Naruto Forums

TV Tokyo (ended 2007)

Least evil Akatsuki member? *Spoilers

  • Avatar of mugogrog

    mugogrog

    [342]Apr 6, 2009
    • member since: 02/23/09
    • level: 1
    • rank: Weatherman
    • posts: 5

    k I think the least to most evil akatsuki r

    1 Itachi

    2 Konan

    3 Deidara

    4 Sasori

    5 Zetsu

    6 Kisame

    7 Hidain

    8 Tobi

    9 Pain

    10 Kakuzu

    11 Orochimaru

    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of TheSilentSound

    TheSilentSound

    [343]Apr 7, 2009
    • member since: 04/04/09
    • level: 3
    • rank: Soup Nazi
    • posts: 50
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do?

    Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it.

    Top 5 (From most evil to least)
    1- Madara
    2-Sasuke
    3- Itachi
    4- Pain
    5- Oro... if you count him
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of bloodiedblade

    bloodiedblade

    [344]Apr 7, 2009
    • member since: 07/29/08
    • level: 9
    • rank: Door Number 2
    • posts: 1,023
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do?

    Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it.

    Top 5 (From most evil to least)
    1- Madara
    2-Sasuke
    3- Itachi
    4- Pain
    5- Oro... if you count him
    so you think madara is the most evil?
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of AnimeMadness

    AnimeMadness

    [345]Apr 7, 2009
    • member since: 09/14/05
    • level: 22
    • rank: Freak and Geek
    • posts: 6,778
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do?

    Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it.

    Top 5 (From most evil to least)
    1- Madara
    2-Sasuke
    3- Itachi
    4- Pain
    5- Oro... if you count him


    That may be so, but compared to the other Akatsuki, Itachi isn't as bad.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of TheSilentSound

    TheSilentSound

    [346]Apr 8, 2009
    • member since: 04/04/09
    • level: 3
    • rank: Soup Nazi
    • posts: 50

    bloodiedblade wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    so you think madara is the most evil?

    Obviously...

    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of TheSilentSound

    TheSilentSound

    [347]Apr 8, 2009
    • member since: 04/04/09
    • level: 3
    • rank: Soup Nazi
    • posts: 50

    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    That may be so, but compared to the other Akatsuki, Itachi isn't as bad.

    Seeing as Many Akatsuki members(Kisame, Zetsu, Paper-Cut, and All of team Snake except Sasuke) intentions haven't been revealed I think Itachi makes the top 5 easily. Not only because he killed his entire clan, but also because he made his brother watch it. No matter why he did it that's evil.

    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of Eddy654

    Eddy654

    [349]Apr 8, 2009
    • member since: 08/31/07
    • level: 18
    • rank: Land Shark
    • posts: 3,914
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    That may be so, but compared to the other Akatsuki, Itachi isn't as bad.

    Seeing as Many Akatsuki members(Kisame, Zetsu, Paper-Cut, and All of team Snake except Sasuke) intentions haven't been revealed I think Itachi makes the top 5 easily. Not only because he killed his entire clan, but also because he made his brother watch it. No matter why he did it that's evil.

    Oh and btw the group is now referred to as ''Hawk''.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of bloodiedblade

    bloodiedblade

    [350]Apr 8, 2009
    • member since: 07/29/08
    • level: 9
    • rank: Door Number 2
    • posts: 1,023
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    bloodiedblade wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    so you think madara is the most evil?

    Obviously...

    i was just checking. itachi is not all that bad. he did try to stop a war from inside the leaf village. if i had to pick i would say orochimaru is the most evil but to each their own.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of master_m11

    master_m11

    [351]Apr 8, 2009
    • member since: 08/03/08
    • level: 12
    • rank: Evil Bert
    • posts: 1,649
    don't know how you could say anyone of them is not as evil as the other but if i had to pick the least evil one i would say it would be itachi because he tried to save the leaf village as a whole by killing his own beloved clan. he could have killed kakashi and the others when he came back to the leaf but instead chose to avoid it.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of AnimeMadness

    AnimeMadness

    [352]Apr 9, 2009
    • member since: 09/14/05
    • level: 22
    • rank: Freak and Geek
    • posts: 6,778
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    That may be so, but compared to the other Akatsuki, Itachi isn't as bad.

