Episode Fan Reviews (19)

Write a Review
8.5
out of 10
Average: Great
163 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate Now!
  • What an episode!

    7.5
    "Good"
    Grab some popcorn and set down and enjoy this. I think you'll need some popcorn to get through this one. Its so awful its great!
  • once again an almost perfect episode of icarly

    9.5
    "Superb"

    ikiss was awesome. the reason why it wasn't perfect when the part when the kids were making fun of Freddie when he havn't had his first kiss. i felt sorry for him. but this specail was pretty sweet. anyway i thought the funniest part of the episode was when freddie says that he pulled a prank on Sam and Carly says "What are you tired of living". Also this episode has my new favorite quote when at the beginning Sam says this to Freddie. "I don't play to win i play to get even" That's my new Favorite quote. The beginning was Hillarious. Also what shocked me was when Freddie and Sam kissed. When i first saw this episode i never thought in a million year that would happen. and they kiss again in IOMG, ilost my mind, idate Sam and Freddie, ican't take, and ilove you. AKA Seddie stroy. The best part in the epiosde was when Carly said that Sam went to far. That actually changed the way I acted to people. I was nicer to my friends because of that speech. Overall, it was almost perfect

  • Everyone makes fun of Freddie just because he never kissed anyone. Wow!!! this episode shows just how unrealistic and stupid this show can be sometimes

    6.0
    "Fair"
    Well, I didn't get the big deal of why everyone gave this episode good reviews. This episode was just okay. It wasn't good but it also wasn't bad either. There were much more worse iCarly episodes than this so it's a good thing that I don't actually hate this episode unlike "iMeet Fred". "iMeet Fred" is WAY more unrealistic than this episode. I just really hated Sam in this episode. I hated how she was putting the fish in Freddie's locker just to win but I am happy that Freddie actually got her back in the beginning of the episode. Speaking of the beginning of the episode, I found it funny that Gibby was handcuffed to Sam. I also laughed when Carly was being Spencer's trainer so Spencer can build up some muscles. Gibby throwing hot coffee in Spencer's face was absolutely hilarious. The rest of the episode was just unrealistic and just plain boring. I really hated Sam for confessing to all of the viewers on iCarly that Freddie has never kissed anyone... that just showed how cruel Sam can be and why she is the most hated character in this show because I really don't like her. Carly actually talking some sense into Sam about how Sam ruined Freddie's life was good. Sam actually talking to Freddie was good and when Sam and Freddie kissed was good (I guess) but it's not really a huge deal. Overall, this episode was just okay but it really wasn't a big deal to me... I mean, if you haven't kissed anyone yet, it means that you're still trying to find that one special person for yourself. 6/10
  • perfect

    10
    "Perfect"
    What I liked: the teacher yelling "I am Freddie Benson and I have never kissed a girl!", Gibby throwing coffee in Spencer's face, then asking for water, Spencer tricking Gibby into leaving, the ending of the episode, and various other parts.



    Good episode. I am not a "Seddie" shipper, I watch for the laughs, and this episode definitely had a lot of laughs from me. It was also good for plot development, and it ends in a way that is talked about a lot in upcoming episodes. A+ grade from me
  • It was OK, but...

    6.5
    "Fair"
    You know this episode of iCarly wasn't too bad. At a few parts, I thought it was funny, like when they were showing the preview for that awful movie, I think it was. And I also enjoyed the fact that Freddy finally played a prank on Sam. Also, I liked the fact that Sam and Freddy finally kissed each other! I couldn't believe it! I also liked the fact that Sam actually stood up for Freddy. She actually did a nice thing for him for once instead of something mean to him. But, I did have one problem with this episode which made me drop the score. It was the plot. The summary was that Freddy gets beaten up by his schoolmates after it is revealed that he hasn't been kissed by a girl. And I was like, What? C'mon, Schneider! I dunno if I am older than them, but I'm around their age, and I haven't been kissed by a guy and no one goes around calling me a dork or mocks me by making kissy faces. I'm not embarrassed about something like that but he makes it look like you should be humiliated if you haven't been kissed. Worst of all, a bunch of girls that looked, what, like eight or nine were making fun of him. That scared me a little bit. If people as young as that are making fun of haven't-been-kissed teens then it makes me nervous about what's happening to kids nowadays. But despite that false message in this episoe, I did enjoy it. Grade: C. Teen_Tomboy out!
  • I love this episode. One of my favorite episodes. Freddie gets teased after Sam tells the whole world he never kissed any one.She feels bad so she admits she never kissed any one either

