Grey's Anatomy

Season 6 Episode 9

New History

5
Aired Thursday 8:00 PM Nov 12, 2009 on ABC
8.6
out of 10
User Rating
283 votes
6

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
Meredith finally returns to work for the first time since the hospital merger and is daunted by the competition that awaits her. Owen recruits Dr. Teddy Altman, an Iraqi veteran, as the new cardiothoracic surgeon, but Cristina is not happy about it. Meanwhile, Izzie finally returns with her high school mentor, who needs treatment for dementia, but she and Alex show very little interest in reconciling. Also, the Chief's stressful responsibilities are taking a major toll on him.moreless

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Thursday
No results found.
Friday
No results found.
Saturday
No results found.
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • A pathetic way to destroy Izzie. But Meredith rocked this episode!

    8.0
    The best moment ever about this episode? Meredith and Derek's scene (I think they were in the lab or something) and they go a little something like this:

    Meredith: You know, there was a moment, for like 5 seconds, when hit-by-a-bus guy wasn't George and Izzie had just come through surgery, and you and I had just done our post-it.Derek: Mmhmm.Meredith: Just like 5 seconds where everybody was happy. I keep closing my eyes trying to get back to that.

    Wow. That was really emotional and sad. And true!! What an awesome scene, and Ellen sure is an amazing actress.

    Now what I hated about this episode: Izzie, Izzie, Izzie. Oh god I remember Izzie and Alex's wedding last season and how they made me love them as a couple! And how, just a few episodes later.....like, what the hell?! Hated her here.

    Also the guy she brought with her, did not interest me at all. Nothing about that medical case was interesting. It was dull, stupid and very not-entertaining.

    I liked the cafeteria scene with all of them (except Izzie of course). That was a nice change of pace especially when Alex screams at everyone to stop mentioning Izzie and Meredith says, "This is a really weird day." Haha. That was funny.

    So that's all I got to say. Not a "good" episode overall, but Meredith and Derek's scene really make me want to give this episode a high score.moreless
  • Operation destroy Izzie's character.

    8.0
    I know, I know...her best friend died, she had cancer and was fired but is that really a reason to get so horrible. Especially to Alex. I completely agree with him, why didn't she just come to him? In my opinion this is really bad writing. I don't think Izzie would ever just leave. I don't think she'd refuse to come back and then be unfriendly to Cristina, Meredith - everyone. I did like the Alex/Izzie confrontation though.



    This storyline is a badly written excuse for Katherine Heigl doing a movie or something...I'd rather that she just died back in the premier because this season is destroying her character. I thought Bailey was really good here. Very funny and her concern for the Chief was a good watch. Speaking of the Chief...he's drinking again. I find it hard to care at this point. He's another character they're making very hard to like or understand.



    I would like to see more of Meredith now she's back at work. I'm sick of all this happy stuff, give her a dramatic (not soapy) storyline please. At this point I'm questioning the direction of this season...the stand-out storyline here was Cristina realising that that new heart surgeon was a cardiac god. But that looks to become a love triangle...so really half good, half blah...moreless
  • Izzie is self absorbed as ever. Chief wrestles with his demons alone. Miranda & Adele brings back the humor. Yang finds her cardio god & her potential rival in the romance department.moreless

    9.0
    I enjoyed this episode for two reasons; Miranda and Adele. These two women were funny together, and it was refreshing to see some of the light humor come back into grey's. The return of Izzie was not very exciting. I'm not really liking her character these days anyway, sure Alex is no prince. But he stood by her with all her drama and she leaves him because she thinks he's the reason she got fired. The reason she got fired was because she came back to work too soon and made a major mistake with Miranda's patient. How all of a sudden that's Alex's fault is beyond me? Alex is too good for her. I personally like the couple of Owen and Yang, but I also like the new resident with Yang as well. Not sure which couple I'm going to be rooting for with these two. Meredith's back but who cares. Maybe for once in her life she could try and help the Chief. And the Chief gets a storyline, finally. I would probably drink too if I had to deal with all the drama that is grey's. Glad to see he can still count on Miranda and Adele, Derek kind of put him out to dry. And is it wrong for me to want Sloan and Callie together. I just think their more interesting as a couple, plus their funny together.moreless
  • Chief gets his drank on.