    Seeing as Many Akatsuki members(Kisame, Zetsu, Paper-Cut, and All of team Snake except Sasuke) intentions haven't been revealed I think Itachi makes the top 5 easily. Not only because he killed his entire clan, but also because he made his brother watch it. No matter why he did it that's evil.



    First, I don't consider Hawk to be true Akatsuki members. If they were they would be the least evil out of all the Akatsuki. Second, Pain, Kakuzu, Hidan, Tobi, and Deidara/Sasori easily make the top five before Itachi. What Itachi did is nothing compared to what they did. At least he had a good reason despite how f*cked up it is.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of GamePick2

    GamePick2

    [353]Apr 9, 2009
    • member since: 04/06/09
    • level: 3
    • rank: Soup Nazi
    • posts: 61
    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    That may be so, but compared to the other Akatsuki, Itachi isn't as bad.

    Seeing as Many Akatsuki members(Kisame, Zetsu, Paper-Cut, and All of team Snake except Sasuke) intentions haven't been revealed I think Itachi makes the top 5 easily. Not only because he killed his entire clan, but also because he made his brother watch it. No matter why he did it that's evil.



    First, I don't consider Hawk to be true Akatsuki members. If they were they would be the least evil out of all the Akatsuki. Second, Pain, Kakuzu, Hidan, Tobi, and Deidara/Sasori easily make the top five before Itachi. What Itachi did is nothing compared to what they did. At least he had a good reason despite how f*cked up it is.


    Only Hidan and Tobi out of those that you mentioned did anything bad. Itachi is 10 x worst.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of Evolution_666

    Evolution_666

    [354]Apr 9, 2009
    • member since: 07/02/08
    • level: 14
    • rank: Autobot
    • posts: 680
    I would say Zetsu is the least evil, so far all he has done is spy, and eat people. I mean we have not seen him actually kill anybody, so until his entire background or any of his background is revealed, I think he is the least evil.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of Eddy654

    Eddy654

    [355]Apr 9, 2009
    • member since: 08/31/07
    • level: 18
    • rank: Land Shark
    • posts: 3,914
    GamePick2 wrote:
    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    That may be so, but compared to the other Akatsuki, Itachi isn't as bad.

    Seeing as Many Akatsuki members(Kisame, Zetsu, Paper-Cut, and All of team Snake except Sasuke) intentions haven't been revealed I think Itachi makes the top 5 easily. Not only because he killed his entire clan, but also because he made his brother watch it. No matter why he did it that's evil.



    First, I don't consider Hawk to be true Akatsuki members. If they were they would be the least evil out of all the Akatsuki. Second, Pain, Kakuzu, Hidan, Tobi, and Deidara/Sasori easily make the top five before Itachi. What Itachi did is nothing compared to what they did. At least he had a good reason despite how f*cked up it is.


    Only Hidan and Tobi out of those that you mentioned did anything bad. Itachi is 10 x worst.
    Pain is pretty Evil as well chapter 369 pg 14 states he killed his Parents, Wife, and children and extended his horror to Hanzou's family.
    Edited on 04/09/2009 8:11pm
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of GamePick2

    GamePick2

    [356]Apr 9, 2009
    • member since: 04/06/09
    • level: 3
    • rank: Soup Nazi
    • posts: 61
    Eddy654 wrote:
    GamePick2 wrote:
    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    AnimeMadness wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    That may be so, but compared to the other Akatsuki, Itachi isn't as bad.

    Seeing as Many Akatsuki members(Kisame, Zetsu, Paper-Cut, and All of team Snake except Sasuke) intentions haven't been revealed I think Itachi makes the top 5 easily. Not only because he killed his entire clan, but also because he made his brother watch it. No matter why he did it that's evil.



    First, I don't consider Hawk to be true Akatsuki members. If they were they would be the least evil out of all the Akatsuki. Second, Pain, Kakuzu, Hidan, Tobi, and Deidara/Sasori easily make the top five before Itachi. What Itachi did is nothing compared to what they did. At least he had a good reason despite how f*cked up it is.


    Only Hidan and Tobi out of those that you mentioned did anything bad. Itachi is 10 x worst.
    Pain is pretty Evil as well chapter 369 pg 14 states he killed his Parents, Wife, and children and exented his horror to Hanzou's family.


