iCarly

Favorite
6226
Nickelodeon (ended 2012)

USER EDITOR

marcdragicevic

User Score: 507

SUBMIT REVIEW

ICarly Fan Reviews page 12 of 17

7.7
out of 10
Average
2,531 votes
  • this show is absolutely AMAZING 10/10!!!!!

    10
    the show is absolutely amazing i love the guy who plays spencer(jerry trainor)! 10/10 i would like it if sam had a boyfriend who is a better technical producer than freddie and carly asks him to do the show instead. It would also be better if it was a real life audience there but other than that it is wonderfully exciting. My favourite episode is iWant a world record because that was the first episode i saw and it made me laugh non stop. Jenny McCarthy is an amazing actress and does really well in iCarly. The reason for this is that she has got the right role in the show.
  • A worthy follow-up to the great Nick show, Drake and Josh.

    8.6
    Now, I won't really bother with the plot on this review, but basiclly it's about a girl named Carly who starts her own web show, obviously named ICarly. It's a web show, by the way, and in it her and her best friend Sam perform random acts of stupidity/hilarity/randomness. The person running the show (as in technical stuff) is her other friend, Freddie.





    As soon as you've seen an enjoyed the fantastic (and possibl the best) Nick show Drake and Josh, you're wondering how a (somewhat) spinoff which is similar to it will be. Will it be one of those lousy shows that shouldn't have been made in the first place, or is it so great it's even better? ICarly falls in the middle, it's a very good, great in fact, show which features energetic actors and mostly very funny plotlines which are used to show the creative Dan Schnieder's knack for making sitcoms. In fact, this, along with his other shows (The Amanda show, Drake and Josh, Zoey 101) is in my opinion what's keeping Nick alive. The people at Nick headquarters should be thanking this man for keeping a seemingly dead network (as far as good shows go) alive.





    Miranda Crosgrove is very good in the show, and it goes to show that she can carry her own sitcom with herself in the lead role. However, I can't say she's the only thing that makes this what it is, because her funny and likeable co-stars (who's names escape me right now...) provide setups for each and almost every punchline. And a special mention is needed for the actor who played Crazy Steve in Drake and Josh, because he, like in Drake and Josh, is often the funniest character on the show with his over the top inventions and "art". And lastly, the chemistry between everyone in the show is amazing, espeically for a show that's fairly new. They all fight and love and try to solve problems like they really have been best friends for a long time, and it shows that they've grown comfortable in their roles in such a short amount of time. To be fair, however, Miranda has had experince on Drake and Josh, but her and the other actors are pitch perfect in their roles.





    And I don't think I really need to mention the creativity and energy of the show itself, since that's to be expected from the guy who created and directed The Amanda Show and Drake and Josh. Each episode is unique, and we never get the feeling that things are getting repititous, because each episode provides a brand new and fresh plot.





    Okay, now on to the bad side. As impressive as the lead actors are, they still don't match the charisma Drake Bell and Josh Peck had on their show. They give it their all in each episode, but I guess it was sort of "magic" that made their predecessor so good. They're all funny and energetic, but they're missing that certain spark.





    And honestly, some of the plotlines are very predictable but done in a way in which we "think" it's orginal. For instance, when Carly and Sam get into a fight in one episode. The setup is orginal, and so is the outcome, but haven't we seen the whole "best friend fighting" plot in, I dunno, almost every TV show? Alright, it was acceptable in Drake and Josh, but that's because it was just plain hilarious. ICarly isn't that hilarious, and thus it's flaws show.





    Overall, ICarly is surely a great show and a creative one, and a good substitute for Drake and Josh. But somehow, and it's to be expected, it doesn't quite live up to it. Which, for the most part, isn't a fault of it's own, but with it's creator. Blame him for making a great and classic TV show, and then just making a great TV show.
  • iCarly is a show about a teenage girl who starts a webshow with her two best friends where they can talk about anything they want.

