Gilmore Girls

Season 7 Episode 12

To Whom It May Concern

1
Aired Tuesday 8:00 PM Jan 30, 2007 on The WB
9.3
out of 10
User Rating
307 votes
34

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
Lorelai notices some odd behavior from Sookie. Luke and Anna attend a custody hearing. With help from Paris, Rory finally makes amends with Lucy. While attending Richard's economics class at Yale, Rory witnesses a frightening scene. Christopher finds the letter Lorelai wrote for Luke and confronts her.moreless

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Today
11:00am
ABCFAM
12:00pm
ABCFAM
Thursday
11:00am
ABCFAM
12:00pm
ABCFAM
Friday
11:00am
ABCFAM
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • One of the best episodes of the season.

    10
    This is definitely one of the best episodes of this season so far. I like how Sookie randomly drops by with some coffee for a chat with Lorelai at the start. The scene where the judge read Lorelai's letter was extremely touching and it was clear that Lorelai still loves Luke. Christopher and Lorelai finally has a big fight - as much as how I liked them being together, the chemistry wasn't there. Rory finally gets back together with Lucy, and I'm quite happy that Paris was so direct with Lucy, since she couldn't stand Rory being treated this way. She certainly is a great friend. It's amusing how her obsession with perfection takes over as she plans her own future and at the same time includes Rory in it. Richard faints at Rory's lecture, leaving a dramatic cliffhanger.moreless
  • Things are finally happening and the ending was shocking. Are the writers getting it now?

    9.5
    I have to say it but...finally Lorelai and Christopher are reaching the end of their marriage. It has been doomed from the start and was just a very obvious obstacle for the Luke/Lorelai relationship. I predicted that Chris would find the character reference but I was glad we got to hear it. It just shows how these two are meant to be, it was a nice moment to hear what she thinks of him.



    The confrontation was engrossing and intense but everyone knows that Lorelai loves Luke, so her efforts were useless in trying to calm Christopher down. I'm glad he left as its for the best. Loved that Luke called with news that he won partial custody, she looked so upset. Anna wasn't nice here...she's very harsh on Luke.



    As for Rory's storyline, I was really satisfied with it. I loved how Paris was the one who got her and Lucy to make up...she's hilarious but the things she said about Rory were sweet and I was glad that Lucy made things right. What about the shocking end? Richard has a heart attack, that was a bold move and very6 dramatic for this show. It worked though...can't wait to see what happens next episode.



    In other news Sookie is pregnant...this was funny, loved her freaking out. So this was the best episode of the 7th season...are the new writers finally getting it?moreless
  • So it seems the marriage between Lorelai and Chris is finally over...!

    9.1
    I liked this episode. Rory are finally good friends with Lucy again (you gotta love Paris), allthough it was kind of a lame make-up they had in the cafeteria... That could have been more interesting!

    And now Sookie is pregnant! I can't believe that Jackson never mentioned to her that he didn't have the vesectomy. She is sooo entitled to get really mad at him. I guess Jackson had to be really thankful that Lorelai was there to calm her down...

    The best part of this episode is off course the letter. That letter was soo moving, and you could tell that Luke was happily surprised. I get why Chris couldn't ignore it, and now it seems that the marriage is over! Yay, let's get Lorelai back together with Luke... :)moreless
  • Lorelai finds out why Sookie is acting so strange. Rory and Paris are trying to figure out their future after Yale. Rory and Lucy make up. Christopher finds Lorelai's character reference for Luke and reacts badly. Luke wins his court case.moreless

