Episode Summary

EDIT
8.8
out of 10
EPISODE RATING: Great
177 votes
  • Your Rating: 10
    "Perfect"
  • Your Rating: 9.5
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 9
    "Superb"
  • Your Rating: 8.5
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 8
    "Great"
  • Your Rating: 7.5
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 7
    "Good"
  • Your Rating: 6.5
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 6
    "Fair"
  • Your Rating: 5.5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 5
    "Mediocre"
  • Your Rating: 4.5
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 4
    "Poor"
  • Your Rating: 3.5
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 3
    "Bad"
  • Your Rating: 2.5
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 2
    "Terrible"
  • Your Rating: 1.5
    "Abysmal"
  • Your Rating: 1
    "Abysmal"
Rate Now!
Liz's new gilfriend, Poppy, wants her to have cosmetic surgery. James makes Christian and Michelle help her steal another kidney. Sean offers consultation to Marlowe, who wants longer legs.
  • Is this really what the show has come to? Kidney stealing and a couple that keeps cheating with their nannies?

    5.9
    "Mediocre"
    Why exactly did Julia and Sean get re-married? All that they have done since they got back together is sleep with other people. And who didn\\\\\\\'t see the Julia/Marlowe angle coming? It would have thrown everyone for a loop to see somebody not cheat. Also, I am so sick of hearing Julia be bitter and critical of Sean. Her character is almost unbearable to watch now. And are they seriously still going with the kidney stealing? I believe when you look up the definition of \\\\\\\"jump the shark\\\\\\\", a kidney stealing storyline is at the top of the list. The show started out so strong, and now they seem to be reaching into a grab bag of discarded story ideas. There are so many ridiculous storylines going on right now, it is hard to keep up. It seems as though the writers have run out of ways to be provacative, and are now just trying to be as outlandish as possible. If you happen to catch an episode while flipping through the channels, it is sometimes hard to distinguish it from the soft core porn found late at night on Cinemax. We get it, Dr. Troy has a hot body and has lots of sex. Every episode. For long periods of time. This season is getting really hard to watch. And now the previews say the Kimber is pregnant?! (Oh yes, a \\\\\\\"Who\\\\\\\'s the Daddy?\\\\\\\" story is just what they need.) Just to review: this season we have Christian questioning his sexuality; Sean and Julia have a handicapped baby (but we discover the shocking secret that Sean grew up disfigured!); Matt joins Scientology and hooks up with Kimber and somehow there is no backlash for his hand in a MURDER last season; they sell the practice to a billionaire and his hot wife, who of course Christian falls for, but can never have; we learn that she is actually a part of a hooker/kidney stealing ring terrorizing Miami and must eventually kill her husband and steal his kidney to save her love Christian from some angry Asian men who want their kidney quota met; Sean sleeps with a nanny canidate who nuts out, but luckily she gets hit by a bus and he doesn\\\\\\\'t have to tell his wife; and there is Julia, hooking up with the all-knowing male nurse Marlowe, who happens to be a little person and considers surgery so he can become taller for his true love. Does that about sum it up? The guest stars have been pretty entertaining (Rosie was great), but other than that, this ship seems to be going down rapidly.moreless
  • ...............................................

    5.0
    "Mediocre"
    Im sorry but.... this show has become almost complete thrash. Aftger 2 brilliant seasons we get... THIS?

    Like, 5-6 a-class actors, actresses as guest stars every episode... that's cool. But maybe the writers should concencrate on writing good stories instead of just showchasing celebrities.

    well, this episode wasn't like that but.... it was just as bad. Marlow (sp) is probably the worst character on the show so far. The thought of Julia and him sleeping together... wait... not just a thought. THEY FRIGGIN.... DID IT!