    I misread it. I didn't seen Pein mentioned.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of TheSilentSound

    TheSilentSound

    [357]Apr 10, 2009
    • member since: 04/04/09
    • level: 3
    • rank: Soup Nazi
    • posts: 50
    bloodiedblade wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    bloodiedblade wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    so you think madara is the most evil?

    Obviously...

    i was just checking. itachi is not all that bad. he did try to stop a war from inside the leaf village. if i had to pick i would say orochimaru is the most evil but to each their own.

    I don't know how to multi reply yet so I'm going to do it all here o_O

    OK first thanks I forgot Sasuke changed the name of the group

    Second I don't trust Madara... His story seems a little too convenyet and he had everything to gain from it. Even if he is telling the truth I see no reason why he made Sasuke re-live that moment TWICE. That certainly makes him evil in my eyes, not even counting him killing the clan.

    Third to AnimeMadness

    How is Sasori evil? He's not a "good guy" but certainly not evil. Same goes with Clayman. I put both Pain and Madara in my top 5. I didn't put Kakuzu and Hidan in there because I don't feel like they are evil. One was just serving his God, the other is just really greedy. I might give you Kakuzu because the Heart thing...

    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of GamePick2

    GamePick2

    [358]Apr 10, 2009
    • member since: 04/06/09
    • level: 3
    • rank: Soup Nazi
    • posts: 61
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    bloodiedblade wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    bloodiedblade wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    so you think madara is the most evil?

    Obviously...

    i was just checking. itachi is not all that bad. he did try to stop a war from inside the leaf village. if i had to pick i would say orochimaru is the most evil but to each their own.

    I don't know how to multi reply yet so I'm going to do it all here o_O

    OK first thanks I forgot Sasuke changed the name of the group

    Second I don't trust Madara... His story seems a little too convenyet and he had everything to gain from it. Even if he is telling the truth I see no reason why he made Sasuke re-live that moment TWICE. That certainly makes him evil in my eyes, not even counting him killing the clan.

    Third to AnimeMadness

    How is Sasori evil? He's not a "good guy" but certainly not evil. Same goes with Clayman. I put both Pain and Madara in my top 5. I didn't put Kakuzu and Hidan in there because I don't feel like they are evil. One was just serving his God, the other is just really greedy. I might give you Kakuzu because the Heart thing...



    I don't see how the heart thing is evil. He killed them in battle so he took what he wanted.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of TheSilentSound

    TheSilentSound

    [359]Apr 10, 2009
    • member since: 04/04/09
    • level: 3
    • rank: Soup Nazi
    • posts: 50
    GamePick2 wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    bloodiedblade wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:

    bloodiedblade wrote:
    TheSilentSound wrote:
    I was looking through the pages of this topic (I find it kind of funny how people can watch the same thing and have different reactions to it) and I noticed something kind of strange when people were debating weather Hitler was evil or not. The same person who compared Hitler to Pain is the same person who said Itachi was evil. I might be misunderstand his/her statements but when someone brought up the fact that Hitler and Pain had good intentions he completely dismissed it. Shouldn't Itachi also be evil since according to his logic Intentions/reasons don't matter but actions do? Itachi should be evil since it doesn't matter weather he was doing what he thought was the right as long as he did it. Top 5 (From most evil to least) 1- Madara 2-Sasuke 3- Itachi 4- Pain 5- Oro... if you count him
    so you think madara is the most evil?

    Obviously...

    i was just checking. itachi is not all that bad. he did try to stop a war from inside the leaf village. if i had to pick i would say orochimaru is the most evil but to each their own.

    I don't know how to multi reply yet so I'm going to do it all here o_O

    OK first thanks I forgot Sasuke changed the name of the group

    Second I don't trust Madara... His story seems a little too convenyet and he had everything to gain from it. Even if he is telling the truth I see no reason why he made Sasuke re-live that moment TWICE. That certainly makes him evil in my eyes, not even counting him killing the clan.

    Third to AnimeMadness

    How is Sasori evil? He's not a "good guy" but certainly not evil. Same goes with Clayman. I put both Pain and Madara in my top 5. I didn't put Kakuzu and Hidan in there because I don't feel like they are evil. One was just serving his God, the other is just really greedy. I might give you Kakuzu because the Heart thing...

    I don't see how the heart thing is evil. He killed them in battle so he took what he wanted.

    Yeah I guess... depends on who started the battle. If he fought them just to get their hearts they yes he is evil

    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.