Definite improvement, but not one as long as you'd think
8.0
"Great"
By now, we've realized that every character on the island has a past that they're trying to get away from. Whether they came from the front end or the tail section, these people desperately want to leave their past behind. There is on exception to this rule--- Sawyer. Even stranded on a island thousand of miles away, he still thinks that he has to be this bad, despicable human being just like the one who conned his mother and ended up killing her and his father. From the moment he landed on the island, he has been doing his best to maintain hat reprehensible attitude, even though there is a good person there, buried deep within. (He'll even get to a point where he wants to find, though it's going to take a lot more trauma then this.)
Sawyer is very good at reading people, though not nearly as well as he thinks he can. He can recognize it in fellow pariah-- his comment to Charlie about being the most hated is almost identical to one he said to Boone when he tried to take the water supply nearly two months ago, and he knows how to play on that. He also recognizes when people care about him, and if he didn't know that Kate was sweet on him before, he knew about it when he was recuperating. He takes what information he has been reading off other people--- Jack, Locke, Ana Lucia, and files it away. But more important then all of this is how people see him. For several weeks he was viewed as a contemptible scoundrel, until he took the raft off the island to get rescued. When he came back, people started looking at him differently--- not just Kate, but the others like Hurley and Michael. And this is anathema to him, because he still thinks that he's trying to make sure that he is the real Sawyer, and that he is regarded with nothing but contempt. Some might argue that his actions in this episode are part of his true nature shining through, I think that Kate is far closer to the mark when she confronts him in the en, and tells him: "This is about making people hate you!" The expression on his face speaks volumes.
What he does is bad enough. When Sun is attacked, apparently by the others, Sawyer uses his relationship with Kate to make it seem that spot that her holes in the story. He watches Jack and Ana's behavior to make it seem like this an attempt to begin recruiting for this army that they're creating. Then he goes to Locke, whose alliance with Jack about storing the guns is tenuous, and Sawyer knows won't take much to dissolve. A little maneuvering, and suddenly Sawyer is control of the weapons. The way he's played off so many of the others is bound to make him hated, but the speech that he gives immediately following seals the deal. Sawyer has no interest in being" the new sheriff"; that's too heroic. And later episodes will show that he ahs no problem just giving the guns away when needed. This is all about him being the con man who "never did a decent thing in his life"
The back story that appears involves a 'long con' that he was doing with a woman named Cassidy, and this has more resonance to it, not only because of what he does, but to who. There was fan speculation by some sites that Cassidy might be a con artist herself, and given the way that she acts around Sawyer a lot of the time, there is evidence of this. However, unlike many of the characters in these flashbacks, we will see her a couple of more times, and it does seem that some of her actions were genuine. Sawyer says otherwise, and he lies to her so many times in hard to tell, but it's clear he felt something for this woman. This was not just a con; it was evidence of what a bad person he is, and we see that in the last little segment of his flashback. (Nor was she the only person we've seen before; when he's having a meeting in a restaurant, the waitress who takes his order is Diane, Kate's mother. Her hairstyle's and this is a different diner than before, so maybe this is probably before Kate killed her husband.)
This is also the first episode that we see Sayid in awhile, and it's clear that he still in the mourning for Shannon (which does make sense, it's only been a week since her death) Hurley tries to bring him out of his shroud by giving him the shortwave radio that we saw Bernard and the other tailies use in 'The Other 48 Days". This does pique him a little because by episode's ends, he's worked on the radio and now it's picking up another transmission--- and I recognized the music. It was Glenn Miller, the jazz composer who died in the 40's--- when his plane crashed in the Pacific. Now it's possible that they picked this up from a radio station somewhere out in ocean, but given what we later learn about the island, is it possible that the signal is live, but coming from another time. We know that there's a power source somewhere in the island it is possible that's where it was intercepted from? Or am I crazy?
The radio is symbol of a lack of communication between the survivors. Locke, Jack and Sawyer encountered the Others together, but rather than work together to form a proper army, Jack went to Ana and talked with her, Locke started fiddling around with the combination (and it didn't help matters when he learned about Charlie's possible relapse) and Sawyer found a way to outmaneuver them both to make a power play of his own. They have the makings of what could be a real force here, but instead, they're all moving in different directions. It's no wonder that the Others have been able to run roughshod over them; they're so messed up in their own stuff, they can't find a way to work together. Despite that long ago admonishment from Jack, it does seem like were coming up on 'every man for himself' here.
This episode is a shocking one not only because of Sawyer's attitude, but because what we learn about Charlie near the end. Despite what he tells Sawyer, it's obvious that he's back on the drugs again--- hoods on, after all. Though this is a very well done episode, it's not quite as good as some of the earlier ones this seasons, or the one's that have involved Sawyer. There is a major disconnect between the survivors still here, and it's going to take an outside force to bring it. That force is going to show very soon. Till then, it seems a little like marking time.
My score:8.2moreless