    9.7
    Summary Translation: iCarly is a show about a teenage girl, Carly Shay who starts her own webshow with her two best friends, Sam Puckett, and Freddie Benson. The idea of the webshow all starts when Carly and Sam are put down by a teacher at school, Ms. Briggs. Something about where she won't even consider Carly and Sam's ideas for contestants in the talent show. So Carly makes a webshow, called iCarly where she and her friend Sam can talk about anything they want. Don't worry, I haven't forgotten Freddie. He is the technical producer.





    Ok, so Carly is played by Drake & Josh's Miranda Cosgrove. I've heard tons of people say that Drake & Josh will still, always be better than iCarly, but is that true? Seriously.. I'm a boy, and I will admit I would prefer to watch iCarly than Drake & Josh. Why? Well maybe because I feel in the last season of Drake & Josh, everything got so unrealistic. iCarly? Well, it isn't unrealistic, and the idea for three students to have a webshow to be turned into a sitcom? Genius. Anyways, back to Carly.





    Carly is a great character, and like any show, you want to make the star a great character. =| So yeah, Miranda can be funny at some points, but obviously isn't the funniest actress in the world.





    Freddie Benson would probably be my favorite character, or at least on the iCarly webshow cast. He, as I said before, is the technical producer of the show and perhaps a "nerd" but still a great character. He has a huge crush on Carly, but unfortunately for him he has been "asked out" kind of by two girls, none of them Carly. One by a girl in the next grade at school, the other by a girl who the crew are trying to hook up with Gibby, another "nerdier" character. At first, I wanted this Freddie/Carly to be, since I felt like I was in Freddie's shoes, loving one girl and that girl not loving him/me back, lol. But now, I kinda have joined the "Freddie/Sam" side…





    …Which has brought us to Sam Puckett, Carly's best friend and what the writers are trying to make look like worst enemies with Freddie. (Sam is played by Jennette McCurdy) To me, Sam is okay generally, but when I look at her in a possible relationship with Freddie, well, she looks better, lol.





    Finally the fourth main character is Carly's 26-year-old brother, Spencer Shay who is put in charge of Carly since her mother and father are never around. Well his father is in the military and her mom is, not sure what happened to her. Spencer is played by Jerry Trainor, and like Miranda Cosgrove, stars in Drake & Josh as Crazy Steve. Yet being the funniest on the show, he's not as funny and crazy as Crazy Steve. =D





    Well yeah, that's my opinion on the show. =)
  • Answer me this. how do people like this show??? what makes it so special?

    1.0
    I hate this show. why did they have to pick Miranda Cosgrove for this show. theres so much talented actors why her.





    First off.





    The laugh track. Now that laugh track is so annoying. why? it laughs at EVERY single line. Not even in Drake and Josh the laugh track dident laugh at everything. and whats up with carly? she always laughs/smiling at every little thing. and the jokes arent funny at all





    And spencer. He makes the most UGLIEST sluptures in the WORLD. i mean what the hell? It looks like he dug those stuff in the garbage and just put them together.





    And whats with the Web-show?? freedy. JUST GET A VIDEO CAMREA. he has like a studio when there making icarly. theres like atleast 30-40 stuff there. Why dident they just keep up with Drake and Josh.
  • Eh not nick's best creation but it's ok

    4.5
    A show about a 13 year old girl named Carly and her friends who create their own webshow. The show showcases the webshow aswell as conflicts they face in their normal lives. Well in my opinion this show is mildely interesting and needs some work. The episode plots are pretty good but it would be nice if they did more plots that pretained to the webshow so the name of the show would shine a bit more.





    One thing i love about the show is Spencer. In my opinion he is the best and funniest character on there. But iCarly does have some flaws. The jokes arn't really that funny, everytime Sam does something mean to Freddy they trigger the laugh box which gets annoying because alot of the stuff she does isn't funny at all just childish.





    So i would only recommend this to anyone who is a big Miranda Cosgrove fan or just a little girl. Anyone else not really.
  • I realize that not many people like this show and think it is a waste of time and tv space. I like it, it has some great and funny momments, usually Carly's comments on Sam's antics and her fights with Freddie.

