"Once and Again" is always at its best when it is exploring, in glorious and exquisite detail, the institution of family. In few episodes is this done as pitch perfectly as it is in "Feast or Famine." This episode is simply perfect from start to finish and is one of the best examples I can think of as to why millions of people are as devoted to this show as we are.
The episode begins with Rick and Lily planning a Thanksgiving feast to be shared between their respective familes at Lily's place. Rick's mother, Peg (Barbara Barrie), arrives from Kansas and is excited to finally be meeting the woman in her son's life. She quickly notices some of the underlying problems brewing in Rick's relationships with Eli and Jessie. (Rick and Eli are constantly sniping at each other and Jessie does not appear to be eating.) While making note of these things, she also makes a plea with Rick to patch things up with his estranged brother, Mikey. These "suggestions" do not sit well with Rick and the tension builds between mother and son throughout the episode, reaching a boiling point after the Thanksgiving dinner. Meanwhile, Barbara (Bonnie Bartlett) and Aaron (Patrick Dempsey) join the Mannings for the holiday, as the family celebrates their first holiday without Phil.
The script, direction, acting, lighting, etc. for this episode are perfect. The entire ensemble delivers their usual fine performances. This is, however, a mostly Sammler focused episode, so the acting honors in the main cast go to West, Wood, and especially Campbell, who conveys Rick's pain and vulnerability so very well. Barbara Barrie is just wonderful as Peg, a genuinly loving mother and grandmother, whose good advice to her son often falls flat because of its pushy and self-righteous delivery. She has such lovely and natural chemistry with Campbell, West, and Wood that it is very easy to believe that she is part of their family. Her performance is subtle and heartbreaking and she deserved an Emmy nomination and win for it in the guest actress in a drama series category. "Once and Again" was always criminally ignored by the Emmys, but if Barrie's performance here, which is one of the finest guest star performances I have seen on any show, can't get a nomination, I don't know what can.
This is one of the finest hours of television you will ever see and one of the best "Once and Again" has to offer.
moreless
EDIT
Episode Summary
It's Thanksgiving and that means both the Sammler's and Manning's get together for dinner, whether they want to be there or not. It turns out that the two mothers get along quite well. It's Rick and his mom that have issues. She questions whether Rick knows that his children aren't doing as well as he would like to think. Barbara sees her son Aaron for the first time since Phil's funeral. 'moreless
-
Shane West
Eli Sammler
-
Sela Ward
Lily Brooks Manning
-
Billy Campbell
Rick Sammler
Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions
See All-
Trivia
-
Help by adding trivia to this episode. Add trivia
-
-
Notes
ADD NOTES- Jennifer Crystal Foley (Christie Parker) does not appear in this episode. Edit
-
Quotes
ADD QUOTES- Rick: I don't know why I get so sad at holidays. There's no reason. I have more to be thankful for than almost anybody, and I can admit that... any day of the year except Thanksgiving. Edit
- Peg: That was Rick when he was ten. And he built a fort, remember? Jessie: Dad? A fort? Peg: Yes, his father made him draw up the plans for it. Grace: Is that when you decided to become an architect? Rick: No, that's when I decided not to. Edit
- Rick: We're gonna have a nice dysfunctional holiday dinner like all good Americans. Peg: I can't wait. Edit
-
Allusions
-
Help by adding allusions to this episode. Add allusions
-
Show Forums
Add a Topic
See All
Last Activity
Replies
-
Question: I know this board isn't really active... but here's hoping
03/17/112
-
What happened to Season 3 DVDs?
02/12/089
-
Petition to get season 3 released on DVD
08/09/072
-
A season 3 DVD release is looking hopeful....
08/04/073
-
Why was it cancelled?
07/03/073
-
Chance of a Lifetime
S 3 : Ep 19
Aired 4/15/02
-
Losing You
S 3 : Ep 18
Aired 4/8/02
-
Experience Is the Teacher
S 3 : Ep 17
Aired 4/1/02
-
Aaron's List of Dreams
S 3 : Ep 16
Aired 3/25/02
Related Shows
Season 2 Episodes
See AllEp 22
The Second Time Around
Ep 21
Moving On
Ep 20
Won't Someone Please Help ...
Ep 19
Armageddon (1)
Ep 18
Best of Enemies
Ep 17
Forgive Us Our Trespasses
Ep 16
Aaron's Gettin' Better
Ep 15
Standing Room Only
Ep 14
The Other End of the Teles...
Ep 13
Edifice Wrecked
Ep 12
Suspicion
Ep 11
Thieves Like Us
Ep 10
Love's Laborers' Lost
Ep 9
Life Out of Balance
Ep 8
Learner's Permit
Ep 7
Scribbling Rivalry
Ep 6
Food for Thought
Ep 5
Ozymandias 2.0
Ep 4
Feast or Famine
Ep 3
I Can't Stand Up For Falli...
Ep 2
Booklovers
Ep 1
Wake Up, Little Susie
-
dmarex EDITOR
User Score: 1010
-
ericlong
User Score: 312
-
Riff_Rafferty
User Score: 62
-
rustle49
User Score: 40
-
Yakira
User Score: 38
-
SrRui
User Score: 13
-
mitchelc
User Score: 12
-
Seapharris7
User Score: 9
-
Mafeu
User Score: 8
-
EKlumppJr
User Score: 8
-
char2renee
User Score: 7
More
Less
