Nickelodeon (ended 2012)





ICarly Fan Reviews (543)

Write A Review
out of 10
2,675 votes
  • Overall, a pretty good show

    The first 3 seasons were alright, there were some good episodes here and there but seasons 4-7 were awesome. I remember how much funnier the jokes were in the later seasons as well as how much better the episodes were in genereal. The last season was probably the funniest season and it was a lot funnier compared to season 1 in my opinion, I remember they had one episode where they went to the tv show Pawn Stars which actually had Rick Harrison in it. I would say seasons 1-3 were alright but the show became a lot better in the later seasons when the characters were better developed and the characters had a lot more funnier jokes.
  • iLove this show

    I like to see you in real life some time Miranda
  • The last good sitcom before the downfall of Nickelodeon

    When Drake and Josh & Zoey 101 was nearing their end, iCarly was one of Dan Schneider's next projects. It involved a group of children putting together a webshow and getting caught up into the many antics that happen throughout the series. The sitcom was great from Seasons 1-3, but it went downhill in Seasons 4-7. The finale ended the series on a positive note.

    - - - - - - - - - - -

    I thought the first season was great, with their memorable plots that actually had some humour. For my favourite episode, I actually liked the idea of the gang getting their own television adaption and then realising the changes that ruined what made their webshow popular. It pretty much shows why some internet shows shouldn't even get television adapations. Rating: 8.5/10

    - - - - - - - - - - -

    Season Two had their ups and downs. It included one of the worst episodes of the series known as iMeetFred. While there was that, there was still iTakeOnDingo, which is still one of my favourite television episodes. Rating: 5.5/10

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    Season Three was the final good season and the beginning of a new era for Dan's works. It had one of the best episodes known as iPsycho and was a step up from Season Two, but not as good as the first season. Rating 7/10

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    Season Four had a change of style which started with a room makeover in it's season premiere. This season was shorter than usual and had a fair share of hit (iGetPranky) and miss (iPitytheNevel) episodes. There was also the Victorious crossover, which was pretty good. Rating: 6/10

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    Season Five was when things started to get romantic. It began with the four-parter picking up from iOMG that started to spark debates over couples. Aside from that, it was still on the same page on Season Four, but it's certainly an improvement. Rating: 6.5/10

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    Season Six was when the show was beginning to show it's age and starting to lose their charm. The actors were all grown up and things just didn't feel the same anymore. Aside from that, it was the shortest iCarly season, having more cleverly-written episodes. Rating: 7.5/10

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    Season Seven was the final season of this show. The jokes and plots were getting stale due to the lack of ideas for episodes. It felt like the plots were beginning to feel cut off. It started with iShockAmerica (called iShockTheWorld where I live) with Gibby embarrassing himself on live television. I thought that special was mediocre and rushed, but better than iGoToJapan in my sense.. iGoodbye was one of best finales I have ever seen. It really enticed me that this was one of the longest-running Nick sitcoms with other 100 episodes. The rest of this season was as good as Season Five. Rating: 7/10

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    I don't know why this show gets a lot of hate, but i really liked it during it's time. Sure, it my be girly but I really liked it for what it was. The overall premise of this show was pretty interesting for it's time and was one of the last good shows Dan produced. Seasons 1-3 will always be superior.

    - - - - - - - - - - - -

    Overall Score: 7/10
  • A Show That I Feel Has Some Huge Issues, And Some Small Good Elements