    Julia is a hypocrite , but not only that, their relationship is just completetly out of character. It just makes no sense. Her dialouge with Sean at the end of the episode.. " I want to be honest. We're just friends ". Right. Don't say you want to be honest when you're not. Besides, Marlo is plain annoying. We get it, hes a midget, big woop. THat doesnt justify his complete thrash attitude towards... well, everyone but Julia. How annoying was he in the last episode when he kept questioning Christian and Sean?

    Also in this episode: WTF. This kidney business is really happening? Oh boy, it's horrible. The only good part was probably Michelle letting "JR Ewing" die so she coud save Christian... Man, this episode is just continuing the trends of Season 4 which is not good. Heck, this has been going on since season 3. Characters are being watered down to a level where they just become annoying, and the stories are just annoying. BLAH.moreless
  • Poppy 'n' Flesh

    8.0
    "Great"
    I find it strange that the one out-and-proud gay character on Nip/Tuck has only been seen with two women. One which turned out to be a crazy kidney thief, and the other an obsessive, controlling, manipulative nightmare. For a show which comes from the mind of a mostly gay writing team, it's a little disappointing.

    The whole "Liz gets surgery" story wasn't realistic, and it slightly diminished Liz's credibility as a character. She has always been against superficiality, and to see her be so eager to go along with Poppy's ideas of what a perfect woman should look like just didn't ring true. While Sean and Christian do at least question her motives, it's still an unlikely scenario for her. On the other hand, it was great to see Liz finally getting something to do, and I also thought Alanis Morissette gave a really good performance, especially as I hadn't seen her act before.

    Elsewhere, Marlowe and Julia got it on, and it's really shocking to see it. It's pretty daring for the writers to attempt a "little person/ordinary-heighted person" relationship, and I'm strangely enjoying it. The writers didn't get too preachy with the "little person" stuff, which was welcome, while you can actually understand Julia's attraction to him. They seem to bond on a level that Julia just doesn't get with Sean, who is becoming more of a control freak each episode.

    Meanwhile, the kidney arc was a mixed bag. Jacqueline Bisset still rocks, and her rapport with Christian is hilarious ("Eau de French cooch"). I also loved Christian dumping all the bodily waste in her car, in revenge for spiking his drink the night before. But Michelle's storyline continues to bring the whole arc down. Most characters on Nip/Tuck are neither good nor bad, but Michelle is a strange figure in that she's just plain unlikable. "Good girl" Michelle is completely wet, while "bad girl" Michelle is just damn awful. What Burt did was undeniably tacky, but you have to consider what drove him to it and how he is feeling, knowing that his wife is running off with a hunky doctor while he's stuck in bed. To see Michelle sit back and watch as her dying husband crawls along the floor for what seems like twenty minutes, you realize that you just can't like this character.

    A varied episode which in equal measure works and fails. I loved the Marlowe and James scenes, but the Landau stuff made me uncomfortable.

    Director: Richard Levine
    Writers: Lyn Greene, Richard Levine
    Rating: B-moreless
  • Michelle: "I'm not a killer." James: "No, but your hands aren't exactly squeaky clean are they?"

    9.5
    "Superb"
    Michelle proved that she really loves Christian, to the point of killing Burt to save Christian's life. I was surprised how cold Michelle appeared as she watched Burt die right in front of her face. Her hands aren't clean at all. I knew Michelle was unhappy with their marriage, but I didn't realize until now how much she truly detested Burt. Can't say I'm sad to see Burt go.

    So Liz has finally given in and has decided to get plastic surgery at the demands of her new girlfriend. That's a surprise. I'm glad Liz has finally found someone, she certainly deserves to be happy, but Poppy just isn't right for her. Her demanding obsession with beautifying Liz is too passive-aggressive, and as soon as she started insulting Liz during her operation that was the end of Poppy in my book. Liz needs someone that will love her the way she is and not try to turn her into something she's not.

    James was deliciously evil as usual; although, we finally got to see a softer side of her this episode petrified at the hands of Asian thugs and harassed by Christian. I loved that Christian has finally decided to fight back against James. However, James had the upper hand this week; Christian barely survived his rendezvous with her call girl.