    9.9
    I think it would have been a funnier story line to have the vasectomy fail rather than have Jackson deceive Sookie in such a way but it's fun to have Sookie pregnant again. It was a nice way to share Melissa's pregnancy with her fans. I'm glad that Luke won his case but I hope it doesn't mean we have to see too much more of April. This was a strange story line and I hope that she is only mentioned in passing in the future. Well Christopher is now showing his true colors. When things don't go well, he leaves. Emily said it best when she said, "You were a charming boy. A weak, but charming boy." (Season 5, episode 12 "Come Home") Christopher took advantage of Lorelai when she was hurting. It was appalling that he thought it was ok to sleep with her when she was in such a vulnerable state (end of last season). He charmed her with romantic dates and a trip to Paris. He took her on the rebound and now blames her because she shows some loyalty to a long time friend. Instead of talking it out, he has a tantrum and walks away. Lorelai should be stronger but she is still hurt from her break up with Luke and confused about her feelings for Chris. She is trying hard to make her marriage work even though the alarm bells are ringing. Hopefully she'll figure things out soon. Next episode should go a long way into helping her decide with whom she should ultimately be.moreless
  • Freakin' Men! This was an episode full of male mishaps.

    9.2
    They are always trouble aren't they? No matter what they are doing, they are doing something to drive us crazy.



    First, there's Jackson. Who didn't go get his stuff fixed. Now poor Sookie has to birth another child. And I speak from personal experience, this is NOT an easy task or one to take lightly. But it was rather sweet how bonds friendship helped Sookie deal and accept her fate. The mother of three kiddos.



    Secondly, there's Luke. He had the best intentions, but still seemed to cause trouble, albeit very indirectly. But, the trouble was there, so it must be listed.



    Then there's Marty, who although not seen was the cause of a quarrel between two blossoming buddies. If it weren't for his inability to get his head together, there would have never been any issue.



    Poor Richard, while not intentional, he cause some drama at the end of the episode with his medical situation. Not his fault, but it did cause some stress for Rory (and later stress for the rest of the Gilmore women, although not in this episode).



    Lastly Christopher whom it seems has lost his freakin' mind. Getting mad at Lorelai for the coffe from Luke's that SOOKIE brought over. Hello, it was brought in by a third party. Lorelai can't help its the best coffee in town. And then getting mad at her for trying to help Luke get to see his daughter. WTF? Come on man! You've *really* lost it!



    So, therefore I'm re-titling this episode 'Male Madness'.moreless
Alexis Bledel

Alexis Bledel

Rory Gilmore

Lauren Graham

Lauren Graham

Lorelai Gilmore

Edward Herrmann

Edward Herrmann

Richard Gilmore

Scott Patterson

Scott Patterson

Luke Danes

Liza Weil

Liza Weil

Paris Geller (Episodes 22 - , recurring previously)

Melissa McCarthy

Melissa McCarthy

Sookie St. James

Douglas Rowe

Douglas Rowe

Jim

Guest Star

Cheryl White

Cheryl White

Barbara

Guest Star

Denise Dowse

Denise Dowse

Judge

Guest Star

David Sutcliffe

David Sutcliffe

Christopher Hayden

Recurring Role

Jackson Douglas

Jackson Douglas

Jackson Belleville

Recurring Role

Krysten Ritter

Krysten Ritter

Lucy

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (13)

    • Luke is awarded joint custody of April.

    • This is the second time Lorelai has been Luke's character witness. In "The Lorelai's First Day at Yale," when Luke is talking to the lawyers, he asks her to be his character witness to prove that he wants nothing from his divorce with Nicole.

    • While she's now married, the Judge refers to Lorelai as "Ms. Lorelai Gilmore". Since the Judge does nothing but read Lorelai's letter, we can assume that not only did Lorelai not take Christopher's name (she said she wouldn't, so no surprise there) but it also looks like she's attached to her single status. It can also be interpreted as a way of not hurting Luke.

    • One unrealistic aspect of the custody hearing is that the judge does not take April's opinion into account. In actual custody proceedings, the child usually must have her own attorney appointed to represent the child's interests, because those interests are not always in line with the interests of her parents. In a situation where the child is old enough to vocalize her wishes, the judge would definitely take those wishes into consideration. Here, April was definitely old enough to have an opinion on the matter, and she clearly wanted Luke to have the partial custody he requested. If this was an actual custody proceeding, the judge would have spoken with April (or her court-appointed attorney) and it would have been another strong factor in favor of granting Luke shared custody. This was probably not incorporated into the episode, because not factoring in April's opinion made the hearing more suspenseful for the audience ... if less realistic.

