emily and Richard throwing a party. The prom is here.



    It's Lane's band first gig and they have a plane to keep Mrs Kim out.



    Since last episode Jess's car disappeared, I have almost sure that it was Luke, the look on his face was guilty.



    The Inn is very bad, they have to fire a lot of people, that's bad...



    Lorelai is summoned to the Boaster Club, Max shows up and both play it cool. The Chilton graduation party is coming.



    Those guys, the party organizers were so weird, they looked all bad and rebel but the house preparation, taking everything out, piking the worst things to use lol



    Jess is not graduating, he is in a real bad mood, that's a great way to end a party, fight, cops...



    It was fun to see Lane drunk calling Mrs Kim, that was really fun. And the one with Lorelai and Max too. The 10 feet distance lol



    Jess was a jerk with Rory at the party, in the room, it had to end in a fight...
  • Lorelai runs into Max at a Chilton booster club meeting. Lane's band play at a party which ends badly.

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode is probably one of my favourites. It has everything Ive come to know and love about this show - fast, witty dialogue, quirky characters, great relationships etc - and some extra revelations and excitement.

    Lorelai is coerced into joining the Chilton Booster Club where she runs into Max who plays it cool. This upsets Lorelai so she goes to speak to him causing him to reveal that he isnt over her and thinks they should stay away from each other. This was actually a really sad moment. I thought Max and Lorelai were really good together and it was sad to hear him say they should stay away from each other. Especially since the look on her face was one of hurt.

    The party however was the main attraction. Kyle, the host, 21 year old cousin shows up with a beer keg. Lane, who is frustrated and upset by the Young Chui/Dave situation gets drunk, phones her mother and tells her everything! Everything about Dave and the band and everything shes spent so long and worked so hard to keep a secret.

    Jess as always is being moody and obnoxious however this time he has a reason - hes just flunked out of school and been told he isnt allowed to go to Prom (which he has promised Rory he'd get tickets for). Rory goes upstairs (to a dark and deserted bedroom) to check hes ok. Inevitably things start to heat up. Rory tries to leave before anything actually does happen and Jess yells at her causing Rory to run out the house in tears. Not before she runs into a concerned Dean however.

    Jess sees Rory with Dean and gets annoyed/jealous, Dean runs after Jess and punches him. A full blown fight ensues, with people trying to break it up unsuccessfully, trashing most of the house and ending in the garden where the cops arrive. It was all really exciting. I think I yelled at the TV a couple of times and gasped a few times. Lane telling Mrs Kim everything is bound to have all kinds of repercussions. As will the fight obviously. It was a heck of a fight and it had to happen eventually! All very well done too. Although Rory probably could have done a bit more. She just kind of followed them around feebly shouting guys stop it. Most of the time she wasnt even in the shot. She could have attempted to break Dean and Jess up. Ok so the guys who were trying were getting thrown all over the place by them but neither Jess nor Dean would have wanted to hurt Rory so if she had got in the way they would have avoided hitting her and stopped. Right? Hmmm, maybe she was sensible to stay out the way...

    Did anyone else cringe ALOT when Lorelai was in Luke and Nicole's room. I really wanted her to just get out. It was painful to watch.

    Over all a very exciting and well done episode. Lots of issues ended up out in the open.
  • Jess and Dean get into a fight...

    9.4
    "Superb"
    On their first free Friday night, Lorelai and Rory are at a loss over how to spend the evening, while Emily and Richard cavort at the party they're hosting; Lorelai is appointed Grad Night Treasurer and runs into a playing-it-cool Max at her first Chilton Booster Club meeting; Lane's band gets their first gig at a party and rocks the house, but Dave rocks Lane's world when he flips out after discovering that Young Chui is in love with her; a despondent Lane indulges in a little too much beer, and then drunkenly calls her mother and confesses all; when staff cutbacks at the Inn force Lorelai to do turn-down service, she becomes very unsettled at seeing a cozy Luke and Nicole in the room she's offered as thanks for Luke's help with repairs after the fire; Jess's inability to tell Rory that his frequent absences have caused him to flunk out of school and miss graduation and the prom prompts an argument between Jess and Rory, and then a full-blown brawl with Dean after Dean comes upon a tearful and distraught Rory.
  • Lane's band plays a gig where Lane gets drunk and calls her mom,things heat up between Jess and Rory,and Dean and Jess get in a fight. Lorelai is appointed treasurer of prom money and has many encounters with Max.

