Torn Between Two Hannahs

Season 1, Episode 17, Aired

Episode Fan Reviews (33)

Write a Review
9.0
out of 10
Average: Superb
193 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate Now!
  • Perfect

    10
    "Perfect"
    Miley's cousin Luann visits and she thinks Luann is out to get her. Jackson and Robbie try to make a scarier house than their neighbor for Halloween, will they be able to succeed? And is Luann really out to get Miley?



    It was good, I liked the scary house plot more than the main one, but the main one was also pretty good. I think the conclusion of the whole thing was kind of dull, but I enjoyed the rest too much to care a whole lot, so my grade for this episode is a very easy and well-earned A+
  • Luane visits Miley and embarrases her while locking Miley in a closet when she pretends to be Hannah and ruin Miley's secret.

    8.5
    "Great"
    it was a good show. miley just duplicated herself to look like luane but it still was a good show. luane is so mean though!i can't believe that she would do that to miley in the show. miley deserves a better cousin then that and i defintley don't think miley likes luane in this show. miley seems very mad at luane for being mean to her and pushing her down a well when she was little. i think luane should of been punished and they didn't even show when luane was talking to miley's dad about how she was being mean to miley. good show.
  • I just love the hate relationship Miley has with her cousin. When Miley tries to reveal the real evil Luann in her it apparently dosen't work out. But when she gives up Luann ties up Miley and goes out to the party and wants to reveal Miley! Love it!!!!!!

    10
    "Perfect"
    When I saw this episode I fell in love with it and I just kept watching it. I think it's great for Halloween! I just love the conflict of Miley and her cousin Luann. It is so funny and I just can't believe that Luann looks exactly like Hannah all dressed up! Well now I know what she means when she's got the "Best Of Both Worlds" except that Luann cannot sing very well. But I loved the ending when Lilly and Oliver try and guess who is who and when Jackson and Robby trick their neighbor!! That is one heck of a night!
  • Miley's evil cousin Luanne comes to visit and nearly embarrasses Miley by trying to blow her secret.

    9.5
    "Superb"
    Torn Between Two Hannahs was an interesting episode. I liked the joke that Robby Ray played on Dontzig. I really can't believe what Miley's evil cousin, Luanne, had tried to do. Luanne tried to reveal to the whole world that Miley was really Hannah Montana. But I think that I know precisely what would have been a one hundred percent perfect punishment for Luanne after she tried to blow Miley's big secret during the party (Note: This idea came to me after I watched the episode). As a punishment for trying to embarrass Miley, Luanne should have had to work for Uncle Earl.
  • annoying...

    6.6
    "Fair"
    The idea of this episode was...weird. Miley's cousin came to town and she looks just like Miley, but more country. Miley tells everyone that her cousin is evil, but they don't believe her. It was like the boy who cried wolf almost. In the end, the cousin ties Miley up and poses as Hannah to ruin Hannah's reputation. The story in this episode was actually not that bad, but the acting was annoying. The whole country Miley character drove me crazy. She was so annoying. Some of the parts in the story were pretty cheesy also. Overall, ok episode that could have been better of the country Hannah wasn't so over-acted.
  • It's Halloween in Malibu and Miley's cousin Luann is visiting.The thing is that Luann wants to reveal her cousin's secret to the world while impersonating Hannah. Meanwhile Jackson and Robby competes with their nemesis to determine whose house is scarier.

    8.0
    "Great"
    I liked everything about this episode except the fact that Luann is an evil,jealous witch and has always been. Miley Cyrus did a great job playing both Luann and Miley Stewart and Billy Ray did a great job playing Bobby Ray and Robby Ray. By the way, Luann isn't the only evil thing in this episode.The Stewart's next-door-neighbor Dontzig is also evil. I hate Luann's voice she sounded like two pigs giving birth to each other. I also think that Oliver is so desparate that he'll settle for anyone but he also did a good job figuring out whose Miley and whose Luann.
  • I love this episode!!

    9.7
    "Superb"
    I think it was awesome and one of the best Hannah Montana episodes. I'm glad whoever did this put it on here or else I would've been tracking it down on youtube.com. Whew!! Good thing in found it. Thanks! hahahaha hahahahah hahahaha thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks.
  • Wow this is a great great great episode!!!