    5.5
    Kim Raver officially joined the cast of Grey's Anatomy. Couldn't care less about that.



    Usually Grey's has about 5 or 6 storylines per episode, forcing one of them to be at least a little bit entertaining. This theory was disproved tonight as the whole episode was just flat out boring. Izzie's return was anti-climatic, Chief's breakdown was poorly executed and uninteresting, and I could care less about the "drama" between Hunt and Yang.



    If this is the direction the show is heading in, I'm probably not going to like the rest of this season. But I'm an optimist, sort of, so I'll remain positive.moreless
  • Chief screws up...

    7.5
    Tonight's episode of Grey's finally put in perspective the lives of Doctors in the post merger era. Chief Webber gets a reality check eventually dealing with the chaos surrounding the merger. Very evidently from the final scene, where images from the last few years flash across his eyes, as he sips his forbidden beverage. I am sure we can expect a whole lot of drama from the chief now, probably one dealing with his resignation or alcohol abuse.



    Cristina meets Teddy the new cardiothoracic surgeon. Teddy initially appears to be a little rusty at her job, but eventually turns out to have some pretty awesome skills and the ability to patiently teach her residents. Meredith is also back at SG after making her recovery.



    And finally the bad news, Heigl is also back.moreless
Ellen Pompeo

Ellen Pompeo

Dr. Meredith Grey

Sandra Oh

Sandra Oh

Dr. Cristina Yang

Katherine Heigl

Katherine Heigl

Dr. Isobel "Izzie" Stevens

Justin Chambers

Justin Chambers

Dr. Alex Karev

Chandra Wilson

Chandra Wilson

Dr. Miranda Bailey

James Pickens Jr.

James Pickens Jr.

Dr. Richard Webber

Joel Grey

Joel Grey

Dr. Singer

Guest Star

James DuMont

James DuMont

Sheldon Morris

Guest Star

Heather Corwin

Heather Corwin

Casey's Mom

Guest Star

Loretta Devine

Loretta Devine

Adele Webber

Recurring Role

Kim Raver

Kim Raver

Dr. Teddy Altman

Recurring Role

Robert Baker

Robert Baker

Dr. Charles Percy

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (2)

    • Izzie is from Chehalis, WA, a moderately sized townalmost exactly halfway between Seattle,Washington and Portland Oregon.

    • Goof: In the beginning of the episode when Izzie comes back with her old teacher and the teacher said something about Izzie being pregnant and Meredith said " You pregnant?" Meredith should know that Izzie can't be pregnant because they took her eggs before she started treatment for her cancer, so she can have kids one day if she wish too. So she can't be pregnant.

  • QUOTES (30)

    • Cristina: Thank you for my present. And I'll try to get over birds on the scrub cap.
      Owen: Teddy's best friend, she was this bird person she loved birds. And um... She died in the second tower. And that's why Teddy gave up her attending position at Columbia and she joined the Army. I told you she'd surprise you.
      Cristina: Thank you.

    • Callie: What's going on?
      Bailey: The Chief's takin' some time off from surgery for a while.
      Callie: Because he's having an affair?
      Bailey: Because of the merger. He's not having an affair. He's exhausted. Now, I've lost my work-husband and my husband-husband.
      Callie: So, I'll be your work husband.
      Bailey: You already have Sloan.
      Callie: Oh, yeah, that's true. What about Shepherd?
      Bailey: Pssh. Are you kiddin'? All that hair? I can't be lookin' at that all day.

    • Alex: So are you back or...
      Izzie: Oh did you want me to come back? Cause you told the Chief you had serious doubts about my abilities to be here.
      Alex: What?
      Izzie: You went behind my back and told the Chief I wasn't ready to be here.
      Alex: He was making cuts, I was protecting you.
      Izzie: You got me fired Alex.
      Alex: Is that what you think?
      Izzie: This job was the one thing I had left, the one thing, and you took that away from me. You interfered and got me fired. I have forgiven you for a lot Alex. I've had to forgive you for a lot, but I cannot forgive you for this.
      Alex: You made an assumption. You decided I did something. You didn't ask. You didn't hang around to talk. I am your husband and you didn't give me the benefit of the doubt. So you know what? I can't forgive you either.