    • We find out that Sookie is pregnant in this episode.

    • When Jackson is talking to Lorelai in his kitchen, he opens the water bottle but then on several shots the cap is still on.

    • When Lorelai returns home from babysitting, she walks across the yard in the snow. We see clearly that there is snow stuck on the bottom of her shoes as she enters the house from outside. When the camera inside the house catches her entering, she doesn't clean her shoes off yet there is no snow left on the rug and she doesn't slip on the wooden floors.

    • In Lorelai's reference letter she states that she has known Luke Danes for almost 10 years. This is consistent with the fact that in season 5 episode "Written in the Stars" Luke told her he had met her eight years earlier. Also, in "Santa's Secret Stuff" Luke implies to April that he met Rory when he was her age. It seems unlikely that she didn't know Luke for the first eleven years she lived there. In Season 5, episode "Wedding Bell Blues", after the Luke/Christopher debacle Lorelai said to Rory that Luke still remembered her in angel wings. This implied that her knew her at a very young age...probably 5 or 6 or younger, not 11 or 12.

    • Just before Lorelai goes over to babysit, she and Christopher have a conversation. Right at the end when they kiss the last time, her arm isn't round his neck but when the shot changes it is.

    • When Sookie is asking Lorelai to babysit Martha and Davey, her coat is on the chair and she is sitting on it. When she gets up to hug Lorelai after Lorelai says yes, the coat is on the back of the chair and then it goes back to being on the seat of the chair with Sookie sitting on it again.

    • When Lorelai and Christopher are having their ugly conversation in the kitchen the position of Christopher's zipper changes between shots.

    • When Rory and Paris are sitting in the cafeteria, Rory's arms are in difference positions between shots.

    • In this episode, Lucy finally calls Marty by his first name, as opposed to "Boyfriend" -- the label she has given him for the past several episodes.

  • QUOTES (17)

    • Chris: Hey have you seen the level?
      Lorelai: The, uh, thing with the green bubble that goes back and forth?
      Chris: Yeah
      Lorelai: Yeah, Paul Anka and I were playing with it.
      Chris: You were playing with it with the dog?
      Lorelai: Yes, I was trying to hypnotize him with the bubble.
      Chris: Uh Huh
      Lorelai: See if I could talk him out of the habit of chewing on the corner of the welcome mat. Or, I was going to give him a wacky post-hypnotic suggestion like the door bell rings and he spins around in circles.
      Chris: Were you able to hypnotize him?
      Lorelai: No Chris, he's a dog.

    • Lorelai: But, you know, babies are more than diapers, though, right?
      Sookie: No, no.
      Lorelai: Sookie.
      Sookie: No, all I remember is eat, sleep, poop, eat, sleep, poop.
      Lorelai: Well, there's other stuff.
      Sookie: Yeah, like, uh, diaper rash, and colic, and potty training.
      Lorelai: No, the good stuff.
      Sookie: Well, I'm having trouble remembering that.
      Lorelai: Well, for one thing, they're pretty cute.
      Sookie: Yeah, well, but, cute's not going to help me sleep at night.
      Lorelai: And they smell great. That newborn baby smell, you can't beat that, right?
      Sookie: The smell is pretty good.
      Lorelai: And how about when you give them their first bath. I remember when I gave Rory her first bath and she looked up at me like, "What the hell is going on?" I kept saying, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry."
      Sookie: You know, Davey loved his first one. Martha screamed bloody murder. Oh, my God, the screaming.
      Lorelai: Yeah, but how about the first time they're crying and crying and you go in to pick them up and then they stop crying because they recognize you!
      Sookie: That's pretty cool.
      Lorelai: Yeah!
      Sookie: I'm not going to sleep, though.
      Lorelai: Yeah, you won't sleep, but you'll get another first smile.
      Sookie: Davey had his at three weeks. That's really advanced.
      Lorelai: Aww. And how about when you're lying down, holding the baby, and the baby falls asleep on your chest.
      Sookie: And they're all warm and cuddly. God. I know what you're doing. You're trying to make this sound good.
      Lorelai: In the middle of the night, and you're rocking the baby, and everyone's asleep. Then they fall asleep, then you fall asleep.
      Sookie: (starts to cry) I'm hormonal. And you're playing dirty.
      Lorelai: Pretty good stuff, huh?
      Sookie: I guess.
      Lorelai: Really good.
      Sookie: Are you talking memory or are you talking ahead?
      Lorelai: Oh, uh, a little bit of both, I guess.
      Sookie: Really?
      Lorelai: Well, the subject has come up. It might come up again.