    8.0
    Sam is definitely a troublemaker but she seems to love it and bugging Freddie. Freddie is funny as he knows that he is a tech geek but doesn't care and of course Carly being the troubleshooter between those two. Spencer makes me laugh so hard with his childish antics, I want a relative like him, it would mean more laughter and fun in my life. He is a really good sculpter. I like how ICarly involves its viewers, never done before and the segements, no matter how dorky or silly they might seem. I saw it one night, after the preview interested me and it become my personal favourite to watch each week.
  • Now wat will Nick do.

    1.1
    This has to be the most stupided shows ever. who wants to watch two girls who are 16, act like there 5 or 6 years old. PLus who in the hell want to a 14 year old fat kid take his shirt off every time he's in an episode and dance with his shirt off. That is something that nickoledon should not show little kids. and there parents sure don't want there kids to see a fat dancing like a complete retard and danc with his damn shirt off. Come on nick you are better than this. come up with better shows than this
  • This is the most ridiculous show I've ever had the misfortune of glancing at. Miranda is more talented than this. This is a show about 2 girls who look 18, running around acting like 5 year olds. I rather watch her on Drake & Josh than THIS garbage.

    1.0
    Review? This show deserves no review. This show deserves to be canceled and removed from the Nickelodeon channel line-up. I am very disappointed with what the writers have reduced Miranda Cosgrove to. I know Nick Channel viewers are young and naive, but you need to give them more credit than that. These writers are telling viewers "We think you are blind, and that you will enjoy this. We have sorry story-lines and unrealistic plots that your young mind can understand!". This show, among others with more UNREALISTIC PLOTS such as "That's So Raven" for example... need to GO! There needs to be more shows with more realistic story-lines that kids these days can actually RELATE TO.
  • I love it

    10
    This show rocks. If it gets cancelled. Everybody would wonder why. This is a great show. A couple of years ago I would only watch cartoons but after seeing stuff like this I bearly watch cartoons. The episodes are so funny. Like Ms. Briggs is mean but funny. The charctors have something that rocks about them.


    Sam is so Funny.


    Freddie is so smart.


    Carly is so breakable { cracks under real bad prssure.}


    Ms. Benson is so over protected she's funny.


    Spencer is weird and so so Funny.


    Ms. Briggs is so funny.


    All the charactors are funny, Wierd, and Wacky.


    All the episode are so funny. Like the one where they dunk there heads in ice cold water.


    This show rocks.
  • A must See SHow.

    8.9
    I really like this show.It's about a girl named Carly who makes a webshow with her friend Sam.This show is really funny.There usually is a problem involving icarly.This is a very vary very very good show.I try to see this show every time it's on.I think Spencer is really reall really really weird.Carly is a nice girl is the leader of the webshow.Sam is this mean girl who dislikes Freddie a whole lot.Sam scares me.Freddie is the camera producer.He's a total nerd to me.And Spencer is Carlies big brother who is a artist.And he's the one thats really weird.And that does it for the review.
  • i wouldn't say it is my favorite show but it is good there are episodes that are better than others!!!

    6.5
    well i cant really write a lot about the show what i do know is its a show about three friends making a website many can watch for laughs and giggles i haven't watched that many episodes but the ones i have watched have been... i like it but i think it is one of the lower of my favorite but i dont want to be rude just in my personal opinion i think it is an ok show Carly is fun to watch i really liked her in drake and josh she was always funny in all the pranks she did and now she has her own ok show thats pretty cool!!
  • Wow! A show about a 14 year old girl living with her 25 year old brother doing a webshow called "iCarly"

    10
    This show has a very unique attribute to it. The main character's name is Carly Shay and she works on a webshow with her friends Sam Pukett and Freddie Benson. On her webshow they do all sorts of cool things such as showing videos sent by peopel from around the world. They are always doing the craziest things. While they are doing the show, Carly's brother, Spencer, is a artist who makes really cool sculptures. he won a world record for most mpoving things on a sculpture by having 137 movable parts. Sam never seems to hang out at her own home because her mother is not a good provider. Freddie tries to avoid his mother because she always embarrases him. She also wants to spend lots of time with him because she took offense when Freddie threatened not to put puzzles together with her if she doesnt let him fence in the episode iFence. This is a really good show and i hope that many peopel will like it for its comedy.
  • OMG I love this show so much!