    • Alex: Just explain her to me, okay? Because I don't get it. I don't get her. Meredith: And I do? I'm like you. She's all bright and shiny, after everything she's been through. I don't get it. But you're the one who married her, so you're the one who needs to figure it out. I can't solve everything. I lost the better part of my liver trying to solve everything. So if you want an explanation, you have to go talk to, Izz.

    • Bailey: I'm going to say a name and then you are going to tell me that you are not having an affair with her... Izzie Stevens.
      Richard: What?
      Bailey: That's why you ignored the DNR, that's why you fired her, that's why the two of you were in your office screaming at each other. (Richard starts to laugh) It is not funny. That girl has cancer, and a husband, and... 'ya okay I know it's none of my business but it's now affecting people's lives.

    • Teddy (to Cristina): So you're gonna book an OR, becaause I'm your attending and when I tell you to book an OR, book an OR! (walks off)
      Arizona: I like her.

    • Meredith: It's my first day back. I just wanted to have a normal lunch.
      Cristina: Yeah, well take a look around. Nothing's normal.

    • Meredith: What did you say to Owen?
      Cristina: Oh, that she's gotta go. I mean, he knows how important this is to me. I need someone who is gonna take me to the next level, and he brings me like this Desert Storm Barbie who hasn't seen the inside of an OR in like ten years? I mean, if this is what he thinks of my talent, I gotta break up with him.

    • Teddy: So you and Yang? What happened to you and Beth?
      Mark: Oh he didn't tell you? Beth showed up at the hospital one day, she didn't even know he was-- Ow! (to Callie) Did you just kick me?
      Arizona: That was me.
      Teddy: Okay, wow. So when you called me up one day and told me about this great job and this great hospital you were just bringing me out here as a present for your new girlfriend?
      Owen: It is a great job with great people, one of whom just happens to be... yeah. Yeah.
      Teddy (laughs): That's okay. I'm not mad. I'm just gonna enjoy all the ways you'll have to make it up to me.

    • Arizona: Have you met Cristina Yang yet?
      Teddy: Mmm. Cristina Yang may, in fact, be the best resident I've ever seen.
      Owen: You think?
      Teddy: Yeah, I do. I don't think she likes me very much, but yeah.
      Mark: Ooh. She doesn't like you?
      Callie: Mark...
      Mark: No, you're probably right. Just because Yang drove off the last few cardio attendings...
      Owen: She did not.
      Mark: Burke.
      Owen: Come on, that--
      Mark: Hahn.
      Owen: She had nothing to do with Hahn leaving.
      Callie: Nope, that was me.
      Mark: Dixon.
      Owen: Cristina just needs a strong Cardio attending. She deserves a strong Cardio attending.

    • Mark: You don't think it's Bailey?
      Callie: No.
      Mark: Really? I kinda like them together. It's not Yang, is it?
      Arizona: What're you guys talking about?
      Mark: Oh, you haven't heard? The Chief...
      Callie: Mark, you are a terrible gossip.
      Mark: I am an excellent gossip.

    • Izzie: He needs a spinal tap. His falling could have burst an aneurysm and some bleeds show up on a spinal tap that don't on the CT.
      Charles: And some doctors enjoy torturing patients because they messed up and don't know what they're gonna do with the rest of their lives.
      Izzie: You are the one that got me fired. You owe me this, you little bitch. Unless of course you want me to find that snotty Reed, what's her name? Tell her how much you love her. Cause I will.

    • Bailey (to Reed and Lexie): And doctors? If I find out that either one of you has said a word about this to anyone, I will make sure that you are the ones that require emergency surgery.

    • Reed: Dr. Bailey? Do you mind if I scrub in on the Chief's ileostomy?
      Bailey: Yes, I do mind. That man is old enough to be your father.
      Lexie: Dr. Bailey, have you seen the Chief?
      Bailey: No. Uh-uh. You don't need to be seeing the Chief, either one of you.

