Grey's Anatomy

I was rather disappointed. This episode was full of sappy drama. It was missing the classic humor that makes this show work. The double dating thing is outrageous. Two little boys fighting over that self-centered, bratty woman ("I want heat, romance, etc"). I guess there is really only one hotel in all of Seattle. It certainly explains how Derek found Addison in the season premiere. Izzy standing outside all day took the cake. Call me crazy - the only scene that really hit home for me was Addison in the supply closet. Now that was well worth it. And the previews for next week... Hmmph. This makes me sad. But it's still Grey's and I'll need an intervention before kicking the habit.

I just saw it... First off... the coffee scene... Love it!! Especially the way she pretty much talked around the subject of her dream but Cristina caught on... Loved it!



The bet that took place between Cristina and Alex... Loved that! Especially how Derek used a surgery to get Meredith out of that date



Mer: Finn will get another date

Derek: That's okay, he needs all the help he can get



LOL good one! Score!



"My Fantasy is not two men looking at each other"

LOL



Go Meredith! I love the speech she gives both of them after her and Derek's date

The handholding is adorable btw!! :love:





For the rest of the episode

It's nice to see Bailey sticking up for Izzie so much... it was really sad to see Izzie standing outside the hospital btw.. Katherine Heigl did an amazing job on it nonetheless..

Cristina/Burke were interesting too... I love that during that case she realised she needs to help Burke and that's she's willing to do that!! :)

Alex and that kid.. really cute.. I'm beginning to love Alex more and more..

That case was really interesting as well.. the whole 'Heroes' thing she was going through

George/Callie... it was kind of funny.. the whole George dealing with Callie moving in but I felt sorry for Callie... It's nice to see Meredith and George talk though, I mean about personal stuff like that...

Mark and Addison.. I have a different vibe about them then the vibe I had in 'Yesterday'... I'm not sure if I actually ship them or not...

aww... and in the end Alex/Izzie... :sigh: Really cute!

The show really needs to drop the self pity part of Izzie or at least make it more believable. No one would stand outside in the same place for an entire day, nor would someone lie on the bathroom floor for an entire day. The writers have to bring Izzie’s character back to reality and if not, let her quit. Her blank stare at the face of the building had me yelling at the screen. Also, please tell the writers to go find the funny George who left coincidently when new doctor girlfriend showed up. If someone can show me the chemistry b/w the two, I’d be happy to listen. So, when they find the old George, make sure they send the girlfriend packing and ship her to another hospital’s basement. As for the good parts, I think Karev is hilarious, the Meredith dating thing seems to have good potential, and Burke’s struggles are much more heart felt and believable. One other thing, if I just had major brain surgery and my wife started getting mad at me for not being able to come up with quick answers, I’d hope my doctor would take it upon himself to kick her in the shin.

Well we know meredith didnt sleep with Finn, so now who is the father of meredith\'s baby DEREK or mousy little george?

The show still keeps you at the end of your seat. Absolutely the best show , the witers are spectacular the story lines that they come up with are superb.Hopefully this show will end up being one of the longest running show on abc.The casting is unbelievable, its amazing how all these actors have blended so well together, although i think addison needs to go back home, no one feels sorry for her Boo hoo to her she shouldnt have slept around

I have to call this a filler episode. The first few episodes promised that Meredith would make a choice but as it the case they dragged this out. I would have thought she would done it already but I knew better. One thing I kinda agree with one user who said Meredith wasn't herself. I mean she said she wasn't a whore last season, yet she's kinda leading both Finn and Derek on at the same time which is a bit unfair. I mean she planned two dates side by side and of course Derek was going to interrupt the lunch date with Finn. I want to see this Finn character have more backbone if this is going to be the familiar two guys fighting over one girl type of thing. The rest of the episode was ok, highlight being Alex and that girl who was a patient.



LMAO She did a lot of crazy things and for all things to think that she's a superhero.