    10
    "Perfect"
    Miley did a marvelous job on playing Luann, who is Miley's evil cousin. Luann's accent in the episode was so funny but Luann did look a little funny with red lips and geeky eyeglasses and cowboy hat! The episode was well written and was one of the best Halloween episode for Disney Channel since Luann is an evil witch, who tries to uncover Miley's precious secret. The episode also has a lot of funny scene and Miley called Luann different name like "that pig-calling butter-churning"

    and it is just so funny and i can't stop laughing after that. So Rock on Miley!!! Surprise me with more of episodes
  • hahaha its so funny

    10
    "Perfect"
    well this was so funny..what happens s Miley cusion comes from Tennessee..and she jealus of Mileys career so she tries to ruin it by telling everybody her secret..she almost gets to do it cause everbody think shes a swwet Tennessee girl NOT..Lilly and Oliver(who asked her out) finaly believed her after Lilly found out she was Launna was NOT Miley and Miley gets to the Halloween Dance and everbody is dressed like Hannah Montana so it gets hard to find Launna after tey fing her Miley tells her father and she goes home and never got to tell Miley secert
  • hilarious

    10
    "Perfect"
    It's halloween, Miley gets a visit from her cousin Luann. It's been awhile since she's seen her. Miley had bad memories of Luann, and she's convinced that she hasn't changed. Her dad Robbie Ray tells her to give Luann a chance and she does. When Miley tries to be so nice to Luann, she lives to regret it, Luann's a real trickster and she gives Miley a good one. During a Halloween party, Luann goes there disguising herself as Hannah Montana. Miley races to the party with Oliver, hoping that she can save her career and her reputation from her evil cousin. It's hilarious.
  • its was the coolest one

    10
    "Perfect"
    hannah montana is really cool i like how she sings and acts the season 2 is going to be cool too and her show makes me laugh alot she inpires me and her show

    *t

    **h

    ***e



    ****s

    *****h

    ******o

    *******w



    ********i

    *********s



    **********r

    ***********e

    ************a

    *************l

    **************l

    ***************y



    ****************c

    *****************o

    ******************o

    *******************l

    and it deserves o get all the trophy for best show and act i give it a 100 and wat i like about torn between two hannah's is that miley stewart(miley destiny hope cyrus) acts as two person as miley and luann
  • Two Mileys in one episode. Twice the pleasure.

    9.8
    "Superb"
    Miley's evil cousin, Luanne, that looks just like her is coming to visit. It's amazing how someone can play more than one character and they talk to each other and it looks real. This was one funny episode. Luanne was smart because she didn't do anything to Miley to make her trust her and the BAM. When Luanne told Lilly to wait in the car, I really thought that she was Miley. At the party it was funny how Luanne couldn't sing or do anything. She was making Hannah look really bad. This is a series classic and a hilarious episode thats well put together.
  • Miley's cousin Luanne (who could pass as her twin) comes to Malibu to visit. But is she really as nice as she appears to be?

    9.8
    "Superb"
    I love this episode! Miley Cyrus did a great job at double playing Luanne and Miley! Oliver was hilarious in this episode. This episode was so funny and it was original. Instead of the whole predictable "I'm sorry" thing, the Luanne/Miley fight is unsloved, which is perfect for season two. My favorite part was at the party when they were trying to tell which one is the real Miley. Oliver then says "Wait, I know how to tell which is the real Miley! Both of you kiss me!" Luanne says yes while Miley says "Ew!" and they know who is who. I love the outfit Miley wore as Hannah at the party. There are so many funny lines in this episode. It is one of the best. I just think they could have made Luanne look a little more different than Miley. But I liked Luanne's accent. I liked how she said situtation for some reason. This is totally an episode worth seeing!
  • Miley's cousin, Luanne, come to Malibu. Watch this episode to find out if she is evil or nice.

    9.2
    "Superb"
    Wow! I loved this episode of Hannah Montana! It was sooooo awesome. I loved the part when Luanne dressed up as Hannah Montana, leaving the real Hannah Montana behind. That part was sooooo exciting. I could watch this episode all the time. This episode was the best one ever made!
  • In this halloween-themed episode of Hannah Montana, Miley's cousin Luanne comes to town... And it doesn't get pretty!...

    9.5
    "Superb"
    Luanne pretends to be nice to Miley and her friends. But then we find out what Luanne is planning all along, to be Hannah Montana! Later in the episode Luanne locks Miley and ties her in her huge closet. Then she goes with Miley's friends, making them think that Hannah Montana is really her... (Luanne) While Miley escapes from her closet, she tries to plan a way to get Luanne, before she expose Miley's huge secret! This episode of Hannah Montana, is excting because you never know if everyone will find out Hannah's big secret!
  • Mileys cousin Luanne comes to their house. Luanne and Miley could pass off as identical twins. Anyway, Luanne pretends to be Hannah Montana at a party and tries to reveal the secret that Hannah Montana is Miley Stewart.

    9.8
    "Superb"
    Typical someone pretends to be someone else,then the heroes jump in and save the day (the heroes being Lilly Truscott and Oliver Okin). Still like the show, just wish they had more original ideas. I think Miley and Luanne were both played by Miley Cyrus. It was a little weird to see them like that. Its still a fun show. I love Hannah Montana, and this is great to be able to see episodes like this. I really like all of her shows, but this one was one of the best she has. She has good shows but this really is great. Even though it is unoriginal I still reccomend it.
  • This is one of the best episodes to date.

