You can't even compare these two shows.
One Tree Hill is brilliant with emotional storylines,deep characters and great acting,with a few exceptions.Also,One Tree Hill is thought-provoking and inspiring..If you find it boring then you are obviously not a very intellectual person.If you are onlyinterested in scandals and mean girls you should just watch GG.
On the other hand,Gossip Girl is very swallow and it might be more fancy or extravagant than OTH but that doesn't make it better.The acting is also mediocre.I love Leighton Meester and Ed Westwickbut Blake Lively and Chace Crawford are horrible.Another thing i hate about this show is the relationships.I mean Natehas gone out with Blair,Serena,Jenny and Vanessa..?..Serena has been with Nate and Dan more than once.OTH only had one major triangle: Peyton/Lucas/Brooke...
Both shows have had "bad" seasons but GG had only one perfect season whereas OTH was perfect all the way through highschool,IMO and the adult years are not bad they are just different.GG's college season(season 3) was by far the worst of all.
Anyway,my vote goes to OTH,of course.
Edited 2 total times.