George & Callie\'s are both having relationship trouble as they may have to cool it down a bit. Meanwhile back at the hosptial, the staff is trying to prevent a patient from having elective surgery. As Meredith is dating everybody from McDreamy to McSteamy. Very good show and that it is no wonder I love this show.

I was very disappointed with this episode!! Meredith for the first time seemed like she was acting! it just didn\\\'t feel real , I liked the parts with christina and the whole betting and her cutting the chicken ,and at the end with the roommated moment! I think the first and second episodes were much better written and ofcourse the first two seasons but I don\\\'t know this one wasn\\\'t as interesting and exciting , and Meredith wasn\\\'t herself (BAD)!

It seems that the lines were not well written at all and rished.. didn\\\'t enjoy it as the previuos one ..

Lots of little things seemed to happen to move the storylines forward.

Mark is now going to blatantly pursue Addison and he did a very charming job of it in the bar. Addison gave Meredith a verbal smackdown and Meredith fully realizes that she deserves it.

Loved the lunchtime betting over Meredith's date with Finn and the fact that everyone was eating Meredith's coffeecake before the shift started.

The guy who was supposed to get his ankle replaced is a very good supporting character with both Buffy and Angel appearances under his belt.

Bailey put herself on the line for Izzie and both she and Alex displayed parental instincts not seen before.

My fave bit was the very end beginning with Meredith's feel me up speech. Cristina laid down the law with Burke. Mark stole Derek's line about the ferryboats and the episode ended with best scene of all. The 3 roommates, Izzie George and Meredith bonding alone in the house once again. YEA!!!!!!!!!!

I really liked this episode of Grey’s! As usual they know how to get the right mix of funny and emotional. Poor Izzy, she really needed a hug! She seemed to be in her muffin trance, just standing out there for hours... Abigail Breslin (of Little Miss Sunshine fame) was so sweet as Meghan - I love it when Alex goes soft! “The pain’s there for a reason”; Izzy needed that. Sandra Oh is so funny, everything she does makes me laugh! Love the chicken scene!



Side note: anyone else agree that it would be economical if Callie, Webber, and McSteamy all share a hotel room? That would cause some interesting waves at SGH :D

Well, the previous episodes were great, but this one fell behind the others. The idea of dating two people at the same time and both knowing about it is really absurd, but Cristina enjoyed it, and I really loved to see the cathastrophe happening! I wanted Addy and Mark to be together, and I didn't like Addison rejecting Mark; you like the guy, don't play the hard woman card! The stories, were rather dull. The girl with superpowers? A guy that wants his knee replaced? They got short with the case Cristina was dealing. And why George wouldn't like to have Callie around? The worst part was when I saw Addison CRYING! She's Satan! She doesn't hide from a battle! She's starting to fall, she needs a special order of thicker skin or something! And Watching Addison like that, mmm it wasn't a good move. This episode was really boring and annoying and I was waiting for something to happen. For me it's a 7

I thought the beginning of this episode was funny, opening with Meredith's dream of a threesome with Fin and Derek. I also thought it was funny watching Bailey basically tell the chief what he was going to do with the whole Izzie situation. Which brings me to Izzie: i was getting annoyed with her as i do sometimes. I understand she is sad, but she's pushing away and being mean to the friends that are trying to be there for her and support her. First she lays on the bathroom floor for an entire night and most of the next day, then she stands outside in front of the hospital for another entire day. However, the end of the episode made me feel a bit better towards her, since she wasn't being so ignorant to her friends. So George was getting annoyed with Callie living with him. I thought he was being a little over dramatic about it, and in a way sort of mean. Good for Callie for telling him off. Alex gets stuck working with Addison again, but again it turns out to be an enlightening experience for him. Addison knew exactly what she was doing starting from the day he told her he wasn't interested in gynecological work. So they get a case of a little girl suspected of being abused but soon find out that she has a chromosomal disorder that keeps her from feeling pain. I have to say i was disturbed to watch a little girl yank staples out of her arm that she put there herself. When she said she had a kid punch her twenty five times in the stomach and once with a baseball bat, the first thing i thought was internal injuries. I've heard of people dying from getting punched in the stomach, and that's after even just once. I thought the scene where Alex and Cristina were betting on Meredith's lunch with Fin was hilarious. Cristina's reaction when Derek came back just had me rolling. Which brings me to Cristina. Burke was annoying me with his feel sorry for me attitude over his situation. He's one of the top Cardio Surgeons in the country and he's acting like a kid. I'm glad Cristina gained a little understanding but also decided to be herself and take the bull by the horns, by refusing to let him just lay down and take it. Good for her for forcing him to try to do what he does best. I thought the end of the episode was funny where Meredith told they boys off. However, she does have a tendancy to be a bit of a tramp, and even though i love her i sometimes don't think it's right for her to be toying with these guys emotions. I mean, after trying to work it out with his wife, Derek leaves Addison for Meredith, who decides she now wants to have her cake and eat it too. While i think it's normally a good thing to keep your options open, i think Grey is being selfish in this situation. All in all i still enjoyed the episode as usual.