    9.9
    "Superb"
    This one episode determines many futures. Lane's mom now knows of Lane's band. Jess and Rory's relationship is now on the rocks. Dean once again steps in for Rory. Lorelai and Max share some moments together. The relationship between Emily and Richard / Lorelai and Rory is now somewhat tarnished when Lorelai and Rory, lost at what to do give Richard and Emily a call and find out that the Gilmores are having a large "get together". This episode comes to be the near end of Jess and Rory. Well this episode is great because it gives lots of forshadowing of what the future season and episodes will be bringing to this already powerfully entertaining show!
  • Jess flunks out of school, so he can't prom tickets. He doesn't tell Rory and when they're @ a party, and they seem like they're gonna "do it," he gets mad @ Rory b/c of the prom thing, but she thinks it's b/c she didn't want to "do it" then and there.

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode was really sad. I love Jess I could tell he wouldn't be on the show much more after this. I only wish that we could've seen Rory/Jess' relationship a little longer. The writers didn't let a lot of the episodes focus on just the two of them like they did with Rory/Dean and I didn't like that.
  • Wonderful

    9.4
    "Superb"
    Overall, this was a pretty amazing episode. It had major plot and/or character developments for most main characters. I\'ve loved the story line with Lane playing in a band since day one and with her being the music fanatic that she is, it seemed inevitable. So to see them actually play a gig was amazing. Though I\'m not quite convinced that the band was as good as everyone kept saying they were. The interaction between Lorelai and Max was classic as always and had me wanting them to get back together. I also loved the conversation between Lorelai and Sookie about Luke\'s butt.
  • Lanes band plays at a party and rory attends

    10
    "Perfect"
    i really liked this episode i thought that it was really entertaining and exciting. i thought that it was great that lanes band got a gig for a high school party and i thought that it was really funny that the party turned to a keg party. i was really surpised with lane that she got drunk and she called her mother to tell her that she was in a band and that she wanted to go to the prom with dave. i thought that it was really funny that rory and jess got into a arguement that caused jess and dean to get into a fight.
  • the party scenes were hilarious, but nothing can top the lorelai-max encounter...oh the whole ten feet basketball player thing was great! lol...anywho love this episode

    9.9
    "Superb"
    awesome epsidoe, one of the ebst of seson . when rory goes to the party, and lane tbhrows up! thats great, oh and the drunken call, young chui saving a seat, the band's crazyness. also the tips from lorelai before ht party, and when the fight breaks out and dave falls on young shui and young chui says "get off of me" and dave couldnt. that was funny. oh and the booster club, the booster club. ah great great episode. (not disregard all mispellings in this)
  • Between Lane calling her mother when she's drunk, and the Dean-Jess fight, Gilmore Girls fans were sure to enjoy this episode!

    8.6
    "Great"
    I realize that this review isn't up to my usual standards, but I've decided to simply review the ending scenes. I love the scene, and so does my mother (I'm 15) where Dean gets in a fight with Jess by punching him. But we also love where Lane calls up her mother, coninually calling her "Mama", which is how she refers to her normally, and, having just drank a beer-and-a-half (isn't that hillarious!), informs Mrs. Kim that she's in a band, doesn't love the Korean boy she's been set up with and instead wants to go to the prom with Dave, because Dave and Lane rock together. That was perfect! And the Dean-Jess fight was also great. Who wouldn't love that?
  • We were all waiting for the Jess-Dean fight. And it was quite what i would have expected though it worked out very well.

    9.8
    "Superb"
    We were all waiting for the Jess-Dean fight. And it was quite what i would have expected though it worked out very well. Rory's tears were a little overdone and Dean's reaction was horrible. I wonder how Lindsey felt, because if I were her I would have been pissed with Dean for getting in a fight with my ex-girlfriend's boyfriend over my ex-gf crying because of something he did. A little bit over-protective of our "savior Dean" in my opinion. Luke's anger with Jess doesnt help his already battered emotions. Obviously Jess is going through something but he won't talk to anyone about it.
More
Less