    • (After fighting with Christopher and waking up alone, Luke calls)
      Lorelai: Hello?
      Luke: Hey, I didn't wake you did I?
      Lorelai: Uh, no, hi. No. I'm up.
      Luke: I just had to tell you–-I won!
      Lorelai: (confused) You won?
      Luke: It's incredible. I thought I was screwed. I mean, her lawyer dug up every last bit of dirt she could find about me, but...
      Lorelai: (realizes what he's talking about) Oh, oh, Luke, that's great.
      Luke: Yeah, the judge waited until this morning to give us their decision, and man that was the longest night of my life. I just got off [the phone] with my lawyer. I get shared custody.
      Lorelai: Wow, congratulations.
      Luke: Yeah, I get to see April at least one weekend a month, every other major holiday, half the summer, we're going to work it all out. It's so great.
      Lorelai: So great.
      Luke: Yeah, I guess the judge just took everything into consideration, and realized how much I wanted to be in April's life. And, of course, your letter was a big help.
      Lorelai: (winces) Well, I just wanted to help you–-help April.
      Luke: Well, you did, and I'm really grateful. Anyway, sorry to call so early. Uh, thanks again.
      Lorelai: Congratulations. (hangs up and sighs)

    • Chris: I read your letter.
      Lorelai: It's not a letter. It's a character reference Luke asked me to write for his court case.
      Chris: It reads like a letter.
      Lorelai: Oh yeah?
      Chris: Almost like a love letter.
      Lorelai: (pauses uncomfortably) No, it's a favor Luke asked, because he needed ...
      Chris: You know what, before you go through a whole list of excuses, let me just ask.....is our marriage, for you, basically just marking time?
      Lorelai: What?
      Chris: Oh, come on, Lor.
      Lorelai: Of course not!
      Chris: I mean, it's obvious that you still have very deep feelings for the guy.
      Lorelai: No, no. I've just known him a long time and he's--
      Chris: (quoting the letter) "Always been there, always will be there."

    • Judge: (reading Lorelai's letter) To whom it may concern, in the nearly 10 years that I have known Luke Danes, I have come know him as an honest, and decent man. He's also one of the most kind and caring persons I have ever met.
      (Camera cuts to Chris reading the letter and we hear Lorelai's voice.)
      Lorelai: I am a single mother, and I raise my daughter by myself, but once Luke Danes became my friend in this town, I never really felt alone. Luke and I have had our ups and downs over the years, but through it all, his relationship with my daughter Rory, has never changed. He's always been there for her no matter what. He was there to celebrate her birthdays, he was there cheering her on at her high school graduation. Luke has been sort of a father figure in my daughters life. With his own daughter Luke wasn't given the opportunity to be there for her first 12 years, but he should be given that opportunity now. Once Luke Danes is in your life, he's in your life forever.
      Judge: I know from personal experience what an amazing gift that is, and not to allow him access to his daughter, would be to seriously deprive her, of all this man has to offer, and he offers so much. Thank you for your time, sincerely, Lorelai Gilmore.

    • Lorelai: (about the letter for Luke) I didn't hide the letter! I put it in the drawer in case they lost the typed copy, or the judge spilled coffee on it, the dog ate it, I don't know why I didn't tell you!
      Christopher: I think it's because you're still in love with him.
      Lorelai: No, I love you. I love you!
      Christopher: You know what, Lor, I'm sorry, but I just can't handle this, okay?
      Lorelai: Handle what?
      Christopher: This! You, and him, I just, I can't handle being your second choice. I thought I could, but I can't, okay? I can't be your rebound. I'm sorry. (walks out)

    • Jackson: So, how's Christopher?
      Lorelai: Oh he's good. He's putting up a ginormous flat screen as we speak.
      Jackson: Cool. What the pixel aspect ratio?
      Lorelai: It's got two remotes.
      Jackson: I'll ask him.
      Lorelai: Good idea.