    9.8
    "Superb"
    With full main character involvement, a solid plot, and with the characters acting like themselves, it makes for one of the best episodes in the first season. Miley Cyrus pulls out a fun acting feat when she plays Miley AND Miley's cousin Luanne. This enables Luanne to look exactly like Miley so she can carry out her evil deeds, trying to expose Hannah's secret. Billy Ray Cyrus also gets to play his look-a-like brother, another opportunity for a laugh. Jackson actually acts his age in this episode which is very refreshing, and Lilly is still a great best friend, even when she's rebuking the ever stubborn Miley. Robby gets into his childish side when he and Jackson compete with their neighbor - another fun thing to see. ANd Oliver really comes into his own in this chapter. Well, kind of. He's a player, a great friend, and quick as a whip, along with being the goof-off we already knew and love. The fact that he comes and saves the day makes this episode stick out from all the rest. Every aspect of this episode combined makes for an excellent episode.
  • awesome

    9.0
    "Superb"
    t h i s - i s - o n e - o f - m y - f a v o r i t e - e p i s o d e s , - e v e r y o n e - d i d - f a b u l o u s - a c t i n g , - a n d - l u a n n e - w a s - j u s t - th e - r i g h t - c o m b i n a t i o n - o f - e v i l , - a n n o y i n g , - c u t e , - a n d - a n n o y in g . - i - l o v ed - w h e n - o l i v e r - t o l d - b ot h - " h a n n a h s " - t o - k i s s - h i m - a n d - l u a n n e - s a i d - o k - a n d - m i l e y - s a i d - e w ! ! -s o o o - f u n n y ! !
  • One of the best episodes.

    9.8
    "Superb"
    I really like this episode because it was more exciting than the others. I liked Luanne's accent. Its funny when she says situation. Well this was ploted out great and it didnt have a cheesy ending like some shows have like im sorry about the whole thing and hope you forgive me kind of stuff. It was more funny than dramatic.
  • one of the best episodes

    10
    "Perfect"
    traci/tracy was annoying in It's My Party and I'll Lie if I Want To but in this episode when she was on stage, she was funny

    Miley has an evil cousin, Luanne, who ties her up in her own closet, pretending to be Hannah and who pushed her in a well

    rated 10 because its one of the best eps :)
  • This was a pretty good episode.

    8.8
    "Great"
    Miley's cousin Luanne, who looks exactly like Miley except with glasses, is coming for a visit. she is jealous of Miley and is out to tell the world Miley secret at a Halloween party. Luanne ties Miley up in her closet and goes to the party as Hannah Montana. Milwy escapes an dshe has Oliver come with her to stop Luanne. They grab her behind stage with Miley too and they can't tell them apart so Oliver asks this:



    Oliver: What a minute! I have an idea, I know how to tell which is the real Miley. Both of you kiss me.

    Luanne: OK.

    Miley: Ewww!

    Oliver: (Points to Miley) That's Miley. Luanne doesn't give away Miley's secret and she goes home.
  • Heh...OK...

    6.5
    "Fair"
    This one wasn't high on my "faves" list, but it had some funny things. Like at the end when Robbie gets the kids to chase the neighbor around! And it was an interesting idea about having Miley's cousin come to visit. BUT....this one was just...so-so. They should have made Luanne look a little more different than Miley, I think. And maybe lighten UP on that ridiculously phony accent! I mean come ON! This one is not much more than a time-killer on a rainy Saturday.
  • Miley's "evil" cousin from Tennessee comes to Malbu and trys to reveal Miley's secret.

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode was awesome!!!!! Luanne is my favorite character. That was Miley's BEST role! She was so funny!!!! I bought the episode from iTunes and seriously watched it over and over again!! Luanne was the best and Miley should play her again. Once I saw the ad on Disney Channel, I knew this episode would be really funny, and it was!!!! I hope they play this episode on Disney Channel a lot!!! Also, I think that Emily and Mitchel were good in the episode! Well thats all I can think of, so next time you see this episode on, check it out!!!
  • Halloween

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode is a halloween episode. This episode is about Mily's cousin Luann coming to visit and Miley says shes evil but Lily and Oliver disagree Luann tells Lily and Oliver storys about when Miley and Luann were young and then Luann starts being her evil self. So, during a Hannahween party Luann ties hannah up and acts like her and plans to reveal miley's secret but, Miley, Lily, and Oliver

    stop her. Meanwhile Jackson and Miley's dad decorate for halloween and scare little kids and there neighbor gets the kids instead of them. This episode is really funny .
  • wow...um this is my first time because ive never done this cuz i just signed up....whats this supposed to be about? never mind....i talk alot about things that r off topic sumtimes....anywayz...I LOVE HANNAH MONTANA!!! my favorite show and singer! Yay bye

