One Tree Hill Forums

^Pinky, I always love that you can take a situation where I could go "yeah like that would ever happen" and you come up with a possible plausible scenario and then I can go "yeah, okay" *nodds head* "I can see that" haha!

Anyway, had a few random things I wanted to add

1. Did anyone watch 'Whitney' tonight? They had Alex propose to Whitney and they had the same song that played when Lucas goes "its you, Peyton" at the state championship game. It was so distracting because I could only think of them haha

2. And I cant believe I am saying this, but I hope they dont dwell TOO much on Dan and the funeral in the next ep. I loved that they took a whole episode for Keith because he was a good man, affected a large part of the characters, and because he was taken suddenly. With Dan, you can argue that he's a good man but whatever, he really only affected Naley +1 and maybe Deb, and we knew ahead of time he was going. I'd rather take that time and have some character interaction than have more Dan stuff

3. Since the Craig Sheffer spoiler was wrapped so well, does it make anyone else wonder possibly about Hilarie and Chad? I dont want to get my hopes up, but I never thought that CS would come back without it being leaked or without his name being in the guest title credits (like Matt Barr, Bryan Greenberg, etc) so it could be possible. Just wondering what everyone else thought

I knew it. I knew they'd do that with the ending. There's no way you can do a scene with Dan passing on without Keith. And bravo for them for doing it.

Lucas not being here. That one I don't mind. He hates Dan. He has reason to hate Dan and it makes sense that he's not gonna come. They mentioned him. I filled in the gap myself that's how it should be done.

Overall this was a great episode. First properly good OTH episode in a really really long time.

Hehe, completely agree. And yeah, I meant in the finale, I never expected them back in the next episode. Wellllll here's hoping. I know Im not an LP fan but I still would LOVE to see them back, esp. Peyton since we havent seen her yet since s6 and Id also love to see how Sawyer looks now. I imagine her to look a lot like Jenny.

OK, So this was a great episode!!!!! Even though the Naley reunion was amazing, and as small as the initial reunion was, it still made me tear up!!!Love how Haley just didnt want to let go of nathan while they were hugging. It was sweet. And the scene when Lydia walking made me tear up too. I could seriously go on forever about the Naley scenes so i am going to stop. lol.. I really liked Haley and Dan's closure. It was nice. It brought me bach to season 1 and nathan and haley started dating and Dan was telling Deb that Nathan could do better. And it especially was nice because he has given Haley so much crap over the years. I mean, we can safely rule out that Dan didnt like her in high school. The send off for Dan i really liked. It actually had me feeling not so upset as i was expecting. SURE, I am sad that he died, but i didn't ball my eyes out crying because of the way the whole episode was with everyone's closure with Dan. It kinda gave me closure for his character too

This episode was amazing from beginning to end. There were some things that could've been cut out, but I'll focus on Dan right now. I am so sad that he died. It's amazing how much you can feel for characters from a fictional tv show. My eyes actually got a little teary, especially close to the end on the rivercourt where Nathan told Dan he loved him, and Dan said it back. When Dan started crying, I was through (PJ is a really good actor, there are only a few people on OTH who can cry without it looking forced or funny, and he's one of them). Every scene with Dan and other characters, especially Deb was great. I was glad that Dan/Deb got closure, and he told her not to blame herself for Keith's death; I also liked the banter between them. Dan/Haley/Lydia/Jamie was also sad, but sweet at the same time. At least he was able to seehis grandkidsbefore he died. Keith showing up was a good surprise (and CS has totally aged). Anyway, "you're my plus one" was an amazing line. It was good to see Dan/Keith together, even though it meant they were both dead. My thoughts don't seem to be formulating the way I want them to. I thought there was more I wanted to say about Dan, but I guess not. To me, this was the saddest episode of the season.

I honestly thought the stuff about Clay/Logan and Brooke/her dad could've been ommitted (especially Brooke/her dad). When I saw Sara's parents I was thinking where did they come from, and how come Logan hadn't been with them before, but as someone posted previously, the Dr. probably had Logan at the treatment center tohelp jog Clay's memory. As adorable as Logan is, I found myself no longer invested in this SL as much as I was before.

Brooke/her dad were totally pointless. I'll admit, I was even suckered into thinking he might want a real relationship with her, but he doesn't. Most viewers already knew he was abad father, and he wasn't going to change; all of those scenes betweenseemed repetitive from he episode where Brooke thought he wanted to go golfing with her just because instead of discussing business.

I'm also not that crazy about Julian turning Ravens into a tv show. I totally understand that originally OTH was going to be a movie, but Mark decided to turn it into a series, so that's probably why this is being done, but it's basically a rip off of the Dawson's Creek series finale. Even though Dawson didn't write a book, his tv show The Creek was about his experiences as teenager with his friends, just like Ravens was about Lucas' earlier life and experiences with his friends and coming to terms with his relationship with Nathan, Dan, etc. Obviously many of the experiences were different, but the premise is the same, and I honestly don't think it's original, but whatever. I'm still sad the show is ending