    • Meredith: You know, there was a moment, for like 5 seconds, when hit-by-a-bus guy wasn't George and Izzie had just come through surgery, and you and I had just done our post-it.
      Derek: Mmhmm.
      Meredith: Just like 5 seconds where everybody was happy. I keep closing my eyes trying to get back to that.

    • Meredith: How'd you find me here?
      Derek: The nurses love me. They're my spies. And they're pissed that you're desterilizing their equipment.
      Meredith: What else was I supposed to do? I haven't been able to get on a surgery all day. Before I left there were 5 people to compete with, now there 25.

    • Bailey: Okay, I understand that you're under a tremendous amount of pressure right now, and that you haven't been able to spend time at home, and that a man, in your position has certain... needs, and that, when a man is as powerful and as attractive as you are, those needs might easily be met by...
      Richard: Dr. Bailey?
      Bailey: Yes, sir?
      Richard: Are you hitting on me?
      Bailey: Your wife just showed up here asking me if you and I were having an affair. (Richard goes to say something) No, no! I don't want to know anything about anything. What you do with your business, is your business. And I was not hitting on you.

    • Bailey: Oh, Adele. Oh, I'm so sorry, I just sent the Chief into surgery. Do you want me to-
      Adele: What I want is for you to tell me the truth. Are you having an affair with my husband?
      Bailey: I... I am not having an affair with your husband!
      Adele: I saw the way you handled him just now.
      Bailey: Handled! (laughs) I did not... handle... there was no handling. We work together.
      Adele: You spend every waking moment together, you finish each others sentences, you read each others minds. You're more married to that man than I am.
      Callie: Yeah, but that's just because they're husband and work-wife.
      Bailey: Excuse me?
      Callie: The Chief's your work-husband and you're his work-wife. You look out for each other, you take care of each other, there's nothing wrong with it, it's like me and Sloan.
      Mark: Excuse me?
      Callie: Nobody's talking to you. He's my work-husband but he has a girlfriend, I have a girlfriend, but nothing going on between us.
      Mark: I mean, there was at one point...
      Callie: You're not helping.
      Bailey: Neither one of you are helping. Adele, I promise you there is nothing going on.
      Adele: Something is going on because he hasn't been in his bed all week.
      Bailey: What?
      Mark: Really?
      Adele: The last time he acted like this, disappearing, sleeping at the hospital every night, he was with Ellis Grey. He may not be having an affair with you-
      Bailey: He's not, I promise you. I promise you, he's not.
      Adele (pause): Okay. But wife-wife to work-wife, someone in this hospital is sleeping with our husband.

    • Cristina: Chief.
      Bailey: Now is not the time, Yang. The Chief has an emergency surgery.
      Cristina: The Chief has an emergency cardio situation. The new attending doesn't even know how to put in a temporary pacemaker.
      Richard: Yang...
      Bailey: Hey, do not engage. (turns to Cristina) Did you or did you not ask this man for a new cardio attending?
      Cristina: Yes. But--
      Bailey: And did he or did he not bring in attending after attending, none of whom seemed to please you, and all of whom you ran off?
      Cristina: That is not a fair assessment.
      Bailey: Dr. Yang, has it ever occured to you that you might be the problem? (Cristina is silent) Yeah, right. Now leave this man alone and go torture the new attending.
      Cristina: Sir...
      Richard: Yang, do as Bailey says.

    • Bailey: Chief!
      Richard (waking up): What've we got?
      Bailey: An emergency chole, a new cardio attending and your wife is here to see you.
      Richard: What?
      Bailey: You in trouble. Drink your latte.

    • Cristina (about Teddy): How long's she here for?
      Owen: The Chief offered her a limited contract to test the waters.
      Cristina: Look, I really apperciate the gift, really I do, but you need to take it back.
      Owen: Cristina...
      Cristina: Take it back and exchage it for a real Cardio God.
      Owen: Just give her a chance, I promise she's gonna surprise you.

    • Bailey: Everything alright?
      Adele: Richard didn't come home last night and he didn't call. Tell me he's not lying somewhere in a ditch, dead.
      Bailey: Okay, the last time I saw him was... last night, in his office, he was working on the budget.
      Adele: So, why didn't he answer his pager or his cell phone? And why doesn't anybody in this hospital know where the Chief of Surgery is?
      Lexie (walks up): Dr. Bailey, have you seen the Chief? One of his patients needs an emergency chole.
      Bailey: Okay, I'm on it. You go ahead and prep the patient for surgery. You get yourself a cup of coffe. Decaf. I will find the Chief.

