Law & Order

Season 19 Episode 1


Aired Monday 10:00 PM Nov 05, 2008 on NBC

Episode Fan Reviews (5)

Write A Review
out of 10
63 votes
  • For a Season's first episode, this was definitely not my favorite. The attempt to make this season's opener a controversial and pivotal episode was not as successful as it could have been.

    This season we begin with a continued feeling of the DA's office under Jack McCoy as having a weak ability to accomplish its goals as Prosecution on behalf of the "People." I'm not sure if a series prolonged over 19 seasons can continue to pump out or generate original material that doesn't undermine its once glory years. Here we have a group of reputable professionals from Wall-Street brokers to Public servants like FDNY pinned against a group of angry amateur street fighters. The debate here is, when to draw the line between unsportsmanlike conduct, public violence and of all things terrorism. There is a good point being made in this episode regarding how far we (society) have allowed violence to creep into all of our lives. Now I find myself sounding more of a political analyst (funny this) instead of a TV fan. But that's sort of the nature here. I liked some of the underlying plot, but I've become almost desensitized over the 911 historical event. Law & Order, I think, has really worn a hole into referencing 911. Making this type of statement makes me sound almost unpatriotic. To the contrary. My statement is, Law & Order's constant referencing 911 for plots has almost cheapened those memories. That's my opinion. Political as it may sound, this entire episode revolved on this very issue. Politics, politics politics. I usually enjoy the political developments of a show... but this episode's expression of its stance, has been done so many times. The attempt at controversy played itself out, but not to my satisfaction. Still if you're a true and blue Law & Order die hard fan, it'll still be good viewing. I gave this episode a 7.5 in part because I really enjoy watching the season opening episode with anticipation, but mostly because this attempt to grab you with