This episode had some really funny and entertaining parts. I just loved how George was struggling to tell Callie he didn't want them to move in together. The part where Callie took off her towel in the hallway was just hillarious. I also loved how Merideth was dating both guys. It was funny how she told both guys about her dream, but did not bother to mention that the other was in it. I also loved how Derek interupted her date with Finn and everyone had bets placed on it. I loved how Merideth enjoyed the simple concept of dating so much. However, it got to be a little to much when she got angry at both of them when they were not paying attention to her. I also enjoyed watching Addison and Mark together. It was funny that his plane was "cancelled", and it was entertaining to see her try to resist. I also loved the case with the girl who could not feel pain. This type of case always interests me and I just want to understand how it works. It was cute how they made it into the superhero storylines. The other two medical cases were just ok. I kind of liked them because they related so well to what was going on with the main characters lives.



Izzie standing outside was kind of cool because it showed how she was feeling and you got a sense of how much time had past. I didn't really like the Burke and Christina storyline because it was just about her inability to understand how hard it could be for him to recover.

Meredith needs to choose between Finn and Derek and she had a threesome dream with both of them. She had a lunch at the cafeteria with Finn but Derek devastated it. Meanwhile Megan comes to the hospital with massive cuts and later it is discovered that she has no feel for pain and in the C.T. it is discovered that she has massive internal bleeding. Jasper needed an ankle replacement with Callie and that cause problems in Callie's and George's relationship.

Taylor needs a brain surgery and everything went well but the recovery will be massive and he can't remember the name of things that causes problems with his wife.

Izzie tries to go back to the hospital but she can't.

Ja super mega geil wenn ich etz eifach irgendwas da ine schriebe wo ja eh niemerd verschtaht, will alles amis sind denn gahts mier zwar nachhär nid besser, aber immer hin chan ich denn hoffentlich hergottnanemal ändlich die scheiss serie luege... bin scho viel zgigerig sind das ächt scho 100 wörter??

ummmm so basically the scene that is clouding everything from my mind at the moment is the opener! i was sooo extremely excited to see Mer in bed with Derek, i mean it could have just been Derek and i would have been fine with that one too, but anyway, i freakin love mer and derek so i got really happy for a moment! THEN you see Mcdreamy looking across the bed and you see Mcvet! omg! that was just the funniest, sexiest, greatest scene ever! i wouldnt want to get any sleep if that was the situation i was in either! go mer! nice dream!

Addison hooks up with Mark (Derek's former best friend). Merideth dates Finn and Dr. Shepard. Finn at lunch but Derek interrupts by offering Merideth a surgery. Finn then interrupts the end of Derek and Merideth's date by giving Merideth strawberry ice cream. Then she starts complaining bout how she wants to be treated like a lady and Derek and Finn don't even look at her but they look at each other. Merideth also has a dream bout having a three sum with Finn and Shepard. Cristina pushes Burke's lazy ass. Izzie doesn't make it in the hospital. Karev helps save a little girl's life.

