Season 1 Episode 18


Aired Friday 8:00 PM May 11, 2010 on FOX

Episode Fan Reviews (5)

Write A Review
out of 10
439 votes
  • Unpopular Opinion: Didn't Love It

    Not sure why I didn't love this one like everyone else, the story lines all seemed pretty average. They were good, but not spectacular. Rachel's was the strongest and she showed development, Mercedes made her way back to where she started, and Kurt was overly melodramatic and pitiful (not in a bad way, he just commanded For some reason even though my best friend and several others I know adore Kurt, I find him to be insipid and uninspiring at this point. Anyway, I'm hoping the show gets better by the end of the season, as this is supposed to be the best season of Glee!
  • Very good episode that makes you laugh and cry from a series that seems to finally find its voice, let's hope they don't lose it next week!

    I really loved this episode! Good storylines, especially the one with Kurt and his dad, and some very funny moments. It's starting to look like the show finally found a comprehensive way to deal with the songs, starting them in real time and following up in the overproduced section in somewhat of a dream really felt like a solution that finally works!

    Jessie's Girl was a long time coming for the Finn character and although I don't particularly like the actors voice it didn't sound as bad as some of his other recent tries to sing more rocky music (still trying to get over the whole the Doors cover!)

    The duets between Puck and Mercedes and Mercedes and Santana were pretty good and had me laughing throughout...good to finally hear Santana sing! But the best song of the evening was definitely Kurt's rendition of Rose's that is a show stopper! Amazing singing and shot quite beautifully with the black background I completely felt Kurt's doubts resounding in that song.

    Being a huge U2 fan I hated how they completely butchered the always beautiful One at the end. After hearing that they were going to cover this song I really hoped that Lea Michele would get to sing it by herself without the auto-tune (a girl can dream right?) but with the rest of the Glee club on backing vocals, Finn's solo pieces, the ever present auto-tuner and the rather peculiar arrangements really messed up this song...on the other hand, the last shot with Rachel and that paralysed kid in combination with the way they sung did make me cry.

    Al in al one of the best episodes of the season yet, the only thing that I really missed was the always hilarious Jane Lynch who had very little screen time...O, and when are Tina and Quinn finally getting more storylines?
  • Looking for the perfect record

    I know the credits list everyone's names in alphabetical order to reflect that this is an ensemble show, but Lea Michele is the star all the way. Her rant about how off-pitch half the rest of glee club was is a reminder of how uniquely hilarious this character is written. She's annoying and arrogant, and yet one of the most interesting protagonists on TV. Seeing Rachel sing The Climb horribly off key was a thing of beauty! Lea continues to impress in her range as an actress. How many people can sing a song bad on purpose and make it look genuine?

    Rachel had the titular laryngitis, and it was cute to see her freaking about her ability to sing over her general health. Finn stuck by Rachel which was nice to see, and even helped put her situation in perspective by introducing her to a football friend who was paralyzed. To lose the ability to move seems a lot more serious than a hiccup in Rachel's singing career doesn't it?

    The second major storyline involved Puck trying to get back on top of the High School food chain. I got a real kick out of seeing nerds drop HIM in the dumpster for a change! Puck got the ill-conceived idea that hooking up with "that black girl" would up his popularity, but Mercedes saw right through him. It was a little weird that she still went with it, but I can understand that its nice to finally have someone like that interested in you. At least she knew exactly where they stood, and the situation helped her see what kind of person she really is. Result: she quits the Cheerios. The third plotline was probably the strongest of the three, as Kurt continued to vie for his father's affection. No, I don't think this has been overplayed yet. The trick is every time this story comes up, a new element comes into play. That's why this is the best subplot on the show. This week Kurt had a bit of an identity crisis and after a conversation with Sue Sylvester of all people, (favorite exchange: "Being in glee doesn't mean you're gay It just means you're awful." LOL!) he tried to act more boyish. I liked the take on what Kurt thinks it means to be more of a 'guy'. He's asking his dad about John Mellencamp, he's making out with the school bimbo, and he's wearing plaid shirts and baseball caps. This was amusing but also kind of sad in a way, just the right touch of commentary from the Glee creators on gender roles and inner voice. Brittany had my second favorite exchange of the night: "Let me know if you want to tap this.."

    Three really good stories, and great music to boot? That's all I ask, folks!

    "Jessie's Girl" by Rick Springfield.
    I love this song. Finn still pines for Rachel now that he gets how awesome she is. He did fine by the song, and they were wise not to mess with it too much. It basically sounds just the same.
    Grade: A-

    "The Lady is a Tramp" by Sammy Davis Jr.
    This is the number Puck won Mercedes over with. It was total pandering to her interests, but also funny to see him doing something so clearly out of his element just to show how "black" he can get. A toe-tapping swinging good song.
    Grade: B+

    "Pink Houses" by John Mellencamp.
    Kurt solidly belted this one out, carrying some great subtext on his face. It was brief, it was simple, but it was good.
    Grade: B+

    "The Boy is Mine" by Brandy ft. Monica.
    Holy damn, they dusted this one off! I was like, "Oh man, I haven't heard this in forever!" (I'm flashing back to MTV circa 1995!) Mercedes and Santana faced off, fighting over Puck in a surprisingly great sequence. These two rocked the cat fight!
    Grade: A

    "Rose's Turn" from Gypsy.
    I applaud. Contrasting his earlier number, This one was big, it was stagey, and even more emotional. If you know Kurt, this is so his inner voice, and if you know me, I have a bias for theater. As I said before, Kurt is emerging as the sleeper star of this show. This was awesome!
    Grade: A+ "One" by U2.
    Well come on, this song is excellence. Even with Glee turning it all grand and perform-y, its going to take a lot more than that to damage it. Besides, the context in which it was used was nice, with Lea and the paralyzed guy. Still not cry-worthy or anything, but it hit the message home. Great number.
    Grade: A
  • Tears - Chris Colfer - you are amazing!!

    Perhaps because my own brother is gay this episode really hit hard. But even if it weren't such a close to home story, I'm sure this ep would have struck a very emotional chord. (Oh! I just made a pun, what a nerd.)

    The desperate need to rate in the top number, the desire to be looked at a certain way, respected for things you don't even respect yourself, and pretending to be smeone other than who you are - a theme at least 99% of us can relate to.

    Mercedes story was just as chilling and Quinn becomes my hero again. (Can that girl get any more beautiful??)Finn makes a comeback after being in the boring shadows for a while, adn is reminding me why I liked him in the first place - the jock with more brain and heart than fits his place in the cliques of high school.

    Kurt's (Chris's) final preformance, and the following dialohue with his father STOLE the show.
  • Good episode..

    Now I am finding it hard to figure out the zone this show falls into. While Glee is in the process of finding its identity, I must admit the quality of storylines hasn't gone down even a tiny bit.

    Also, I found this episode to be a refreshing change, focusing more on other characters and giving them a fitting back story and adding another dimension to their character. Kurt trying not to be gay to find a common ground with his dad, started off in a funny way and ended on a very touchy note. We already saw a similar storyline just a few episodes back, but I am not gonna complain. I also loved Puck's storyline this time around. And to see Rachel in different dimension as someone who needs a paralyzed guy to tell her the harsh realities of life, just added more substance to her character. And Brittany still continues with her one liner magic.

    Good episode.