    10
    "Perfect"
    I love this episode. Not only because I ship Seddie, but a lot of other reasons. What I didn't like about is the whole teasing thing. I mean, they were overdoing it with him being teased any where he went and he had to wear a disguise and sit on his fire escape because he was embarassed. I've never kissed any one and no one ever teases me about it. Other than that, I liked it. It shows Sam realizes when she hurts people. Well, Carly told Sam what she did was wrong but it meant a lot that Sam was sorry for hurting Freddie and even admitted that she never kissed any one. It shows Sam does care for Freddie and cares about peoples feelings at times. It also showed us that they really don't hate each other despite what they said. People who hate each other don't kiss. Freddie actually suggested it, and Sam chose to do it rather than hurting him for suggesting it. It was clear they liked it too. This proves that Sam and Freddie definetely have some thing special, even if it's a friendship. I loved iKiss for sharing that moment between them. It deserves a 10/10.
  • iGreat Episode

    9.5
    "Superb"
    This was a great episode, although iSYL was better. Anyway, Freddie's prank was funny and the Freddie, Sam, Gibby chase scene in Carly's kitcchen was funny. Gibby was TERRIFIED!!! I kinda hated Sam in this episode. She was unforgivably mean and evil. telling everyone that Feddie has never kissed anyone. I was glad Carly bit her head off, because Sam really diserved and needed it, to be told off for her actions, because she never is any other time. The kiss was kinda hot, not better than Creddie's kiss though. By the way, I ship both sides. Overall, great episode!
  • ikiss

    7.3
    "Good"
    A very special episode of iCarly here that saw the show's two biggest enemies kiss, so as to avoid going any further without ever kissing someone. This show often gives its younger viewers the wrong message such as misbehaving is cool and has no consequences, but this finally gave them the right idea. Sam was willing to put herself out there to try to apologize to Freddie.



    Factor that in with the idea that this episode was actually funny and you get a good combination. The Spencer storyline was a little bit ridiculous, but what with him is not ridiculous?



    Good episode.
  • A good episode, but a bad message.

    8.5
    "Great"
    This episode is very good, except for the fact that kids should not be teased because they haven't kissed anyone yet, especially at that age. Plus, kids that were like five years younger than Carly, Sam, and Freddie are making fun of them! Come on! They're just kids!

    Nonetheless, this is an episode I do recommend. And, finally, Sam and Freddie kissed. We all saw it from day one. And since iThink they Kissed came out it has become even more interesting.

    Minor details I also disliked are that Sam was eavesdropping on Carly and Freddie. That's not right. But I still like the episode a lot and I give it an 8.5.
  • This episode deals with someone exposing someone else's secret and they get teased for it. The person who told the secret also reveals a secret about themselves. At the end, two very unlikely characters share a kiss.

    9.0
    "Superb"
    I loved this episode. It's one of the few episodes where Sam apologizes to Freddie. (The only other one I know of is iWillDateFreddie). I think that this is a very special episode for a couple of reasons. The first reason is that we find out that neither Sam nor Freddie has kissed anyone and the second is Sam and Freddie kiss, giving each other their first kiss. When they kissed, I just kind of stared at the screen in shock. After coming out of shock, I was like "Awww. That's so cute! They gave each other their first kiss." The only thing I'm wondering is why the heck did Sam keep her eyes open? A kiss, especially the first, is supposed to be special. I would have thought that she would have closed her eyes to enjoy it more. What I'm also wondering is will Freddie forget about his crush on Carly and go after Sam now? I think that'd be really cute if Sam and Freddie got together. I woyuld think that they would share a deeper bond since they were each other's first kiss.
  • Sam does what she does best, but this time she goes too far and deeply humiliates Freddie more than ever. When Sam realizes how bad she hurt him, she tries to make amends...and does something amazing.