    I liked Julia and Marlo's relationship better this episode, and I think Nip/Tuck is doing a good job exploring the handicapped side of our perfection-obsessed society. But seriously, Sean sleeps with the nanny and now Julia? What is this, Days of Our Lives?

    Final Notes and Quotes

    - Conner's finger screws looked painful.

    - My one real complaint of the episode, why would Christian hire a hooker from a woman who just recently drugged him?

    - I loved Liz blackmailing McNamara/Troy into giving her lipo, and the doctor's faces when she started growling, "I want the fat sucked out of me and I want it sucked out now!" were priceless.

    - Marlo: "It's insane but so is love you know."

    Final Rating: Dark, dreary and full of delicious surprises. I loved this episode, so what the heck. 4 out of 4 stars.

    - Tim Bronx
    Find this and many more reviews at: www.motionpicturereviews.commoreless
  • More affairs, murders and attempted murders, and Liz still getting the short end of the stick...

    8.5
    "Great"
    Julia, the hyprocite, also sleeps with a night nanny whose name starts with the letter \"M\".

    Michelle basically murders Burt. Did she truly love him THAT much at one time, to now hate him THIS much?

    And I don\'t think Liz will ever catch a break from the writers. How sad for her to get such a superficial girlfriend. Sure, there\'s nothing wrong with staying in shape, but there\'s also something called loving someone for who they are.

    I loved seeing James squirm to someone after she has been all high and mighty with everyone else. I can\'t believe she almost had her girl kill or do whatever she was going to do to Christian. Wow!

    I\'ve read some reviews of people who hated this episode, but I really enjoyed it.moreless
WRITE A REVIEW

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

See All

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (5)

    ADD TRIVIA
    • It's revealed that Michelle is 30 years old.

    • Christian mentions 'a woman who won the lottery' who paid him four hundred thousand dollars for sex – this happens in Dawn Budge (the woman being the title character played by Rosie O'Donnell)

    • When Sean suggests Christian picks someone up from a bar, Christian replies 'no risk there, just ask Lizzie'. This refers back to Shari Noble where Liz met a girl in a lesbian bar, went home with her and ended up having her kidney stolen.

    • When Sean suggests Christian picks someone up from a bar, he mentioned 'another mother-daughter team'. In the season opener, Cindy Plumb, Christian slept with a mother and daughter that he met in a bar.

    • Liz mentions Mike Hamoui, the surgeon (played by Mario Lopez) that Christian had liposuction off in the episode entitled Monica Wilder.

  • QUOTES (23)

    ADD QUOTES
    • Burt: Come on, honey, let me nuzzle them a little bit. Michelle: I don't really think you should excite yourself right now, Burt. Burt: Shit, you're probably right. Let this be a lesson: never buy a used car. Once you drive it off the lot, one damn thing after another starts to fall apart. It's been a sweet ride though, hasn't it? Michelle: Sweet? No, Burt, it hasn't.

    • Julia: I don't want you to get the procedure done. The leg-lengthening. Not for me. Sawyer: I'm not just doing it for you. I'm doing it for us. Julia: There is no us, Marlowe. I am married. I've told you. Sawyer: I know. But you may not be forever. Look, Julia, I have never thought about doing something like this before. It's just… it's just that, in every other way, we're a perfect fit. And I just don't want the physical difference between us to stand in the way. Julia: How could you even think that? Whatever happens between me and Sean, there is not one thing that I would change about you. Not one.

    • Michelle: Do you have any idea what my life has been like? I'm thirty years old. I sleep next to a man who I have to feed and clean… Christian: Just how much money could he be leaving you, Mrs. Landau? A billion? Because after everything he's put you through, you couldn't possibly owe that old bastard a single thing. You wanna sacrifice yourself for some false sense of wifely obligation? Go ahead. You'll die a rich martyr.