    When I first saw ICarly for the first time back in 2007, I was instantly bored by it. At the time, I didn't think it was bad, I was just bored. However, as the years passed, I surprisingly had a larger dislike for it, up to the point that I realized it seemed like a very uncomfortable show. The story is about a girl named Carly, a calm & happy go lucky girl who starts a web channel with her best friends: Sam, this mean scoundrel, & Freddy, this wimpy nerd. What's the biggest problem with this show? I think I already addressed that, the three main characters are not only bland, but obnoxious & one of which is what I consider part Satan. Carly is just a typical happy, almost problem free girl. Freddy is the loser that everyone picks on(at some points even for the most stupid reasons). Then you got Sam, the absolute worst character of this entire show, who seems like she came out as a character from "Family Guy", she is incredibly mean for the most unreasonable things. Not only that, but the show itself has a mean spirited atmosphere to it, up to the point that I almost felt unclean while watching the show. There are some exceptionally good things about the show, some of the side characters are funny. Spencer is a likeable goofball who is the big brother of Carly. Another example is the mom of Freddy, her reactions can be sometimes fun to watch. Even the shows writing for most of the episodes isn't surprisingly that bad, I did get a fine laugh once in a while, but the laughing mainly came from the side characters. Overall: ICarly is a show that is too uncomfortable for me to watch as it's main characters seem very unlikable, it has a mean atmosphere to it, and did I mention it has that annoying laugh track to it?

    1.5/4 Stars
  • iCarly Review

    I think iCarly is a decent show. I loved watching iCarly growing up. It was one of those nickelodeon shows that I liked when Nickelodeon was going downhill. Their bits on their web show are unique, and I loved the guests that appear on the show. I even love Spencer's subplots in most episodes. The writing in most episodes are stellar, and funnyHowever, iCarly definitely has it's problems. One being the SEDDIE timeline. Sam is my least favorite character on the show, and the show really lost my interest when Sam and Freddie started dating. My second Problem is Carly dating Nonstop. Carly back in seasons 1-4 was a pretty cool character. She was the voice of reason to Sam and Freddie, and she was funny. But, in seasons 5 and 6, my least favorite seasons, She became out of character when she was dating boys multiple times. My third problem with the show, which is the biggest problem are the episodes that are bad such as iMeet Fred, iLost my Mind, iQ, iQuit iCarly, and iPear Store. I'm kind of glad season 7 improved from seasons 5 and 6, because despite season 7 being the final shortest season, it had some episodes that I enjoyed. Overall, Aside from all of the issues I have with the show, I still think of iCarly as a Good show. I enjoyed watching it from the time it came on, to the emotional series finale: iGoodbye. It is FAR from amazing as Drake & Josh was, but it was still enjoyable to watch. Like I said, it was one of the last good shows that came on Nickelodeon, besides SpongeBob, and Harvey Beaks. I give the show a 7 out of 10! Good Job, Dan Schneider! Good Job!
  • icarly

    i love you icarly i watch your show
  • The show that officially lowered the quality of sit-coms

    I used to watch Disney Channel first sit-coms (before it became a teen girl channel), like Hannah Montana or Zack&Cody. They were not the best sitcoms you ll see, but for the most parts they were funny enough, without being annoying. But when the worst Tv writer of all time, Dan Schneider, came in, the television quality of this kind of shows died.

    He created Drake&Josh, who was damn funny, but only because of the two main actors. Man, they were great. They managed to keep funny and likable an horribly written show. If you really think of the stupid premise, the plots, the characters, you will see with mediocre actors it would have been the typical Dan Schneider's trash.

    And then came ICarly, the worst show ever been on television.

    They put a laughtrack at every single line to be sure that kids are stupid enough to laugh.

    They totally destroyed the meaning of "nonsense humour", which is a really difficult and sophisticated art, and turned it in "anything with no sense", with jokes, lines or scenes that make absolutely no sense, but with a laughtrack they are funny. Right?

    What this show thinks is funny is: physical and verbal abuse towards weak kids\people(they are losers! funny!), people pathetically crying or bitching, and those gags Carly and Sam do in their on line show; i mean, Dan Schneider gang really think teenagers are so stupid? who would ever watch that show Carly and Sam do? it has absolutely no sense, ever.

