|^^ I see what you're saying, I do. But on Clay's account, I do still think they are re-writing history a bit, in order to give Clay and Quinn a "family" before the end of the show (just not the conventional type of family, like Naley, Leyton and Brulian have). I don't have that much against it, as I do like Clay and Logan and the storyline, but I was just saying. |
And I still think the Brathan sex tape is unnecessary re-writing of history. You're saying that Ryan/Teresa IS re-writing because it is giving new background info on a character, but isn't the Brathan sex tape basically the same thing? It's not giving us much background info on Nathan as we already knew he was an ass back then, but it IS giving us new background info on Brooke, saying that she slept with Peyton's "boyfriend" long before she kissed Lucas. (Which I still think was a ridiculous way to try and make the girls "even" but whatever). It doesn't really matter that much anyway, I was just talking about Clay/Logan, Brathan was just another example.
No, I didn't day the Ryan Teresa thing is rewriting history. I was rhetorically asking you to prove a point about Brathan/Clay much like I did with asking the same Q about finding out Dan wanted the abortion.
Although @StellarChick, I have heard similar arguments to regarding RT such as "I thought Ryan didn't do girlfriends and only slept around" but that's around debate.
Back to @bronbrons27, It is totally plausible and realistic that Brathan could've slept together soph year.
Fans act like with that SL Mark did a complete or even a slight change in their personalties just to cater to that one SL. the sex tape fits into their personalities just fine, and does not change anything that was established about them in s1-4.
Now if it were about Lucas Haley... Or two other characters who didn't fit into the one night stand mold then that would be Mark changing previously written facts to cater to a SL he wanted to do.
But from s1, the very beginning, before Mark knew what SLs would be in s4 or that there'd even be a s4, it was established that Brooke frequented bars, drank like a fish every weekend, had casual sex every weekend to the point of her running into one of her previous one night stands and totally forgetting she knew him at all. And that took place also in s1. Likewise since s1 it was established that Nathan was not a good bf, to say the least flirted with other girls, he'll remember in the very Pilot when he is driving the bus that cheerleader being all over him and him welcoming it to say the least.
Peyton just breaking up w him, being drunk off his ass as well as Brooke, and the two at the time bring known for this type of behavior there's just nothing non plausible about this SL.