    • Sean: You decided to find yourself a girlfriend and… poof! Poppy appeared. Liz: You hate her. Sean: No! I don't! I mean, who, Poppy? Liz: Did she say something? Sean: No. She may have been a little on the critical side. Liz: Of who? Of me? Well, it's just that she wants me to be the best me I can be. I mean, what did she say? That she was stuck with a big old fat pig? Sean: No… Liz: Oh my god! Sean: You're putting words in my mouth. Liz: Well, someone better because the ones you're not saying suck.

    • Poppy: I can never figure out what comes first with guys; the inflated ego or the small penis.

    • (Liz is undergoing surgery, Poppy suggests they do a few more procedures whilst Liz is under the anesthetic) Poppy: I'm not having her come down to the Keys with me looking like a Teletubby, alright? This is like Michelangelo and the David. We're just whittling away anything that isn't the true Liz. Christian: I think we're done whittling away for today. If she wants anything else done, it's not like she has to make a special trip.

    • Sean: A leg-lengthening procedure's not something I recommend, Marlowe. It's incredibly painful, risky and cost-prohibitive. Sawyer: I understand, but I'd still appreciate you walking me through it, so to speak. Sean: I have to ask. Why? Your stance on Conor's operation was pretty clear. Sawyer: A woman that I'm involved with… she's having some difficulty with the height disparity between us. Sean: If she needs you to put yourself through something like this, I strongly suggest she's not the one you want to spend the rest of your life with. Sawyer: In theory, I agree with you. You're right; it's insane. But so is love, you know?

    • Sean: Why don't you just go to a bar and pick someone up like you usually do? I'm sure there's another mother-daughter team out there somewhere. Christian: Nice. Sean: At least in a bar, what you see is what you get. Christian: Oh yeah, no risk there, just ask Lizzie.

    • Michelle: (after examining a drugged Christian) He knows who you are, James. If we take his kidney, he'll know it was you. James: Why stop at one? I wasn't planning on leaving him alive anyway. I'm not a fool. I know two charming Asian gentlemen who are absolute magicians at making bodies disappear. Michelle: You wouldn't do that. Not even you. James: It's harvest time, darling, and I am under a lot of pressure. I've been given twenty-four hours to meet my quota. Michelle: You think I'm going to let you get away with murdering him? I am not a killer. James: No, but your hands aren't exactly squeaky clean now, are they? Michelle: What do you want me to do? James: Find me a kidney in… (looks at her watch) twenty-one hours and I will keep him from being the next designated donor Michelle: There's nothing human left in you, is there? James: I'm keeping him alive, aren't I? For you. Tick tock, better hurry.

    • James: Let's face it, Christian, not every man can appreciate the experience of a perfectly aged single malt. Smoky scent, sweet and salty taste. Christian: Where do you get the balls to come up to me? James: It's inevitable, you and I. The same refined taste, in Scotch and in women. Don't you believe in fate? Christian: Only in Greek tragedy. James: I believe in critical mass. Tipping points, tiny straws that can break camel's backs. You've been trying to show me who's boss for some time, haven't you? Well, now's your chance.

    • Christian: Honey, I'm not looking to bond. So if you're here to cry boo-hoo over Michelle and then cuddle… James: Look at me, Christian. Do I seem like the cuddly type?

    • Christian: Sweetheart, you're two hours late. If you were a pizza, I'd get you for free. (He opens the door to find James standing there) James: That's because pizza gets cold. Some things get hotter the longer you wait for them.

    • Sean: I don't get it, Liz. Why now, when you've found someone who's obviously attracted to you as you are? Liz: I just think I'd be happier if I looked a little better. Christian: I think the whole world would be.

    • Liz: For your information, my girlfriend happens to be in great shape. Sean: Well, I didn't know you were seeing anybody. That's great, Liz. Christian: I didn't read the news today. Did hell freeze over?