    The worst thing of the show and the worst character of the history of sitcoms is Sam. She is a bully, she is stronger than anyone, she beats anyone especially the so-called losers(because its funny, you know!), everybody is scared by her, and nobody ever stop her. Great stuff, great comedy. She calls herself a misanthropic and she hates everyone, but then he does all those stupid things for the show with Carly, like the most friendly and funny person there is. Great writing.

    Anyway, i'm done. The only good stuff in this show come from Spencer. That's it. After Icarly became so succesful, all the other sitcoms understood that qualities is not important, just put some scene with no sense, give the chacacters technological accessories to make it modern, and fill it with casual laughtracks: the show is done. Fantastic television folks.

  • too many hobo jokes

    The show was great. I really liked it and it was one of the only shows that made me laugh out loud. To me, Spencer made the entire show. I love the guy so much and he really outshined the other characters. At the same time, I couldn't help but cringe at some of the jokes. The word "hobo" was way overused and actually started to ruin it for me, and I liked Gibby, but him taking off his shirt and yelling "gibbeh" was only funny the first time to be honest. I really liked the show and how different it was, but I think they tried too hard to make the show "quirky" and overdid it. A lot of the scenarios were a bit of a stretch. As I'm thinking about this, I'm realizing that without Spencer the show wouldn't have lasted as long as it did.
  • iThink this show is annoying.

    I originally gave this a 3, mainly because the first season wasn't all that bad. I lowered it to a 1 recently. Anyways, I hate this show for many reasons. First of all, the humor is TERRIBLE. There are way too many jokes about hobos. Why do they need to insult homeless people? That's wrong. Second of all, it teaches HORRIBLE morals. Carly is a spoiled brat, and all Sam does is beat up Freddie. This is taken to be FUNNY. Crazy. Another awful thing that is a "joke" is whenever Gibby takes his shirt off. NOBODY NEEDS TO SEE THAT. Overall, this show is pathetic.
  • Awesome

    Overall, iCarly is a really great show. It's hilarious and entertaining. I found almost every episode of every season in the show to be an enjoyable experience. They were all just so fun to watch because the plots were so well written. Almost none of the episodes ever end in a cliffhanger. They either end just the way we would want them to, or they end in a different way than what we would expect. If it ends the second way, it can either be satisfying or disappointing depending on what happens. Every episode had an interesting story. All the episodes were good, but I found the later ones to grow stronger in potential and appeal factor than the earlier ones tended to be. When you compare the early ones to the later ones, the early ones sucked. I'm not saying they really do suck. I'm saying they suck COMPARED to the later ones. Each episode consists of a web show and a plot. The web shows are just stupid, pointless, silly, and weird, but I still like them in a way whether they're funny or not. And the plots are just awesome and keep me coming back for more every time. This claims to be a kids show but adults may like it just as much too and there's nothing wrong with that. This and Victorious are my favorite shows on Nickelodeon. This show often seems to be centered around a problem or something bad happening such as with characters like Nevel, Chuck, and Nora, who everyone hates, but in a good way to make it fun and amusing. That's very ironic. The only thing I don't like is Sam bullying and abusing Freddie both verbally and physically and he doesn't even have the guts to stand up for himself. It's not funny. It's just mean, cruel, obnoxious, and immature and can send kids the wrong message. But then in season 3 she started being nicer to him but was still a little mean and abusive, but by season 4 and until the very end of the show, she pretty much became nice and respectful to Freddie just like Carly and was never mean or abusive to him anymore and I was very happy to see a good change in the way she treated him and a strong bond between their friendship then. We saw a strong maturing development in her character's attitude towards him. Overall an awesome show. I wish it had gone 1 or 2 more seasons because it was getting better. Don't know why season 5 still hasn't come out on DVD yet and am pissed about it. It's the last one. End of review.

  • To AlexMan586

    iCarly is not a "reality" show.
  • A clever show

    made its own identity as a show..

    re runs never gets old, SPENCER made the show so fun to watch
  • LOL, more like iCrappy.

