Mr. Rogers puts together a wooden horse for Chef Brockett. Mr. McFeely brings Lightning, a small horse, for Mr. Rogers to see and ride.
In the NOM, Daniel tells Joey Hollingsworth that Donkey Hodie has broken his arm and needs help. Dr. Bill can't understand how a donkey that has four legs could break an arm. Mr. McFeely leaves Lightning with Elsie Jean while he goes to Someplace Else. It turns out that one of the arms of the windmill has broken. Mr. McFeely repairs it. Elsie Jean asks Mr. McFeely to bring her a penguin. Back with Mr. Rogers, Chef Brockett brings him some cupcakes with numbers on them when he picks up the toy horse. Mr. Rogers helps decorate some of the cupcakes.
Songs: Won't You Be My Neighbor?, Everything Grows Together, To Go To Someplace Else, Tomorrow.