What if X-men didn't have a Professor X to open a school and bring mutants together. There are people scattered throughout the world that discover they have special abilities. And, people who want to contain those people.
6.0
The problem with shows and/or movies that deal with time travel, particularly going back in time to change events, save people, or stop some villain from doing something bad, is that if at first you don't succeed, you can always try again...and again...and again. Movies like the first Terminator or Back to the Future addressed this issue by making time travel impossible after the first trip by destroying the device (Terminator) or making time travel difficult (Back to the Future). In Heroes, one of the mutants can alter time and space, essentially making it possible to time travel. However, he did not have control over his newfound ability making time travel irratic. This lasted for the first two seasons. By the third season, Hiro Nakamura (the time traveller/manipulator) has gained complete control of his ability. Actually, in the 2nd season future Hiro appears to other characters in the present day forewarning of disaster, etc, etc. And, in the 3rd season, both present and future Peter Petrelli (able to copy others' abilities) are able to time travel, having previously come in contact with Hiro and copying his ability. So, with all these people having time travel capability, why is the world constanly in danger of ending, being destroyed, etc? Having knowledge of a pivotal event, why not go back in time and change history? If that doesn't work go back again and do something different. Bascially, do Groundhog Day until you get it right. These are people who can jump through time, jump through space, going anywhere anytime they want however many times they want. They can relive the same block of time as many times as they want until they die. Yet, if something happens that is counter to their plans, rather than rewind and change things, they let whatever happened continue to happen. Take for example Hiro meeting the female flash (I forget her name) who steals half of the formula. She achieves this by waiting for Hiro to open a safe and remove the formula. Why not go back in time and simply not open the safe, or at the very least, knowing she'll try to steal it, prevent the theft from occuring. Another example, Peter goes to future Sylar's house to learn a new ability Sylar possesses. In the process, Sylar's kid gets killed in a fight with other mutants and Sylar goes nuclear creating an impact crater miles wide. Why not go back in time, stop time, and move the kid to safety. Or, go back in time, stop time, but keep Sylar in conscious, learn the ability, and be on your way before other mutant vigilantes seek you out. Also, if in the future, anyone can have mutant abilities, there must be at least one other person who has the time/space altering ability. Others were shown to be able to fly. There are simply too many plausible scenarios that can occur when time travel comes into play losing that sense of urgency and edge of your seat intensity usually associated with suspense thrillers. And, how much more suspenseful is the world being on the verge of destruction. Heroes also falls in other cliche story traps like talking way too much when the characters should be doing something, like running away, for example. Or, let's not question things that any normal person in the real world would question simply out of curiosity. Or, you are a mutant who has met and knows other mutants. Wouldn't you want to keep in contact with them, if at least to maintain a support system? I'm sure being able to fly, or not die, or read thoughts has got to be overwhelming at times. This show can be better. But, there are definite holes in plot, story, and concept that should be addressed. But, probably will not be, making this show simply mediocre rather than great.