    Nickelodeon, I wish you never aired stupid reality shows.
  • fantastic but sadly it ended

    i was bored at home so i started to turn on the tv and then i watched this show for the first, and i was like this show is fantastic! :} but sadly it
  • It was okay...

    Don't get me wrong, I don't hate the show, it's funny, but I kinda agree with some of the people who dislike the series. (Many blame the series for the Nickelodeon change) Now I don't mean to sound critical, but what made me feel a little gray is that current or future TV writers would be negatively influenced by the simplistic quality of writing and/or plot style in TV shows, like iCarly, Hannah Montana and The Big Bang Theory (in my opinion).
  • why the mid 2000's to to the 2010's don't mean nothing to me.

    This show sucked since the very first episode,it was what started the down fall of nickelodeon and it was five years of torture,i did nothing to deserve that totrute from that terrible show,Miranda Cosgrove will NEVER be as great as AMANDA BYNES and i mean NEVER because AMANDA BYNES set the bar and ladder way to high for anybody to climb or reach,2007 to 2012 so glad that Icarly is OVER.

    *10 second laugh track*

  • It looked like a good idea, but it got terribly executed.

    iCarly is one of those shows that may have sounded promising with its clever premise, but it got awfully executed on television. The show is about a teenager named Carly Shay who produces a webshow called iCarly were they do the most random stuff onscreen. in her apartment building, She lives with her older brother, Spencer, and has friends like Sam and Gibbie. The premise is creative, and most shows that had good premises were usually executed awfully, and iCarly is no exception. The first season of the show was pretty good. There was some pretty funny moments, it had the right amount of randomness, and it had something going for it. But after the episode iMeet Fred aired, the show just turned into a mean spirited and cruel pile of junk.

    The characters are too mean sprited and cruel hearted, and are barely likeable. Carly is a whiny spoiled brat who complains about everything and it's so obnoxious. Sam is quite possibly the meanest protagonist ever portrayed in a show. She is always so rude to Freddie for no reason, and even goes as far as hitting him with objects like a tennis bat, makes jokes about hobos (seriously what's so funny about them?), and pushes every aside like they mean nothing to her. Freddie was the only one who could be likeable at times, I envied him anytime he was being hurt by Sam. The acting is just abysmal, if that's the nicest word for the acting. All of the characters either underreact or overreact themselves a lot. The humor is pretty much just juvenile humor that feels too inappropriate or gross, and a lot of it is about hobos or something about fried chicken. Again, what's so funny about hobos? Mocking the poor is just cruel. In terms of inappropriate and gross humor, in one episode they refered to boobs 3 times, which is pretty inappropriate for a kids show, and an example of gross humor would be in one episode a kid named Jermy (who is called Germy due to his constant sneezing) sneezed on the camera and we got to see a close up of his snot which really wasn't necessary.

    The random use of humour in the first season felt pretty funny, but now its unnecessary and goes overboard with randomness to the point were it's not funny anymore.

    The morals are just awful and no children should learn these type of morals. The episode iMeet Fred insists that it's not ok to have a different opinion, super good moral indeed NOT. That has got to be one of the messed up morals ever in a TV Series. No offense to iCarly fans, but after Season 1, the show became unwatchable and mean sprited. The morals are terrible and untruthful, the humor feels too juvenile, the characters are cruel hearted and unlikable, and the acting is atrocious.
  • Fantastic!!!!!!

    GIVE ME THE PIE!!!! you'll love it!
  • Decent

    Not bad, not good either, when I was younger I was a fan of this show. But then I realized it wasn't as good.
  • Ah, here we go again...

    iCarly is a Nickelodeon show created by Dan Schneider. The show did end recently after the final episode entitled: I have watched a lot of iCarly before giving a final judgement so please keep that in mind first. OK, let's begin the review!