    10
    iCarly has got to be one of the greatest shows ever to be made of all time! it is so awesome! And i love it how their Web site is an actual web site you can go on to and see it in real life too! their Web site is definitely the big bomb! it is so popular and famous that i can't wait to become a member on it! iCarly.com rules! I love the show too, it is so much fun to watch! Seriously! Whoa hold on here...this suprises me, how come this show's score is only an 8.7? It should be higher than that! Then its probably because there's been some low score Reviews here lately...ah well, I am not gonna get involved with that. But anyway, keep up the good work icarly! A very successful show to be made indeed. My opinion for this show is that it is a very wonderful show that should be kept running for a very long time, it is very good i'd say along with the cast's fantastic Web Site they created! Miranda Cosgrove, Jennette McCurdy, Nathan Kress, and Jerry Trainor star as the Four Main Characters: Carly Shay, Sam Puckett, Freddy Benson, and Spencer Shay! Now for the Grand Finale! A lot of Videos can be Downloaded and stuff from the iCarly Website... it'd be sweet to make a Video and they choose it to be shown at the end of the show... or rather the show's Credits. Again, it is a super Excellent show!
  • "iCarly" is a sitcom for the YouTube generation.

    9.4
    Miranda Cosgrove stars as Carly Shay, a 13-year-old girl who lives in Seattle with her 26-year-old brother, Spencer (Jerry Trainor), and hosts a Web show with a little help from her best friend Sam (Jennette McCurdy) and next-door neighbor Freddie (Nathan Kress). Unlike "Hannah Montana," "iCarly" is much different because it's the first show in Nickelodeon history to feature the Internet as a backdrop. And I do think Miranda Cosgrove is going to be a household name someday and she is nothing like the other tween starlets, such as Vanessa Hudgens, Ashley Tisdale, and, of course, Miley Cyrus. If you haven't watch "iCarly" yet, this could be the show just for you.
  • I'm not a big fan of the show.

    6.4
    iCarly is a show that I've only seen one episode of. So, I'm going to give it one more chance, but I'm going to tell what I think of this show So Far. At this time, I think iCarly is sort of dumb. I don't find the show funny or the jokes funny. I lost interest in watching it after about 12 minutes. I don't mean to offend, this is what I think of the show So Far. Still, if you haven't seen seen this show yet, you should watch it. Why? The reason is because there are a lot of good reviews of this show, so give it a chance. As for me, I will give this show another chance and see if my view of this show is changed. Thanks for reading my review. - a n d e r s o n 5 8 7
  • a complete waste of time which gives a bad name to this tv channel

    2.1
    There are so many things that i can of that makes this show so horrible. Its THE 2nd worst show on Nick next to Naked Brothers Band. The jokes are horrible and way corny. The laugh track is the worst that i have ever seen, its nowhere near ok. The entire cast is ugly and none of them are funny, except for Spencer. Did i mention the laugh track was horrible or the jokes aren't even close to funny? This is a big disappointment from Dan Schneider. Hes created some of my favorite shows like Drake and Josh and created some of the best classic shows like Keenan and Kel and All That. I expected this show to be at least decent, but instead all i got was a crappy disappointment with crappy everything. I ReElLy HaTe ThE LaUgHiNg TrAcK this show would be a lot better without it just mentioning it again.
  • dis show is very funny and has most people from zoey 101 and drake and josh.

    8.6
    I know you see sometimes the world will change for me and be so wonderful.live life,breath air I know somehow we're gonna get there and feel so wonderful...It's all for real...I'm telling you just how I feel so wake the members of my nation it's your time to be there's no chance unless you take one and the time you see the brightest side of every situation some things are just meant to be so gimme your best and leave the rest to me! leave it all to me just leave it all to me just leave it all to me...





    dis is my favorite song ever!
  • about a webshow.