    10
    "Perfect"
    I have to say that having watched since the pilot, I didn't think Sam and Freddie would have such a tender moment with each other. I always thought that Sam secretly didn't hate Freddie. I mean, she always makes fun of him, and while she does to everyone weaker than her, she never passes up an opportunity to slip something in. If she really hated him, she couldn't work with him or be around him civilly. She never apologizes or feels bad because Freddie takes it and keeps coming back. It isn't until someone brings up how much she hurt someone does she actually feel some guilt. When it's Freddie she hurts, she really shows emotions. Like in this episode, she's determined to win the prank game with Freddie and does what she normally does without thinking. She tells everyone Freddie has never kissed anyone and when Freddie gets excessively teased and humiliated, Carly brings it to her attention how hurt he is. She actually feels bad and divulges that she has never kissed anyone either to everyone on the show. She goes to Freddie and apologizes. He accepts. He establishes that he doesn't feel like he's living unless she makes fun of him. When Sam admits that what she said on the webcast was true, he casually suggests that they kiss to get it out of the way. What got me the most was the fact that Sam didn't object; in fact, she encourages him to move in to kiss. Now I'll admit that it was strange that Sam kept her eyes open during the kiss. I mean, people have said that usually means the person isn't into it. But I put it together with how she acted afterwards. She was quiet and off-center, as if she was thinking (something I don't think she does a lot of). That made me think she actually liked the kiss, and she kept her eyes open because it surprised her that kiss wasn't bad. And when it was over, a lot of thoughts were racing through her head and she didn't know what to say. It was really cool seeing them share something important and very personal. I like this because it has some potential to go on for a while. Like maybe Sam will have opportunities to date other boys and maybe she won't because of Freddie or maybe she will and Freddie will be jealous. I think it would be great if Sam and Freddie secretly start dating (because they both have reputations to protect) and Carly finds out about it and starts wondering about what she might be missing out on. The writers could do so much with this. I can't wait to see what.
  • Schiender is getting on my nerve!

    8.0
    "Great"
    First of all, Why the heck is it wrong not have a first kiss at that age?!?!?!?! I mean hello, im like the same age as them in the show and like i've never kissed any guy before. So what the heck is wrong with that? What? You get a boyfriend, kiss him get married get a baby by 16 and there! You cant enjoy life anymore?!?!?! See, this is why i seriously hate Schiender's shows. its just so stupid what they imply on teens these days



    And, yea, so Sam said that whats wrong with not having a first kiss. but she had her first kiss with freddie (im jealous XD) and that ruined her speech so badly! What the heck?



    But i did enjoy this episode. there was humor, drama and seddie! So, despite Schiender's stupid message to teens, i really enjoyed this episode
  • Freddie did the unthinkable, he played a prank of Sam by hand cuffing her to Gibby. Sam swears revenge. Which she gets by blurting a secert of Freddie's while doing iCarly.

    10
    "Perfect"
    The episode starts with Carly watching a foot talk to her. Freddie then runs in and locks the door. HE tells Carly that he played a prank on Sam. Carly fears for his life. Sam breaks the lock by force and drags Gibby into Carly's apartment. She tries oh so hard to get Freddie but fails. She swears revenge on him. A while later Carly and Sam are relaxing in the attic when Freddie shows up. Then end up talking about their frist kisses. Carly says her's was with a boy named Ben Hoopsher after eating potato salad. Sam says her's was with Buddy Hinton at a CuddyFish concert, in a pot-a-potty. Sam then gets up to get some potato salad. Carly asks Freddie about his first kiss. He tries to convince her she didn't need to know but Carly wins. Freddie never had his first "real" kiss. He begs Carly to NOT tell Sam. But Sam was listening just out side. During the next iCarly Same tells the world about Freddie. Freddie is then mocked by the whole school. Carly gets mad at Sam about it and guilts her into apologizing. Sam goes to Freddie and says she's sorry. Then she tells him that she's never had a first kiss ever either. They both wish to just get it over with. Then they decide to kiss each other to just get it out of the way. But it seems that both Sam and Frddie enjoyed the kiss.
  • Truly amazing episode.

