The episode begins with Faith pulling a prank on Hope- Hayley's stomach "explodes". Faith laughs it off saying she's peed in her pants and Hope corrects her by saying it's her (Hope's) pants. The sisters learn that there's a Halloween party invitation from Mrs. Rackett who Faith describes as a crazy woman from their neighborhood. Hope says Faith used to torture her when they were little, playing tricks like "Ding Dong Ditch"- they even Tee peed her house using about 50 rolls! Faith pranks Hope again by tricking her in opening a box. Inside the box is Justin's head dressed like a vampire!
Hope and Faith got to Mrs. Rackett's party and learn that they are the only guests. Cornelia begins to freak them out by telling them the story of how her husband departed after trying to take off 50 rolls of toilet paper on their elm tree. Hope and Faith look like they're guilty. When Cornelia goes to get some drinks, they snoop around the cupboards and find dolls that say Hope R.I.P and Faith R.I.P. They try to leave but when they open the door, it becomes a wall.
Faith is separated from Hope and tries to scream and find her sister. Then she finds Hope getting electrocuted by some sort. Then Hope gets up and laughs at Faith- it was all a prank! However the prank backfires when Cornelia traps Faith and Hope- Revenge is good!
Charley and Justin are dressed as villains from the Austin Powers movie and leave to go get candy. Sydney teases Hayley because her nerd friend Edwin is coming over. However when Sydney sees that Edwin has a hot brother Henry she decides to play a little game called "The Art of Seduction". She fails however when she learns that Henry has a girlfriend and she ends up humiliating herself.
Faith and Hope are locked up in chains in a kind of dungeon. Faith begs Cornelia to kill Hope first- age before beauty! Faith manages to kick Cornelia into the wall of weapons and ends up killing her! Cornelia has an axe on her back. Faith gets free and tries to save Hope. Hope screams because Cornelia is getting up behind Faith but Faith isn't falling for it! Cornelia "axes" Faith too and Faith shouts "Ow," because she was supposed to be hit lower. Hope learns that it's all part of Faith's prank- Cornelia double crossed Hope! Faith knew about Hope's plan all along because she read Hope's journal. Cornelia tells Hope she did all this because she wanted a chance to act with Daytime Emmy winner Faith and also Faith threw in some sneakers which turn out to be Hope's!
The night ends and Justin comes home with a whole bag of candy but Charley is still in the neighborhood collecting!





