A couple of small annoyances keep this from a perfect score-
9.5
"Superb"
Glee is a funny beast. When the show is good, its damn good. Fantastic. And I think they know it. I can't quite articulate what I'm trying to put my finger on, but sometimes I feel like Glee thinks a little too highly of itself. Is it possible for first season phenomenon to get...cocky? (Answer: Yes. See: Heroes) I know this sounds crazy, and it was hard for me to point out specific examples, but there's just something about the way the show presents itself. It can feel more like fan service and try too hard. "I don't know anyone who'd miss an episode of Glee-"
These are the first words of the episode, in the recap, and right off the bat this rubbed me the wrong way. Don't get full of yourselves, guys. You may have blown your load already in the first season, with every plot imaginable, and you can only rinse and repeat with these competitions for so long...
The fan service continued at Will's place, crying, because of their chances at Regionals. Are you kidding me? This pity party felt really forced and manipulative- tugging on the heartstrings of the viewers. This happened a lot throughout the episode- a problem I had with the Sectionals Fall Finale as well. And if you didn't think they could push it further, check out Journey's 'Don't Stop Believing' (their amazing number that started it all) on the radio, that breaks Shuester down. I think we get it, Glee. Our kids are a rag-tag long shot to win. (But they'll pull it off, right? ;)
Things quickly turned around after the shaky beginning, though. For starters, I loved the judges acknowledging the fact that out heroes are the rag-tag underdogs. This self aware sense of humor has always been a strength of Glee. Everything about the Regionals competition was perfect. Aural Intensity! Are you serious, lol! New Directions basically knocked it out of the park with their Journey medley, which included Don't Stop Believing 2.0. We got the best performance from Vocal Adrenaline that I've seen, and even though I don't think it was as good as ND, they were polished and showy, and I got the vibe that they were championship material.
We got some returning cameos from Josh Grobin and Olivia Newton John as judges. Both were as funny as ever (esp Grobin) and in the cleverest, sharpest part of the plot, They turned on New Directions, forcing the one and only Sue Sylvester to be the single vote FOR our glee club. I really liked that swerve. It's refreshing to see the fan service back fire. Not only did ND not win, they didn't even place! Ouch. Now this genuinely got a reaction out of me: I was sad. This finale was a chance for reflection over the past year, and there was plenty of that (and inspirational speeches). But it also tied up plot threads, including Rachel and Finn, Rachel and her mom, Will and Emma, who had some great stuff, and even the principal's blackmail. One element that didn't really work for me was Quinn delivering her baby (a finale cliche if there ever was one) cross-cut with the VA performance. Not as effective as it could have been. Quinn's labor performance wasn't there. Trying to match up the lyrics with the visuals wasn't so much clever as it was obvious. Puck named the babe Beth, which was nice, and Shelby adopted her. Aww. Random, but Aww.
Journey Medley
Included was "Faithfully + Any Way You Want It + Lovin Touchin, Squeezin + Don't Stop Believin'" but I'll lump it together as one performance. One grand, 'bigger is better' = best performance. Grade: A
"Bohemian Rhapsody" by Queen.
Johnathan Goff finally got to tear it up. I mean seriously tear it up. If not for the baby delivery, I would have liked this even better.
Grade: B+
"To Sir With Love" by Lulu.
A sweet 'Thank you, teacher' moment for the class and Mr. Shue. But I'm kinda meh on the song.
Grade: B
"Over the Rainbow" from The Wizard of Oz.
Okay, this one finally got me. Lump in the throat, teary eyed- all the other forced teary moments were unmoving for me, but Morrison sang this beautifully, and Puck harmonized perfectly. Grade: A+
At the end, Sue did a noble thing and convinced the principal to keep Glee around for one more year (like they were really going anywhere) and despite my issues, I was overall extremely pleased and with the finale. Some resolution for the Kurt-Finn plot would have been nice, since that was by far the best material this year. Nevertheless, a satisfying conclusion, to one of the the most refreshing new shows I've ever seen. Here's hoping season 2 keeps it up!