    10
    "Perfect"
    well, actually...ive never seen it but i keep hearing about it...and its really good! i love hannah montana! i mean sum people trash it and i dont knoe y! its a great show and shes a good singer! did she really sing a song on tv? never mind that...who here has seen a hannah montana concert?! i haven\'t but i REALLY want 2! dont u? i do...but anywayz....i hear this eppie is really good so hopefully i will watch it if i have time 2night since it is coming on 2night.....anywayz...so i guess thats it....by the way yes im a newbie!
  • This episode of Hannah Montana was like the best ever. It was funny when Luann came to visit and she was nice to everyone, but she was mean to Miley. Luann was mean to Miley because she locked Miley in her closet and Luann would tell people her secret.

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode was like the best ever. I saw this episode on youtube.com before it came out and it was so funny and hysterical. One of my favorite quotes was when Lilly and Oliver couldn't tell which was the real Miley. My other favorite was when Luann was on stage and saying, " The other side, the other side, the other side of...." Then all of a sudden the lights had turn off when Luann was about to rip her wig off. I also liked the new song Robbie was singing, but I don't know what the song's called. Oh well. I hope you enjoyed reading the review and summary as much as I enjoyed typing it.
  • Seen it Before

    7.7
    "Good"
    Every series deserves a decent Halloween episode and this isn't it. Pulling out the tired old cliché of the look-alike relative, Miley clashes with her evil cousin Luanne who looks just like her. Miley Cyrus plays the extra role doing another tired old stereotype that all people in Tennessee are hillbillies, rednecks and country singers (Thank you, Jeff Foxworthy!!!!). The cousin schemes to ruin Miley's success as Hannah Montana, but if you pay attention to the plot, the end can be easily predicted. The sub-plot is another tired old TV formula of one-upping on the neighbors, seen funnier on Home Improvement, but here, it is a bit more interesting than the main plot. Jackson and Robbie try to out do their obnoxious neighbor, Dontzig, finally in his second appearance on the show, and unexpectedly get set up as a result, only to turn Dontzig's prank on him. Overall, it's a nearly fair episode I could have written a lot better, and I'm sure Miley's clone, Luanne, could return for more mischief like Serena from "Bewitched" in another future episode. This is one plot gimmick that does not need to be repeated, and speaking of repeats, I've a sneaking hunch that like all Halloween episodes for Disney Channel series, this episode will suddenly and inexplicably vanish from the regular rotation of weekly repeats
  • This is the best Hannah Montana eppy EVER!!!!!!

    10
    "Perfect"
    This is the best eppy ever. Seriously i laughed so hard on this episode. Like when Oliver slapped the pie and hit himself with it then wiped it all over him. It was so funny. I also loved when Oliver asked Miley and Luann to kiss him and Luann was like "okay" and Miley was like "eww." I also loved the line "Get the Hannah Banana cream pie" I am also happy that Oliver was in this. I havent laughed at any of the eppys with Jake Ryan but i laughed hysterically when Oliver was in this. This is the exact reason why i watch this show.
  • miley cousiin luann comes and Apparently, Luannis really a "Trickster" and try as she might Miley cannot get anyone to believe that Luann is out to get her. As Luann aims to expose Miley's and Hannah's secret will Miley be able to stop her cousi

    10
    "Perfect"
    i thought this eppisode was halarious!!!!! it really is why i watch the series! i think that miley did an awsome job as luann and miley!! also i thought that the whole thing with lilly/lola giving luann the idea to reveal mileys secret was really funny! and emily omely osment saying her brothers famous line was a very really good idea! and oliver is so stupid and funny!i found luann shes on stage! can you say priceless/!?!?! and i thought the whole thing with the halloween decorations was prety funny and donzick trying to trick them!! and the bull horn was so funny! also i loved the well thing and if oliver asked me to kiss him i\\\'d be with luann and do it!lol
  • Miley's cousin Luanne comes and she acts very sweet to everybody, although Miley is determined to reveal Luanne's dark side. After Miley and Luanne settlle there problems. Luanne threatens to reveal Miley's identity as Hannah Montana. But she is caught.

    9.9
    "Superb"
    I loved this episode! I thought that Luanne's accent was horrible, but she was still evil enough to make this episode great. There were lots of funny lines, and the plot was great too. Although, I've noticed through alot of episodes that Miley gets in a situation where she gets really close to revealing her identity, but in the end she squeezes herself out of the trouble. It still was definetily my favorite episode yet. In fact, I can't wait for it to come on again! I better go check the schedule . . . but anyway, I think that was a series classic!
< 1 2
More
Less