    • Richard: (to his students) Now, when it comes to papers, I am guessing that some of you, of course, will be asking me for an extension. You'll be happy to learn that I have no problem with extensions. Here's what you do: you look at the due date for the paper, and you write it down on your calendar two weeks prior to that due date--and there you have it. I've just granted you a two-week extension.

    • Lorelai: You smell good. Familiar. Is that my conditioner?
      Chris: Maybe. I don't know.
      Lorelai: Are you using my conditioner?
      Chris: Sometimes, why? You don't like to share?
      Lorelai: No, I'm married now, I love to share.
      Chris: So why is it so funny?
      Lorelai: Because you don't have that much to condition.
      Chris: I know that.
      Lorelai: It's just been really unruly lately?
      Chris: Alright, I got a lot of work to do here.
      Lorelai: Alright. Listen, I love that you're using my conditioner. And I love that you're putting up this jumbo-tron thingy all by yourself, and I can't wait to come home and watch flat sports with you, and I love you, goodbye.
      Chris: I will be here.
      Lorelai: Hey if you feel like shaving I've got a brand new Lady Schick in the drawer. Feel free to use it.
      Chris: Oh, I might just do that.

    • Paris: Okay, look. It's time to put an end to this little junior high game you're playing.
      Lucy: (taken by surprise) Hey, Paris.
      Paris: Have you read Rory's letter or not?
      Lucy: Um, yeah, I just--
      Paris: Well, will you please tell her you forgive her and kiss and make up already? This is really messing with her head.
      Rory: (running up) I'm sorry, Lucy, I didn't--
      Paris: Don't apologize. I've got her on the ropes.
      Lucy: Look, I just got back an hour ago, so I just read your letter.
      Paris: Yeah, and?
      Lucy: Well, it's not really fair--I mean, with you being a writer.
      Paris: Yeah. Yeah, life's not fair. Can you let her off the hook, for God's sake? In case you didn't know it, Rory is a great person, and she does not deserve to be treated this way!
      Rory: Paris--
      Paris: Anyone should feel lucky to call her a friend. I know I do--and you're throwing away one of the best.

    • Christopher: I know you Lor.
      Lorelai: And?
      Christopher: And I know you're not done with him.
      Lorelai: Okay, this is ridiculous. Hey, this is a ridiculous conversation, okay? I have a history with him, yes. I was engaged to him, yes, but I married you!
      Christopher: Tell me you're not in love with him.
      Lorelai: I am not in love with him.
      Christopher: I should have known......I mean, all the signs were there.
      Lorelai: What signs?
      Christopher: Well, the fact that you didn't want to leave Stars Hollow, that you were dead-set against re-doing the wedding, that you didn't want to have a baby with me! I mean, it's all because of him, right?
      Lorelai: No! How can I tell you--it's over, okay? What I had with him is over, Chris.
      Chris: Then why did you hide the letter from me?

    • Sookie: Oh, God, I hope I have a girl, ooh, or a boy!
      Lorelai: Well, chances are pretty good that you'll have one or the other.

    • Richard: So, have you come as a loving granddaughter visiting your grandfather, or as an obsequious student trying to butter up her professor?
      Rory: Well, I'm not buttering up.
      Richard: Oh, good.
      Rory: Well, actually...
      Richard: (smiling) A-ha, I thought I smelled butter!

    • Rory: I'm going through something with a friend.
      Richard: Paris?
      Rory: No, someone else. I hurt her feelings, and even after writing her a very long letter of apology, she hasn't gotten back to me, and I just feel terrible.
      Richard: Well, I doubt it's as bad as you think it is. I'm sure the girl will get back to you. Maybe she's just a very slow reader. (Rory still looks upset) Oh, honey, anyone who knows you knows that you would never purposely do anything to hurt someone else's feelings.
      Rory: Well, that's just it. We don't know each other that well. She's a new friend. We don't have a history.
      Richard: Hmm. Well, I wouldn't worry about it. Rory, you are a person of great heart and great character, and that combination will always win the day.

