One of the biggest revelations in the series history--- who's your daddy?
8.0
"Great"
We haven't seen much of Claire this season, and the few times we have it's in connection with Charlie, so it's good that we're learning something about her. And considering that all we knew about Claire in her previous flashbacks dealt with her pregnancy, it's about time we learned some more about her past. In it is one of the biggest revelations of all, and a link we didn't expect.
Claire (who apparently grew up as a Goth girl with her dyed brown) was raised alone by her mother. They were in an auto crash in which she was driving, and her mother ended up in a coma, kept alive only by machines. Under normal circumstances, they wouldn't have taken care of her, but someone took care of all the expenses--- her father, who Claire had lived her life thinking was dead. Even more shocking, her father is Christian Shepherd. (At last we have an idea as to what he was doing in Australia in the first place. Though I hadn't figured out he was related to Claire, the actress who played her Aunt Lindsey appeared in 'Two for the Road', as the woman he was arguing with before Ana Lucia pulled him away. Another subtle link that we haven't seen much of Season 3) Christian has come to appeal to take her mother off life support. He doesn't know the exact circumstances of the accident, but he seems to know enough to tell her that "There is hope, and there is guilt, and believe me I know the difference." This is a rather strange admission from a man who told Jack that sometime it was best to offer a critical patient some hope, but perhaps he realizes enough to know that the one who needs hope is the one who can move on with her life. She doesn't listen, though, and before she boarded Oceanic 815, her mother was still on life support. And the guilt he was speaking--- which Claire feels for causing the accident in the first place--- will probably never be relieved either. (It turns out, however, that Claire had a right to be hopeful.)
Now, on the island, Claire has her own sort of hope to deal with, when she sees a tagged bird, she tries to seize on this as a hope of rescue, with the idea that by clipping a message to it's wing would somehow get them saved. (How exactly they would do it, seeing as they still have no idea where they are, and don't even have the vaguest geographical coordinates is another story, but you have to believe in something.) Naturally, this doesn't help matters when Desmond starts hanging around in order to save Charlie's life yet again.
(This may have been faulty writing, but let me spin it anyway. According to Desmond's flash, Charlie would have died if he slipped on the rocks trying to get a bird for Claire, so he fired his gun to scare the birds off. But if he hadn't fired his gun, they would have trapped the birds with no problems. Is it possible whoever's sending him these flashes is sending him the wrong information? Or is he making it up as he goes along trying to save Charlie even if this does it the wrong way? Given what we later see this season, I think this may be a legitimate possibility.)
Eventually, Desmond again does something none of the crash survivors have done, and that's reveal his problems to someone. He tells Claire that Charlie is doomed, and she decides not to accept it. She's going to stop pushing Charlie away and try and find hope. Unfortunately for her and Charlie, hope may carry the day here, but fate has a heavier hand with the destinies of both of them (though even now we're still not sure what it is)
Meanwhile, on the other side of the island, Kate, Sayid and Locke are dealing with their own set of problems. Sayid is understandably angry that Locke blew up the Flame Station, while Locke offers half-assed excuses. Mikhail is still acting high and might, but there are definite hints that he knows far more about this island than he's telling. He certainly seems to know more about the castaways. He also mentions a 'list' which we heard Danny Pickett mention before he attempted to kill Sawyer, referring yet again to Jacob. Then they find a sonar fence that surrounds the barracks they are trying to approach. Mikhail says it hasn't function in years, but he's lying--- as Locke proves when he inexplicably grabs him and throws him to his (apparent) death. (And yes, I know, blood shot out of his ears, but there is more to this man than meets the eye)
Now everyone has a new reason to be angry at Locke, and all he offers are even lamer excuses. What the hell is going on with him? He seems determined to isolate himself from Kate and Sayid, he's blown up the Flame, and now he's killed a man (okay, so that last one's not permanent) And now they find some C-4 in his backpack Locke seems to have received some kind of message from the island, and whatever it is, it's telling him that he has to break away. We won't see until the next episode, but it's clear he's operating on some kind of path, but we're still not sure why he considers it so important.
Eventually, they reach the barracks, and we get to see one of the biggest shockers we've seen this season---- Jack is playing football with the Others, and it looks like he's gotten pretty comfortable there. Given what we saw happen to Cindy, it's easy to assume the worst, much like Kate does. What she doesn't know is that the worst is still to come for everyone.
Claire and Charlie end up sending a message on one of the birds (how they fit it on one piece of paper is hard to imagine, but that's another story). Claire seems to have finally accepted that her mother is dead, and her role as the island mother. However, she still seems reluctant to let anyone into her life, even Charlie who has offered so much of himself. She seems to be willing to accept him now, but time is running out for this, too.
The episodes on Claire are not as strong as some of the other episodes (perhaps that's because she's related to Jack ;) ), but this one uses her past far more effectively than we've seen. Maybe she can now free herself from her past, and prepare to accept herself in a new life with her child (if she gets one)moreless