    • Owen: Um, I know you think that I don't understand you. So, I got you a present. (they walk into an exam room)
      Cristina: You got me a cardiac trauma!
      Owen: I didn't just get you a cardiac trauma. I got you a cardio god, or goddess.

    • Izzie: I'm not going in there.
      Meredith: You need to let Alex know that you're okay.
      Izzie: I'm not going in there.
      Dr. Singer: Oh, yes, you're going in. So he got you pregnant, so what?
      Meredith: You're pregnant?
      Izzie: No. He thinks I'm 15 years old.
      Dr. Singer: You're gonna go into that school and you're gonna show those cheerleaders that you have nothing to be ashamed of. Those little bitches are poisoness.

    • Meredith (about Dr. Singer): he's wearing pajamas and an overcoat. What did you do? Sneak him out in the middle of the night?
      Izzie: No.
      Dr. Singer: Early this morning.
      Meredith: You kidnapped him?
      Izzie: Can you please just sneak him in to see Derek? Put him on his schedule? Please?
      Meredith: Izzie, you've been in Chehalis this whole time and the only reason you came back is to bring a confused, sickly man for Derek to look at?
      Izzie: Yes. (Mer hits her arm) Ow! Ow! Stop hitting me.
      Meredith: We were worried about you. I was worried about you!

    • Meredith (opening voiceover): Doctors live in a world of constant progress and forward motion. Stand still for a second, and you'll be left behind. But as hard as we try to move forward, as tempting as it is to never look back, the past always comes back to bite us in the ass. And as history shows us again and again, those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it.

    • Cristina: Teddy Altman. I... I've never heard of you.
      Teddy: Cristina Yang? I-- I've never heard of you either. So I guess that makes us even.

    • Cristina: He's ready for an angioplasty.
      Teddy: All right. Talk me through the procedure.
      Cristina: Because you don't remember how?
      Teddy: No, that was actually a teaching moment.

    • Meredith: So how do you like your present?
      Cristina: Who? Private Benjamin over there? Owen said she would surprise me. Well, guess what? Surprise! She doesn't know how to do surgery.
      Alex: Leave her alone. It's her first day.
      Cristina: Why are you defending her? She went to state school.
      Alex: So did I.
      Cristina: Well, she's skinny and blonde.
      Alex: So's Mer.
      Cristina: Well, she's annoying.
      Alex: So are you.

    • Meredith (closing voiceover): Sometimes the past is something you just can't let go of. And sometimes the past is something we'll do anything to forget. And sometimes we learn something new about the past... that changes everything we know... about the present.

  • NOTES (3)

    • International Episode Titles:
      Czech Republic: Vzpomínky na minulost (Memories of the Past)

    • Original International Air Dates:
      Latin America: January 18, 2010 on Sony Entertainment Television (a.k.a. Canal Sony)
      Finland: January 20, 2010 on Nelonen
      Australia: March 9, 2010 on Channel 7
      The Netherlands: March 29, 2010 on Net5
      Germany: May 19, 2010 on ProSieben
      Norway: October 5, 2010 on TV2
      Czech Republic: August 15, 2011 on Prima LOVE

    • Music Featured In This Episode:
      1. Sunny Day by Joy Williams
      2. Vertical Rhythm by Gossip
      3. End of All Time by Stars of Track and Field
      4. In Spite of Me by Greg Laswell
      5. Poison & Wine by The Civil Wars

  • ALLUSIONS (2)

    • Teddy Altman has just joined SGMW as the new cardio attending. Yang, however, is unimpressed and impatiently refers to her as "Private Benjamin" --an allusion to the 1980 movie Private Benjamin starring Goldie Hawn about a sheltered, high society woman who joins the Army on whim only to find herself in over her head.

    • Meredith: And as history shows us again and again, those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it.

      The actual quote from philosopher and poet George Santanaya's work, Reason in Common Sense, volume 1 of The Life of Reason reads: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."

More
Less