I agree with you guys.
What Ive always wondered about, and they could put this into a SL if they wanted to, was what was the story behind Karen/Dan/Keith back when they were teens? It couldve gone in one of two ways so I mean:
Did 1. Karen and Dan know each other because they were the popular ones, she a cheerleader and he on the basketball team, so then they went out (similar to Peyton and Nathan)? Then once Keith got to know Karen through Dan, he fell in love with her but became friends.
Or 2. Were Karen and Keith already friends, he loved her but never told her, and then she decided to go after Dan? Sort of like if Lucas secretly had a crush on Haley and then he was hurt when she decided to go after Nathan but because they were friends, he decided to stick with her.
Scenario #2 would make more sense to me as to why Keith would stick around with her for so long even though she was dating his brother but I dont know.
Yeah number two makes more sense but we know that keith was also on the basketball team for a brief period of time with dan so it could of been that they were all friends to begin with then when he quit basketball there friendship probably went back a few steps and then she ended up with dan ,,,, would be nice to see