Audrey and Nathan are called to the scene when a man discovers a body burned like Roslyn Toomey's. They figure it's another of Tommy's victims and the coroner promises to get them forensics and identify it. When Lucassi points out that Tommy is dead, Audrey reminds them that they never found Tommy's body. Nathan reminds her that Tommy was connected to Grady, the second killer, but that Jordan has confirmed that neither one of them was with the Guard.
A florist van drives down the highway. A man, Martin Danvers, leaps out of it and runs off into the woods. The driver pulls over and goes after him. When the police are called in, the officer on the scene, Colin, tells her that the two men ran off and left a girl behind. The girl, Ginger Danvers, doesn't say anything useful. Nathan confirms that the Guard uses florist vans to bring the Troubled into Haven, and they figure the passenger was a Troubled with a powerful so bad that he abandoned his daughter.
Back at the station, Callahan tries to get some information out of Ginger without success while Audrey looks on. Duke stops by for lunch with Audrey and sits down next to the girl, who remains silent. He starts in with her, joking, and manages to get her to talk. When Lucassi comes in with a forensics report, Audrey and Callahan go out to hear it, leaving Duke with Ginger. The girl admits that Duke is funny and they start telling each other jokes.
Nathan meets Jordan at the diner and she revels in being able to take his hands. He says that he's there for business and tells her about the incident with her transport van. Jordan admits that she isn't in the loop but becomes interested when Nathan says that Martin left his nine-year-old daughter behind. She offers to make some calls and tells Nathan that the only thing she's been able to find out about Audrey's disappearances are that they occur. Once Nathan leaves, Jordan goes in the back and meets with one of the Guard members, Lance. He complains that she's spending time with Nathan but Jordan complains that she had to lie to Nathan and that they have bigger things to worry about.
Lucassi tells Audrey and Callahan that the corpse had a bolt gun wound like the other victims and that he was buried for five to eight weeks. He also got a dental match on the victim... Thomas Bowen. They realize that whoever they were working with, it wasn't the real Tommy Bowen.
Duke talks to Ginger about how he lives on a ship by himself and that he has a little girl that lives someplace else. When he says that he wasn't meant to have a family, Ginger says that she thinks the same thing and then complains that she's hungry. She convinces Duke to get some ice cream with her and he gives in.
At the park, Duke complains that the ice cream vendor didn't give them the right ice cream. Ginger slips away when he isn't looking and the vendor says that he saw Ginger talking to someone he assumed was her dad. Duke calls for Ginger and, when he gets no response, phones Audrey. Nathan and Audrey arrive and start looking for Ginger, and Audrey tells Nathan what she found out about the fake Tommy Bowen. Nathan tells Audrey to find the killer while he looks for Ginger.
Lance carries Ginger off down the street as Jordan pulls up. Ginger yells at him, saying that she hates his guts, and he puts her down, stunned. As she runs off, Lance says that he hates his guts and stabs himself in the stomach.
Jordan calls the police in and Audrey and Nathan try to work out what happened. Audrey quickly realizes that the wound is self-inflicted and Nathan suggests that Ginger has an ability to control minds. Audrey figures that Duke took Ginger for ice cream because of Ginger's Trouble. They call Duke at the docks, but Ginger is with him and tells him not to tell them anything. She suggests that they should go play and Duke tells Audrey that he can't say anything. He just says that he has to go play and hangs up, and Ginger leads him off.
Late, Duke is playing pirates at the Grey Gull with Ginger. He trips and cuts his hand on a piece of glass, but simply pulls it off and ignores the wound. He climbs up on the second-floor balcony and jabs at imaginary pirates, and Audrey and Nathan pull up. Ginger tells him not to let them hurt her, but a startled Duke falls off the railing and crashes onto the deck below. Audrey tells Ginger that she's hurting people and the girl tells Duke that he's fine. He manages to get up but then passes out from the pain.
Audrey talks alone to Ginger, who explains that her father kept talking to her in the van about how much she would like Haven. She finally told him to leave her alone and he ran off and did so. Ginger wonders why her ability doesn't work on Audrey and Audrey says that she's special. The girl thinks that her father was bringing her to Haven to get rid of her. When her mother died, Martin started treating her differently and Ginger figures that he doesn't like her anymore. Audrey says that's not the case and that her father would come back if he could. She tells Ginger that sometimes people have to go away even when they don't want to, and then goes over to talk to Nathan. He confirms that Ginger's influence on Duke is wearing off and they wonder why Martin didn't come back. Audrey figures that Ginger's Trouble started when her mother died, causing her to feel abandoned, and that she'll be better when they find Martin. She tells Ginger that they need her help and asks about the Guard, and Ginger says that Jordan was in the alley with Lance and describes her.
Nathan sets up a meeting with Jordan at the cemetery and demands to know why she lied to him. Jordan says that she cares about Nathan and explains that they're just looking for her father. She admits that things didn't work out the way they planned and they both realize that finding Martin is the key. Nathan says that he wants to trust her but Jordan warns him that the Guard has their own way of doing things. He demands answers and Jordan finally tells him that Ginger has an uncle in town, Henry.
