Sawyer: Yeah, and Red here was wearing a vest. Which means her posse's gonna come expecting themselves a gun fight.
Hurley: If all they want is her, why don't we just let her go? I mean, I thought we were just gonna go hide. Why do we need to take prisoners?
Locke: We're keeping her because she's gonna be valuable.
Hurley: How's she gonna be valuable?
Charlotte: He means as a hostage, Love.
Hurley: Nuh uh, no, that's not what I signed up for.
Locke: What did you sign up for, Hugo?
Hurley: Look, I'm just saying that if we let her go, they'll look at it as a sign of good faith.
Locke: They'll look at it as an act of foolishness, which is what it would be.