Eric Matheson, a man accused of killing his wife, holds the Lightman Group hostage to get them to prove his innocence.
Zoe has the Lightman Group look into a college athlete accused of rape. Meanwhile, Foster and Loker head to a religious compound in order to determine whether or not it is actually a cult.
A woman with multiple personalities comes to Lightman for help. The Lightman Group has to figure out if she's either the killer or the witness to a murder. Meanwhile the Lightman Group is also hired to question a candidate to the Supreme Court.