    • Liz: I almost died, OK. But I didn't. I got a second chance and I'm not gonna blow it by spending the rest of my Saturday nights home eating Cherry Garcia. Christian: Can't the two of you just watch TV?

    • Sean: Tell me what you don't like about yourself. Christian: Just start at your head and work your way down. Liz: I just want a little lipo and… maybe some work around the eyes. Christian: Oh yeah, that ought to do it. Liz: Shut up, Christian.

    • Poppy: Trust me, in another week you won't even miss the caffeine. Liz: Honey, the patient is supposed to sleep through the surgery not the anesthesiologist. Poppy: Well, once we boost that metabolism of yours you'll be burning energy you didn't even know existed. Liz: She's got me in training. Sean: For the surgery? That's a good idea. Poppy: No, a 5k run three weeks later. Sean: I didn't know you ran. Liz: Me either.

    • Christian: Come on Lizzie, you know you love us too much to leave us. Liz: Try me. Furthermore, I don't want to hear one more snide remark about me, my girlfriend, or my physical shortcomings. I want the fat sucked out me and I want it sucked out now. Are you or are you not gonna do it?

    • Liz: You don't get points for keeping it real any more. Beauty has its privileges and dammit I want them! Sean: Thought it was different between women? Liz: Yeah, well maybe once upon a time. But in this culture, trust me, dyjkes today are the worst. If you don't have the body of a professional athlete, then you are a loser.

    • Michelle: It stopped being sweet the day you forced me to make love to another man in front of you. What ever love I had for you died that day. You don't do that to someone you love; you do that to something you own.

    • Christian: God gave me a dick and I intend to glorify him by playing that organ as intensely and as often as possible.

    • Michelle: You knew I loved Christian and all your money and power couldn't change that. Burt: Well you're here aren't you. If it wasn't the money and power, why'd you stay? Michelle: I stayed, because I pitied you.

    • Christian: I want her dazzling enough to give my dick amnesia.

  • NOTES (5)

    ADD NOTES
    • Original International Air Dates: Czech Republic: January 28, 2009 on TV Nova

    • Jacqueline Bisset (James), Peter Dinklage (Marlowe), Alanis Morissette (Poppy) and Sanaa Lathan (Michelle) were credited as "Special Guest Stars". At the same time, Lathan received the "And" credit.

    • Larry Hagman receives the 'Special Appearance By' credit.

    • Music featured in the episode: "Just the way you are" by Billy Joel (Poppy looks Sean and Christian while they are working on Liz) "Yegelle tezeta" by Mulatu Astatge (Marlowe paints, Julia tells him not to have surgery)

    • Although listed in the opening credits, John Hensley and Kelly Carlson do not appear in this episode.

  • ALLUSIONS (3)

    ADD ALLUSIONS
    • When Liz is in her initial consult, she says she doesn't want to spend the rest of her Saturdays nights at home eating Cherry Garcia. Cherry Garcia is the name of a cherry-flavoured ice-cream that is made by Ben & Jerry's (named for the erstwhile lead singer of the Grateful Dead, Jerry Garcia).

    • Marlowe says his painting is 'not exactly Hieronymous Bosch'. Hieronymous Bosch (c.1450-1516) was a prolific Dutch painter, the majority of whose work was scenes of sin, human moral failing and demons. His work is dense in iconography and- sometimes obscure- symbolism. One of his most famous painting is the triptych known as The Garden Of Earthly Delights (c.1504)

    • As they operate on Liz, Poppy refers to Michelangelo and the David. Michelangelo (1475-1564) was an Italian Renaissance sculptor, painter and architect. He is known for the painting on the roof of the Sistine Chapel in Rome and the design of St. Peter's Basilica. One of his best known sculptures is that of David, sculpted between 1500 and 1504, a large marble statue of the Biblical king that defeated Goliath. Just as Michelangelo chipped away at the large block of marble that became this beautiful statue, Poppy is suggesting that the subsequent surgeries will do the same to Liz.

More
Less