    The concept of this show is based around Carly Shay, a teenage girl who runs a web show with her two best friends (Sam Puckett and Freddie Benson). Also, Carly lives in an apartment at Bushwell Plaza with Spencer, her older brother who is (or was) a lawyer turned artist.

    OK, so far the plot doesn't seem to bad. The idea of a show within a show actually sounds promising but the execution is actually mediocre.

    So, iCarly started when the gang were forced to judge a talent show as a punishment. When Carly and Sam made jokes about Ms. Briggs, Freddie filmed it and the video got millions of views on SplashFace and things went from there.

    OK, the only thing that questions me in the plot so far is the fact that Carly and Sam got millions of views on a video in seconds. Other than that, the plot is fine I guess.


    The characters in the show don't really interest me that much to be honest. It seems like the creators of iCarly got the stereotypical personalities and spent 5 minutes developing them.

    Carly: Being the main character of the show, Carly is usually the sweet teenage girl who always tries to fix people's problems. The main thing I don't like about this character is the fact that she bosses her older brother around and sometimes she tends to act like a three year old when she doesn't get her way (for example: the MMA fight episode). Also, she tends to act as one of Sam's followers whenever Freddie is abused by her and this doesn't set a good example for children. I feel that Miranda Cosgrove (the actress for Carly) doesn't really fit this role, in my opinion she was better as Megan from Drake and Josh.

    Sam: She is one of Carly's best friends who is a tomboy with an obsession for food and fighting. I don't particularly like Sam's character either because she abuses Freddie way too much and she pretty much likes to criticize him every 5 seconds. Also, she starts fights for no reason and she has also been in prison way too many times for illegal activities. At one point, she put herself in a mental hospital because she liked Freddie and the gang busted her out (again, doesn't set a good example). I do admit that she can have some nice moments though.

    Freddie: One of the few characters I tend to pity a lot. He pretty much serves a purpose as a punching bag and target for abuse in 99% of iCarly episodes and he doesn't really have a backbone whenever he tries standing up to Sam. Also, he did appear to be a stalker in Season 1 due to the fact that he was obsessed over Carly. His character did grow on me in the later seasons though.

    Spencer: He is the older brother of Carly who was a lawyer for three days and he is now an artist. To be honest, I don't see him as a guardian, he comes across as pretty irresponsible and he seems too lenient, expect his leniency isn't on the same level as Jessie Prescott's from Disney's At times, he can act like a child on drugs but there are times where he does become serious every now and then.

    Gibby: I don't have much to say about him other than the fact that he is a target for fat jokes, which irritates me a lot.

    Nevel: He is the person who has been the rival of the iCarly gang since he reviewed their show. He does have an obsession for ruining iCarly and he is another target of abuse.


    In earlier seasons of iCarly, the jokes weren't so bad but they started getting overdone and flat to the point where it isn't even funny anymore.

    Moral value:

    I don't really see much moral value in iCarly, it seems like it's teaching children the wrong things and it seems inappropriate at times.


    I have decided to give this show a 3.0. It does have potential but it seems like the creators screwed up the show in some ways.
  • Why Do People Like This?

    This Show is Boring
  • i love your show.10

    i wish i could be there with u. u rock.

  • iBoring.

    This is one of the main reasons why Nickelodeon has gone down the drain. This show is overrated and is stupid, much like Adventure Time. Also, note that this is made by Dan Schneider, who makes the worst shows imaginable. If you want to know a guy who makes the BEST shows ever, try shows that invole Craig McCracken.
  • nahhhhhh


    One of the best shows in the history of the world like all Dan Scnheider's shows is incretable funny and intreresting maby the best show by Dan Schneider and one of the best on TV.
  • Great Show

    To ReviewGuy AKA Nintendogirl98 AKA mewtwo151, you need to watch the show closer if you claim there's "no minorities". T-Bo and The Principal (the guy who played Tuvok on Star Trek: Voyager) were both [Black] recurring characters. Socko [although never seen on screen] was Hispanic. There were of course likely plenty of others who probably appeared in single episodes.
  • I don't know why I ever liked garbage.