    7.2
    iCarly is a show that is about a webshow. Carly Shay, Sam Puckett, and Freddie Benson live in Seattle. They all make a webshow called iCarly. Sam and Carly are the actors on the webshow and Freddie is the tech producer. Carly lives with her brother spencer and Freddie lives in the place next door.


    Sometimes iCarly can be very funny and sometimes it is very stupid. Sam is sort of mean to Freddie because she thinks he is a nerd. Freddie has a crush on Carly. Carly does not have a crush on Freddie but she has a crush on Jake. This is a guilty pleasure of mine.
  • A story about a 13 year old girl who lives in seattle with her 26 year old brother as her guardian. Carly Shay runs a webshow named "iCarly" with her two best friends.Samantha Puckett( the rebel) and Freddie Benson( the whiz- kid)/ neighbor.

    9.8
    I love to just grab a snack and get comfortable while I watch this show. I have'nt been obsessed with a show as much as I am with this one. It's witty, sincere and smart. You should like it if you have any sense of humor. The characters will seem like your best friends and you'll enjoy getting to know them. Carly holds the crew together and seems to be perfect. Sam is the badgirl who you've always wanted to be and can relate to. Freddie is the techie who you want around when your computer crashes and not to mention he's a great guy. Not to forget Spencer who's the fun adult who you wish you could party with. I love this show and not much people know it. Enjoy!
  • not very good.

    2.5
    why did miranda cosgrove had to make her own show? Nick is already going down hill. i don't think their webshow is funny. it's just about random immature stuff that has no punchline in it. and those kids who'd actually sended these videos are just wasting their time. they're sending their vids to a children show. they've should've put it on youtubeeee or something so they could be even more humiliated.





    the laugh track is very annoying. it goes on whenever they say something lame. oh did i mention that the jokes ARE NOT funny. the hosts of the webshow should atleast be 10 years old NOT teenagers. that's just a disgrase. the kids at the school don't look like they're from jr/sr high school. they look like 5th graders. they're short and immature enough to be in diapers!
  • It's only in it's first season, but I love it!

    8.8
    I thought this show wasn't going to be that good, until I watched it. I love this series. It is sooooooooooo coool! Teen Nick has finally invented a good series. In a year, I think iCarly will beat Drake and Josh and become really popular. I think this show, although it's still in it's first season, should be on everyday! And I try to watch it every weekend. I like Sam, because she is hillarious and fun, but I also like Carly, because she's just like any girl. This is probably five times better than any other Teen Nick series, and is probably the second best show on Nick! Go iCarly!
  • icarly is awesome

    9.6
    this is like my favorite show its so funny.at first i thought it was a stupid idea having tv show based on a webshow but it teachs kids how to make a webshow and lots of ideas.also ,like 5 of my friends started webshows because of icary.but i hated the episode when there #1 fan was on the show she creeped me out.i love the music too,but they should change the theme song.finally icarly is so cool no one even watchs disney channel anymore.by the way i hate disney channel because of miley cryrus and zac efron.spencer is my favorite........blah blah blah i never said that
  • Truly a favorite, and very hooking.

    10
    This show is like a fish hook, and we are the fish, this show is very hooking and very funny. It is one of my favorite shows, actually this and CSI are the only two shows I really watch anymore. However, this was surprising, I only watched it because I had nothing better to do. However when I watched it, I just had to keep watching.





    My favorite character is Sam, and it really was her relationships with the others that got me in, but if you get the chance to watch this show, do so! This show will definitely captivate you and hold your interest, you will love it, I guarantee that much.
  • sam is cute and a hottie and she is funny and when she pics on freddie now that is funny carly is also a hottie and funny so she is awsome freddie is cool and funny he is awsome characters to the show and spencer he is funny and cool and fun and crazy

    10
    icarly is fun to whatch and it is about a teenage girl who lives whith her 26 years old brother and and she starts a web show whith sam and freddie freddie is the one who has crush on carly and i think now she likes him to and she will date him and sam will get jelous cuz i think she has a crush on freddie if carly and freddie date she will get mad and stop being friend whith carly and what does freddie do let see and watch it happend and one more think carly and sam are cute but carly is hot
  • Drake & Josh's Little sister gets her own show!