Nathan goes to Henry's home and calls to update Audrey. She thanks him for his help and warns her to be careful. Henry comes out and Nathan shows him his Guard tattoo. Henry explains that he was the one who put Martin in contact with the Guard after Ginger started manifesting her ability, but he hasn't heard from his brother since.
As Audrey watches over Ginger at the Grey Gull, Lucassi calls and says that he found a pulp-based cellulose in the corpse's lungs. As Audrey steps away so Ginger doesn't overhear her, Lucassi says that the real Tommy got the cellulose in his lungs right before he died. Lucassi emails the location of possible sources to Audrey. Meanwhile, Jordan sneaks in and tells Ginger that she can take the girl to her father. When Ginger says that Audrey promised to do that, Jordan says that Audrey is lying and asks Ginger to come with her.
When Audrey comes back, she discovers that Jordan is taking a gagged Ginger to her truck. Jordan insists that she's doing what she has to. As Nathan pulls up, Audrey asks Jordan what's wrong with her and Jordan says that there soon won't be anything wrong with her. Nathan orders her to let go of Ginger and Jordan complies, insisting that she did it for them. He handcuffs her and takes her inside.
Duke returns and assures Audrey that he's okay. Meanwhile, Nathan wants to know why Jordan sent him to the uncle to get him out of the way. He figures that the Guard is holding Martin and realizes that they're using the man as bait to get Ginger. Jordan refuses to answer his questions and Nathan says that he doesn't want to hear her lies. However, Ginger offers to use her Trouble to get Jordan to tell them what they want to know. Audrey warns against it but Duke says that no child should have to think that their parent abandoned them. He talks to Ginger, assuring her that he really is her friend, and says that they'll let her do it but that she has to stop if he asks her to. Ginger promises and asks Jordan where her father is. Crying, Jordan gives them the address of the Guard safehouse but tells Nathan not to go. She warns them that one of the Guard is Kyle Baron and he'll shoot to kill.
Nathan has Ginger ask Jordan why the Guard wanted her, and Jordan says they wanted her ability in case Audrey became difficult. After a moment, Nathan asks Ginger to tell Jordan to answer his questions. Once she does, Audrey has Ginger go upstairs. Nathan then asks Jordan how they were going to use Ginger against Audrey, and Jordan says that they'd use Ginger to hold Nathan, and control Audrey through Nathan. She insists that she cares about Nathan, but he asks why they wanted to control Audrey. Jordan says that when Audrey was Lucy, she refused to go into the Barn and almost got away. Audrey asks what is so important about the barn and Nathan echoes the question, and Jordan says that it's not really a barn, and when Audrey goes inside then she and it disappear for 27 years and the Troubles stop. When Nathan wonders how they know, Jordan tells them that the Guard has been around for a long time. She didn't tell Nathan because she knew he'd try to stop it from happening. He admits that she's right and Duke tells Audrey that it's not going to happen. Nathan tells Jordan that he needs one more piece of information.
At the Guard safehouse, Kyle hears someone outside and draws his gun. Ginger calls and tells him to drop his gun and go to sleep. He smashes the phone but too late. Once he passes out, Nathan and Audrey come in and find Martin tied up in the next room. Audrey assures him that Ginger is safe but needs to know that her father still cares for her. She has Duke bring Ginger in and Martin runs to his daughter, insisting that he loves her. Crying, she hugs him and Martin assures her that he never wants to leave her.
Another Guard man slips in and tells them to surrender. When Duke goes for a gun, the man shoots at him and Ginger tells him to go. Her Trouble doesn't work now that she feels wanted again, but the Guard man figures that it could come back later so he plans to take father and daughter with her. Nathan offers to trade Jordan for Ginger and the Guard man realizes that the symbol means nothing to Nathan. He agrees and takes Kyle with him.
Duke prepares to help Ginger and Martin find a new place where the Guard can't find them. He assures Ginger that she'll find new friends but promises to visit her from time to time. Ginger suggests that he come with his family and Duke says it might happen. As Audrey goes to her car, Nathan asks Duke if he's okay and Duke tells him to keep Haven intact until he gets back.
Audrey goes to the station to get Lucassi's list of factories that produce the cellulose. She shows Callahan the files and confirms that one closed factory showed a spike in its electricity at the same time that Tommy arrived. Audrey figures that the killer has a setup that requires a lot of electricity.
Nathan goes to Jordan's jail cell and releases her. He explains the deal and she asks if he believes that she cares about him. Nathan admits that he does but Jordan realizes that it doesn't matter because he never got over Audrey. When Jordan says that she did it for them, Nathan says that there is no "them." Jordan walks out past Audrey, who shows Nathan what she's find out.
Audrey and Nathan drive to the seemingly abandoned factory. As they approach it, Nathan promises that they'll find a way to keep her from disappearing. They go inside and find a workshop filled with tanks containing human body parts. Some of the tanks are draining and they realize that someone was just there. One tank contains Tommy's skin and another contains Grady's. They realize that the killer burned the bodies so they wouldn't know that they were skinned. Nathan realizes that the Bolt Gun Killer can wear people's skin to duplicate them, and use a bolt gun because it leaves a small almost undetectable wound. Audrey realizes that if Tommy's skin is there then the killer survived the explosion... and is out there with another skin.