Absolutely fan-frackin-tastic episode!!This show just keeps surprising me, and getting me more and more hooked. From the pilot, where we learned that Meredith's one night stand was in fact her new boss, or as McDreamy himself puts it "I'm your boss' boss", we are hooked! This is the latest of the amazing creations from Shonda Rhimes and Betsy Beers, and i am blown away! I am an absolute sucker for the Merdith - Derek/Finn love triangle, and this episode is choc-full of this dilemma! starting with her fantasy of a threesome with them, and ending with her yelling at both of them on her front porch, this episode shows Meredith living every girl who wyahces this show's dream: dating McDreamy and Finn at the same time...YUMMY! Although it's not all its cracked up to be, she ends up yelling at them when Finn crashed her and derek's date: "My fantasy is not two guys looking at each other...No more dating until one of you learns how to put on a reall date...Damnit, i wanna feel like a freakin' lady!". Absolutely classic.



Ont he other hand, we've got shaky ground happening in George and Callie land. A bit of a fight occurring, resulting in Callie living in a hotel room. Staying at the same hotel are the Chief, following his wife kicking him out, Addison Shepherd, and Mark Sloan aka McSteamy.



Izzy is also having problem of her own, and is unable to enter the hospital, as Alex aptly puts it: "Maybe the pain is there for a reason". The pain of Denny's death is still too much for Izzy, and she isnt yet able to face coming back.



As we can see, the episode is left with many unsolved issues, and looking forward to next week!!

Now maybe it's just me, but does anyone see this plan working out, with Meredith dating both Finn and Derek? How does she really think this will help anything? At some point she has to make a choice and delaying that is not going to help.



I - and I imagine a fair number of other Grey's fans - think she should be with Derek. It's always been him, she loves him. You can't take that away with Chris O'Donnell! He killed Doc!



Meredith has always wanted to be with Derek and I think this is more about punishing him for choosing Addison than about her feelings for Finn. I don't really see that Derek did anything wrong either. I mean yes, he should have told her the circumstances when they first got together, but he chose Addison to try and work on his marriage, it's good for him to have tried. No, he hasn't been perfect, he shouldn't have slept with Meredith again without talking to Addison first, but last episode he did tell her.



Finn's reactions have been pretty odd. He finds out his girlfriend had sex with her ex, at a party he was at with her and he's dating her. How weird is that? I think most people would dump her, with pretty good reason. Seems more like something we need for the story arc, rather than a genuine human reaction. Maybe I'm just too unforgiving.

Mcdreamy being Mcdodgy:-) i love the whole crashing the stinking lunch date in the cafe, christina cracks me up, a mcvet joke it was hilarious! i think ellen pompeo is better this season. the whole i had a drweam about you last night, it was so hilarious when christina asks yes mer what was he doing in the dream was fantastic. izzie should either go back to making muffins or take bold step of faith. really callie comes on too strong for my liking. MCSTEAMY is so back, or am loving this season already, the whole cross atlantic booty calls and the slap was so physo. i get that outburst in the linen closet between addi and mer. it was a great episode

It's sad but this is why Grey's can't be the greater show it could be. It's just my point but, when your main character goes from annoying to unbearable then you must be doing something wrong. And don't let me talk about the damn "Mcwathervers", they're just there for the dummy teen girls who just watch it and scream, and get annoying, and make you want to hit your head; you don't have to pay much attention to notice that they're almost useless in the show. Then we go to Izzie, the most pathetic character ever, and I don't think I have to explain why. All the other characters are simply becoming less interesting (or never were it), with the exception of maybe Karev and Yang, who are the only ones who manage to amuse me sometimes. And finally Addison, who once was the totally sexy and cool redhaired surgeon -the opposite of Meredith (and this is a compliment)- but now is just a drunk crybaby -the same as Meredith (and that's something you don't want to be)-.

So what's left, the surgeries? There was only one since the others got cancelled or didn't make it before the end, so no, there's no tension nor life and death situations.



This is just the third episode so maybe I'm being a little hard on it, but if this is where Grey's Anatomy is headed, then they'll make us a favor forgeting about a 4th season.