    • Emily: Oh, and Lorelai, it turns out I have an emergency DAR board meeting on Tuesday, so I won't be able to get together to finalize the seating chart for the party.
      Lorelai: No seating chart get-together? How will I live?

    • Luke: (making conversation with Anna at the courthouse) So...this place, huh?
      Anna: Yeah, what a waste of time.
      Luke: Yeah.
      Anna: Especially since there's no reason for it.
      Luke: Well, I mean--
      Anna: But you have to finish what you started, right?
      Luke: What I started?
      Anna: Uh, yes, when you hired a lawyer.
      Luke: Well, I had to hire a lawyer. It was the only way I could see my kid.
      Anna: But I mean, come on--you really think you have a chance?
      Luke: Yeah, well, that's for a judge to decide.
      Anna: Well, step back. Take a look at it. I mean, look at you. You're you--a hermit, living above a diner in some old, converted hardware store. It doesn't exactly paint a picture of "capable father."
      Luke: It doesn't matter where I live, and I have been nothing but a good father to April.
      Anna: And you know what, you're not gonna get any points for your history with women, either.
      Luke: I don't know what you're talking about.
      Anna: Bailed on Lorelai, got divorced in a heartbeat--
      Luke: I did not bail on Lorelai!
      Anna: You have had no long-term relationships, Luke. Why would a judge trust you to have one with April?

    • Jackson: (talking to Lorelai about Sookie) She's pregnant!
      Lorelai: Well, I know that and you know that but don't you think we should let Sookie in on the good news?

  • NOTES (7)

  • ALLUSIONS (8)

    • Paris: You two were behaving like children. I thought I was going to have to put you on the naughty step or something.

      The naughty step is a technique used by Jo Frost to discipline children when they misbehave. They must stay on the step (also called naughty stool or naughty mat) for a certain amount of time depending on their age. She is the main figure and host of her reality television show Supernanny.

    • Paris: How very "Heathers" of her!

      Heathers is a movie from 1989 starring Winona Ryder, Christian Slater and Shannen Doherty. It's a movie about three popular girls in high school, and a fourth one that wants to become a part of the clique even though she isn't like the other girls.

    • Sookie: Are you sure?
      Jackson: Absolutely. Kinsey Millhone is waiting for you.

      Kinsey Millhone is a fictional female private investigator created by Sue Grafton, and is the protagonist of Grafton's "alphabet mysteries" series of novels. In addition, Millhone appears in a number of short stories written by Grafton.

    • Paris: I have to set up the Goldman Sachs interview before spring break.

      Goldman Sachs is one of the world's largest global investment banks. Goldman Sachs was founded in 1869, and is headquartered in the Lower Manhattan area of New York City.

    • Christopher: All the better to watch Reggie Bush score touchdowns on.
      Lorelai: I forget. Which one of the Bush daughters is Reggie?

      Reggie Bush, nicknamed "The President," alluding to President Bush, is an American football player who plays for the New Orleans Saints.

    • Lorelai: Oh, my God, the eagle has landed.

      'The Eagle has Landed' is a book by Jack Higgins, written in 1975, and filmed in 1976. The phrase "The Eagle has landed" was also used when the Eagle lunar module first landed on the Moon in 1969.

    • The books Sookie wants to take with her skiing are R is for Ricochet and S is for Silence by Sue Grafton.

    • Episode Title: To Whom It May Concern

      "To Whom It May Concern" is the title of an album released by Nat King Cole, the Bee Gees, Freestyle Fellowship and Lisa Marie Pressley.
      It's also a title of a humor blog by an anonymous Chicagoan, who posts unsent letters to people, places and things
      It's also the title of a beautiful poem written by the fictional character Darlene on Roseanne.

More
Less