    9.5
    ICarly is Kinda a spin-off of Drake and Josh I Know Spin offs Aren't that good, but ICarly is very good! The Show is about Carly Shey (Miranda Cosgrove) a girl Who (in the first episode) Decides to host A Webshow With Her Friend Sam Puckett (Jennette McCurdy) and her neighbor Freddie Benson (Nathan Kress). Freddie has a Crush on Carly and is Constantly insulting Sam form this show many things have come including the TV Movie "Icarly saves TV" and it has sold a DVD of the first season and a CD plus a Deluxe Fan Pack.


    Overall Icarly Is A Great Comedy!
  • I really don't think this show is good. The acting is fake and the summmary doesn't suit the personalities of the characters.

    3.8
    This show is about a girl who lives with her brother who wants to be a role model for kids and teens. If they saw her off camera they would be suprised with her friends and herself's behaviour. Carly is the main character and supposed to be the favoured one of the show from what it looks like. Sam is the annoying,belching,trouble maker best friend of Carly. Freddy is the tech man who is in love with Carly and doesn't do a good job hiding it. Things which are good about the show are: it is liked by younger children, the age it's meant for. But if it's meant for young kids they should be ten not thirteen. I'm thirteen and I'm more mature than them. Why do they constantly make goat and cow noises on the web show? Freddy's catch phrase seems to be "Hi there!"


    I really don't like this show and the acting is terrible.


    If thats what there role modelling is about they deserve an A+.(Not a compliment)
  • WOW

    10
    Carly is a teenager who lives with her twenty-six year old brother and guardian Spencer, and produces her own web casts from a studio she constructed in the attic of her home. She does this because she isn't looking for fame or fortune, but just because she wants to be a good role model for kids and teens. "iCarly" makes TV history as the first series to incorporate kid-generated original content into its script. The characters are cool... besides Sam. I like the plots, and th humor has best onto everything. Only 8 more words until I am dibe. I'me done!
  • This show is pretty good. Cosgrove is really making a star out of herself!

    8.5
    iCarly is about a thirteen year old girl named Carly who teams up with Freddie and Sam to create the ultimate webshow titled- you guessed it- iCarly. They display whatever they want- what teachers do when they're not in school, Spencer's awesome sculptures, etc. The show is much better than the website in real life. If you ask me, you should totally watch iCarly. I wouldn't say perfect- they can make it better- but defenitely a show worth watching on Nick. My grade- hold on. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B+.
  • Carly lives with her 26 year old brother Spencer. Together Sam, Freddy, and Carly made a web show called ICARLY and everyone tunes in to watch it! they have to think of what to do for each web show. they sometimes run into trouble every now and then!

    9.0
    i love this show! it is soo funny and i watch it everytime it's on! i love Spencer because he is soo soo FUNNY and i love it when he makes his sculptures because some of them are really COOL! Sam is hilarious when she picks on Freddy, but sometimes they are mean! Freddy's mom is wicked weird and i would totally hate if I ad her as a mom beacuse i wouldn't want TICK BATHS or DAILY BODY CHECKS! that's just totally weird! but she is o.k.! Sometimes Freddy is cute! i think he is really great tech producer!





  • Summary-Summary-summary... O.K. a summary for iCarly, how do I do this? And 255 words, goodness.

    10
    What bad thing could I say about iCarly? I'm obsessed. iCarly is an awesome show that has tons of fun comedy that the stupid things just have to make you laugh. It is the best show on TEENick right now. Miranda Cosgrove and Jennette McCurdy make the show wonderful to watch they are such great actors! The show appeals to almost everybody. You should watch it just for the old classic stupid jokes they will always keep in a TEENick series. Its kind of like Zoey 101, which was also a great show, minus the boarding school. You need to watch it too!
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Today
3:00pm
TNCK
3:30pm
TNCK
Wednesday
3:00pm
TNCK
3:30pm
TNCK
10:00pm
TNCK
10:30pm
TNCK
Thursday
3:00pm
TNCK
3:30pm
TNCK