Plot: Meredith experiments with her three way fantasy. Derek continues to be a petulant little prick, and Finn may soon find himself over his head. Alex treats a little girl with a superhero complex. Christina leans that Burke is taking a leave of absence while he heals, and Izzie decides to take a leave of her own, sanity that is.



Is it just me, or is this show losing its edge? Does anyone really care who Meredith chooses, or are we all just waiting for a freaking anvil to fall out of the sky and end her indecisive life once and for all? Sadly, this isn’t Looney Toones and the writers will drag this stupid storyline out for the rest of the season just like Yosemite Sam dragging Bugs Bunny’s dead carcass after he pummels him with bullets. Cartoons can be so very violent these days. The child with a superhero complex was a pretty interesting story, if only for the fact that like me, she has the ability to heal herself at a super fast rate. You see I was born with a mutant gene; I’m very special I assure you. I’m suffering from withdrawal as I have to wait till Monday to catch a new episode of Heroes… Just because you don’t feel pain, you’d think you would realize that damage is still being done to your insides. For a superhero, she is a little on the slow side no? Izzie, you are some sort of crazy. I mean season two when you tried to kill your lover in order to safe him, that was crazy; making an inordinate amount of muffins to fill the void in your heart, that’s still crazy. Standing outside the hospital, not for an hour or two, but the whole **** day; that is certifiable! Did she pee, did she eat, and more importantly, did she poo? These are all legitimate questions, since Izzie is a crazy person and may have soiled herself in her quest to have a staring match with the hospital. It would have been great if the chief had been watching her the whole time. “You know I was going to give you your job back, but you just creeped the **** out of me!” Does anyone else feel that she is playing the pity card a bit hard? Setting aside the issue that the chief would never let her practice medicine again, why doesn’t she try going to a different hospital? Maybe there is only one in all of Seattle, just like there is one **** hotel where all the cast members meet up at the end of the episode, right after they get a drink at the only bar too!



Meredith’s dating plan is starting to look like the inevitable train wreck it was destined to become. It seems very clear that she likes Derek more, but knows Finn is the better choice. So she gives Finn the crappy lunch date, which we all know is reserved for guys going straight to Friendsville. You don’t hook up with someone after having a ****ty sandwich in the middle of the day. No, you go home and take a bloated, food induced coma nap. The worse part of the episode had to be when she threw a hissy fit about wanting romance and love and not to have the guys fight with each other. I’m sorry did I hear you mention the word romance? I thought you were more interested in a gangbang. I’m sorry Meredith I don’t think I see anything wholesome in your future. Did anyone else notice that Derek and Finn looked about ready to make out with each other? I think they would enjoy some good old man on man action more than her. At least the viewers (female/gay) are rooting for that outcome. Nobody wants to be that odd man out in the three way, do they Meredith?



Parting Thought: Don’t tell someone you dreamed about them unless you are going to say what you were doing; that’s just rude, ****

If you like my reviews check out www.lifereviewed.com

I love seeing Cristina being there for Burke, and supporting him by finding a way for him to get his strength and dexterity back. I think Burke will recover fairly quickly. Right now he is afraid that he may never get 100% function of his hand back, and that scares him. Being a surgeon is important to him, and he probably can not imagine what his life would be like without it, and at the same time I think he will discover that both surgery and Cristina are at the top of his priority list. But he will be back in the OR, along with Cristina by his side.

I loved the storyline with Alex and that little girl being a superhero. I have never laughed so hard in a Grey's Anatomy episode. The little i am a superhero. it was so funny. Then Alex asked Geogre if he reads comicbooks and he goes on and on about them. So funny. i also loved how Alex went out to Lizzie at the end of the day and asked where it hurts. I loved that Storyline about how your body hurts for a reason. The storyline between McVet, McDreamy, and Meredith is a little dumb. I thought it was funny how they kept coming to the dates and intrupting them. I hope that storyline gets better. I am really happy that McSteamy is back

The dating two guys Meredith is the most horrible storyline ever in Grey's Anatomy. The character of Meredith is getting silly and miserable.



