Although this is far from one of the show's classics, I was a little surprised to read the other reviews that rate this as bottom of the barrel.
It is a fair story, and I found it had a few amusing parts, although it does suffer from season 9 syndrome of not really being the show at it's best.
I think one of the things that could have easily improved this episode is the inclusion of a b-plot. It would have beefed the episode up more; I think the main flaw is that the cat story alone is not enough for a good episode.
The funniest parts of the episode, for me, were Bill and his dog, and just how well things were going for them. It was nice to not see Bill fail for once.





