Sherriff Haines refers to the Amish as the "A-mish" (long "A") when talking to Jessica about their incapacity to murder. No sherriff from Lancaster County would pronounce "Amish" this way, (just as no one from Lancaster would say "LAN-caster)." This is strictly a tourist/outsider enunciation.
Additional Credit: Titles & Optical Effects by Pacific Title
Hunt Block and Martha Byrne have been starring together in CBS 'As the World Turns' for the past few years.