An extremely well-crafted episode in all aspects: writing, acting, sound design, cinematography, editing, and direction.
9.5
"Superb"
The brilliance of this episode may not be immediately apparent until you consider this: Willie's entire story is told in words. There are no flashbacks.
How, then, is it that we as viewers still feel the full brunt of Willie's story? Several factors combine to create the incredibly intimate, almost claustrophobic effect.
First, the writing. The episode itself is well-crafted, the dialogue well-chosen. We are pulled away from the main plot only a few times in the beginning before Willie's story becomes the sole focus. Mac, A.J., and the detective all take very minor roles; our focus remains on Harm, Willie, and Bud, who plays an essential supporting role. This structure is well-designed and very effective.
Second, the acting. Most of the story is told only to Harm and Bud -- and each of them has a particular viewpoint that allows us to be drawn into the story. Harm, of course, cannot help but be drawn in, once he realizes that this man might lead him closer to finding his father. But Bud is really closer to most of us as audience members, because of his innocent, naive, and almost idealistic view of the world. Harm brings his own baggage to his views of Willie; Bud has no such preconceived ideas -- and for that reason, he is a good conduit for us as viewers.
Third, the sound design. While there are no flashbacks, there are moments when non-diegetic sound (sound not coming from events onscreen) supplements Willie's story and enhances the images our minds form from Willie's words. The added sound is not overpowering, nor does it run through the entire story; instead, it is thoughtfully added at certain points, where it does its job with subtlety and brilliance.
Fourth, the cinematography. Once Bud, Willie, and Harm enter the courtroom, where Willie finally tells the true story, the color shifts to sepia, enhancing the "time gone by" feeling, allowing us as the audience to forget the present and be drawn into the past -- Willie's past -- with Bud and Harm. It is a brilliant and incredibly effective choice.
Finally, the editing and direction. The final choices made that make the episode what it is are good, solid, and well-chosen. Nothing detracts, and we are only distracted when we need to be, in the beginning of the plot. The choices of location -- Harm's small office, which gets even smaller as more people crowd in -- and the courtroom, which, while empty except for the three people in it, still manages to feel strangely claustrophobic as Willie's story builds -- enhance the trapped feeling that Willie himself carries. He is trapped by the story, trapped by his past until he is finally able to admit it and get it out into the open.
In fact, the courtroom is a brilliant choice for that confession. Though Willie is never on the stand, never takes an oath, it is only in the courtroom -- one of the few places in the world where people are expected to be completely honest -- that he finally allows the full truth to be revealed.
By the end of the episode, we have been thoroughly drawn in to Willie's story -- and as an expected topper, we understand Harm's naturally heroic decision that ends the plot.
But what continues to amaze me is that Willie's story is told without a single flashback. The episode almost feels like a well-crafted stage play, especially in the courtroom -- three characters in a single location, telling a story in words. And we, as an audience, sit entranced, unable to tear ourselves away. It is brilliant, brilliant work.moreless