The rest of this story is just ok. The superhero girl ended so plain that it is a great disappointment as well. Derek was a nice person in season 1 and he is becoming more and more annoying, which is horrible. First of all he lied about he's married, then he stayed with his wife while expecting Meredith to still be in love with him but he doesn't have to sacrifice "my wife". Now he's interrupting Finn and Meredith's lunch with a fake smile on his face. How disgusting. The storyline is definitely getting awful and painful to watch.

i loved this episode, the threesome!!! every girl's fantasy. McSteamy was really hot too.

i felt sorry for addison when she was crying, and it was hard to watch izzie outside the hospital thinking about the wedding dress and all that stuff.

it was so funny when McDreamy ruin mer and finn's lunch. and when cristina realized that burke needed help, that was great too.

it was absolutly amazing when meredith yell at derek and finn, saying that she wanted something romantic not 2 guys looking at each other.

my favorite part was at the end, when izzie, george, and meredith end up together like they did before.

I don't understand why everyone's didn't love this episode! Addison's love life to me is more interesting than Meredith's at the moment and I think her and McSteamy were great in this episode!!! I loved it, certainly entertained me. Come on...crying in the supply closet = classic. (Although I am waiting for the ultimate Meredith and Addison show down which I'm hoping is still to come).

Okay now that I think clearly if you took the Addision vs. McSteamy out the episode was a bit bland. Although I did enjoy when Derek stole Meredith from Finn showing his "I'm a big macho brain surgeon" side.

The characters are evolving. By far, the most interesting is Christina (Sandra Oh). Her contradictory personality, one part type "A", win-at-all cost, take no prisoners and the other part human and caring, is exciting to watch. Preston is the perfect foil as he's struggling against his anal retentive, Momma's boy personality. He knows he needs to change and is trying. Christina is changing almost against her will. Alex is also an interesting and complex character. His interactions with Addison and the pediatric side of the business have brought out a side of his personality clearly camouflaged by the "tough guy" exterior. And finally, the Miranda Baily character is a key ingredient in the show's success. Other characters are good, too, especially the "what you see is what you get" Callie, the mostly wimpy, "doesn't know what he wants" George and the troubled Izzy. Unfortunately, the central figure of the show, Meredith Grey, has become the weak link in both the story line and the character development. The relationships she is having went out of style after high school. If the writers don't change it quickly, she will devolve into the character study of a totally self-centered nymphomaniac with no redeeming value at all.

Oh..it went great..first with meredith's menage a trois fantasy and then with McDreamy and McVet playing by Mer's rules..Meredith has the power on her hands...and both Mcs are into her very much...I think she'll choose Mcdreamy coz' Finn is kinda warm and Derek is really hot!!

McSteamy is back in the scene for real now!

and Addison again messing things up!

Izzie's cowardness was really painful to watch! poor girl...I like her so much,and Alex is starting to be nice..First with that "rough girl" and then with Izzie!

Callie and George's desagreement didn't suprise me...coz' they're too diferent!

The episode was not deep but made us laugh and expect more!

I thought this was a great episode, best of the three so far. Lots of comedy relief from Sandra Oh and Meredith. Is it just me or did Meredith suddenly get some personality and better hair conditioner? Addison and Mark were funny during this episode, but not really essential. Some people thought it was just a filler episode, but that was ok by me. I don\'t need tragic medical drama happening every single day here. Besides, it was so funny, I couldn\'t stop laughing anyway. Absolutely love the scene at the end where Alex is the only one coming to get Izzie. So sweet.





"Everytime I think you're boring, you rise."-- Cristina. =)

Alex treats a little girl who shows signs of child abuse. It turns out the little girl has a rare genetic disorder where she cannot feel pain. Addison deals with the consequences of the next morning when McSteamy wants her to go back to New York with him. Cristina is running out of patience with Burke and his self pity. Meredith begins dating both men who each show up during the other's date with her.