    9.5
    "Superb"
    This episode rocked so much! This was one of the best episodes of iCary EVER! I loved seeing Sam and Freddie kiss, it was so cute. but it would have been so much better if Sam didn't have her eyes open! this just goes to show you show unsophisticated sam cam be. lol. that's part of her charm.it was really sweet when friddie said, "hey...i hate you." that was soooo an "i love you." freddie is so adorable. and it was so brave when sam told everyone to stop bothering freddie about not kissing anyone. if that wasn't seddie, than i don't know what was!
  • a brilliant episode and a big turning point in Icarly.

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode was a major turning point in Icarly as there were many people shocked to find that sam and freddie may actually have "something" going on afterall. It also spawned something big which we all now know as "seddie". There have been many minor seddie moments but this one is what most people think is the biggest (I disagree I think the biggest one happens in ispeed date). This is the episode that gave Icarly drama, a meaning if you want to call it that. For everyone saying it brings a bad message althoguh it is true many kids this age havent kissed anyone (I'm one of them myself) and we shouldnt make fun of them I think this sort of stuff will happen in all programs and sometimes we just need to look past of them. 9/10
  • after Sam tells one of Freddie's secrets to the viewers of icarly, Freddie's social life starts to decline. on the next icarly, after getting guilted by Carly, Sam reveals something personal about herself.

    10
    "Perfect"
    this episode was amazing in my opinion! people have been waiting almost a year and a half for Sam and Freddie to kiss, and they finally did. there were things that could've been better, but was the only episode that if i had it on dvd, i wouldn't fast forward through any part. that's how good it was. this episode was the best episode that has been made for icarly. i think that for the next few episodes, Sam and Freddie should think about how they feel about each other, even possibly start dating. i know that a lot of people would love that to happen
  • Pranks come to a climax between Sam and Freddie. When Sam tells the world about Freddie's secret on an Icarly webshow. Causing everyone to make fun of him. Sam then tells the same thing about herself. Leading to a special moment between Sam and Freddie.

    9.5
    "Superb"
    This is what all Icarly fans had been waiting for a long time. But the thing tha caught my eye was when Sam and Freddie shared the kiss. She seemed very uneasy about it. I went back and watched that part again. Her eyes were looking away from Freddie. It almost seemed like she really didn't want to kiss him. It was kind of like she was just going through the motions. Freddie was really into the kiss, you could tell that by his body language. I would give the kiss between them as a 5 for effort. The show is good, I hope that this storyline goes very far. There is so much that they can do with it.
  • Freddie plays a prank on Sam, so to get him back, she tells the iCarly viewers that Freddie hasn't ever kissed a girl. Freddie gets mocked, so Carly guilts Sam into telling the iCarly viewers that Sam hasn't had a kiss either.

    10
    "Perfect"
    This episode, though unrealistic, was my favorite of all the iCarly episodes. I say this because Sam and Freddie have always had something between them. I have always wanted them to start dating, even though at the end of this episode, they agree they will hate each other no matter what happened between them. Even so, they still kissed which I thought was brilliant. However, this was unrealistic and out of character. First of all, no one cares if you've never kissed anyone when you are in the ninth grade. Also, Sam and Freddie, no matter how much anyone wants them to, would never ever EVER show affection towards each other. But, I didn't care. I thought it was amazing. I recorded it and cannot stop watching it!
  • Sam kisses Freddie.

    10
    "Perfect"
    It is the moment we have all been waiting for, the moment that Freddie & Sam kiss. It looks like they are going to start dating. We all know they don't really "hate" each other. This episode started out pretty innocent, Sam ruining Freddie's life & Carly hating Sam for it. I really want Carly to find out that Sam & Freddie kissed. The football plot was very dry for me. Gibby was annoying in ways. I loved that Sam & Carly movie. It was hilarious. It was a terrible movie. That is the plot formula for every teen girl movie. Amazing episode.
More
Less