    I use to like this show a lot but looking back on it this show is really upsetting.

    this will be split up into 2 parts Episodes, Characters


    icarly is a terrible show with an annoying laugh track that plays ALL THE TIME! even when an unfunny joke is being played. This show has terrible morals. Morals are either entirely forgotten by the characters or aren't even mentioned. an example is during the SamxFreddie arc where Carly tells sam and freddie to sort out their own problems and then she solves one of their problems in the very next episode The most infamous example of unfriendly moral is imeetfred what the fanbase can agree on as the WORST EPISODE in the entire series. where Freddie is hated on (and even threatened with his life) for an opinion (and he was pretty nice about it too) The worst part about it is the fact that Sam beat him up with a Tennis Raquet because he wouldn't apologize for saying "I just don't think Fred is all that funny" another terrible episode is "isellpennytees" where Sam enslaves a group of children (And this is played for laughs) My least favorite episode has to be "idate a bad boy" when Carly starts to act like a slut for no reason at all. disrespects her brother and then dumps her boyfriend for such a shallow reason that teaches kids that you will be dumped or not be cool for having unpopular interest.


    Dan Schneider has a serious problem with creating characters

    Carly: the main character of any Dan schenider show (Zoey,Tori) an bitchy Mary Sue who solves everyone's problems and get's straight A's Has no personality and begs for attention and cries when she doesn't get what she wants (she even says this in an episode) The only personality trait wikipedia can come up with is that she is shallow. Carly is also shown to not have any other friends than Sam and Freddie. Sam talks to other girls and has another friend named Wendy and Freddie is in tons of clubs but Carly is usually always shown alone because no one like a bitch. (I like Miranda Cosgrove though)

    Sam. I love Jeanette MCcurdy but her character Sam is such a terrible person. She bullies everyone around and does not get any karma or payback. every time she hurts Freddie, it is played for laughs (If the tables were turned and if it was Freddie who was the abuser, Freddie would be the most hated person on the show)

    Freddie, Okay, you guys get it I love the actor but hate the character. Freddie is a doormat nerd who can't stand up for himself

    Spencer, So stupid and irresponsible

    Gibby, once he stop taking his shirt off I stopped caring about him.

    there are no minorities in the show (which can be a case of fridge brilliance because Seattle is one of the whitest cities in America) and maybe it's a good thing because Minority are always treated poorly in Dan Schneider shows. overall icarly is a terrible show. final score 1/10

  • I used to love this show, but not I don't anymore.

    When I was younger, I used to be a desperate fan of iCarly. Now I don't really like it anymore. Sam is an extremely unlikable character, and seeing her on Sam and Cat(which I'm falling behind on) they put her cruel personality on an overdrive, which means she is even worse on the new show. The laugh track plays all the time, and it got repetitive fast. I feel sorry for the people who grow up on Nick. If you're searching for a good Dan Schneider show, watch Drake and Josh, you'll have a much better time with the stepbrothers.
  • I love iCarly but...

    I love the show iCarly but as I was watching I noticed 4 things.

    1. Why is it so immensly popular? The webshow i mean. It's not funny just slightly annoying and stupid. If iCarly was a real webshow I wouldnt watch it.

    2. Carly is kind of a brat. (KINDA not by much)

    3. That Messin With Lewbert segment is so cruel. Basically all they do is humilate Carly's doorman Lewbert (ill admit hes annoying) and put it on the internet. Just cause you dont like someone doesnt mean you do something like that. Whats even worse is this is aimed at little kids so now they're gonna do it just because iCarly did it.

    4. Why do they always say Carlys hot? She's not that pretty. I think Sams cuter.

    one more thing i noticed is their sense of humor is stupid. seriously whats so funny about making fun of someones boobs? or a fake pie?
< 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10