One Tree Hill

Season 2 Episode 5

I Will Dare

Aired Wednesday 8:00 PM Oct 19, 2004 on The CW
out of 10
User Rating
367 votes

By Users

Episode Summary

Felix organizes a "dare night" to test the limits of his new classmates. While out playing the game, Lucas meets a mysterious new girl, Anna, and the two of them share an instant attraction. Peyton tearfully confesses to the church that she recently tried cocaine, and Keith is caught off guard when a beautiful woman comes on to him. Meanwhile, Karen goes on a date with Andy, her younger professor.moreless

Who was the Episode MVP ?

No results found.
No results found.
No results found.
  • Dare Night

    I hate Felix, but he did organize and event that became one of my favorite episodes. Dare night is so much fun. I kind of want to do this with my friends.

    Karen has a date with Andy which goes really well. I like them together.

    On Dare Night it's the guys (Lucas, Nathan, Tim, Mouth, Fergie, and Skills) against Felix & the girls (Brooke, Peyton, and Haley). They do a lot of fun and a couple risky dares. My favorite's are the karaoke that Mouth, Skills, and Fergie do and the dare Lucas did with the clothes. It was hilarious watching Lucas go from store to store returning the women's clothes he was wearing.

    Keith also met a very pretty woman at the dealership.moreless
  • this was a good ep

    in this ep of the show one tree hill brooks new neibor has a party and it turns into a dear night were to win you have to do dears and they break up into teams and lucas goes and meets a mystrious strange that he has attraction for but later finds out its brooks neibors sister and also in this ep caren goes on a date with her young professor that she gets along with in class and keith goes on a date also but its with a younger women who he falls for . this was a good ep and lucas teams loses becasue he does not show the photos and peyton tells in church she tried cocain and other things happen this was a good epmoreless
  • Felix organizes a game of dare. Lucas meets a mysterious stranger. Nathan and Tim reconnect. Brooke gets to know Felix a little better. Karen and her professor flirt. Keith meets a woman whilst test driving a car.moreless

    I really liked this episode. It is, to date, one of my favourite. It's one of those episodes that's not too heavy and there's not much drama or plot development but it's a lot of fun. I'm still not entirely sure about Felix as to whether or not I like him or not but he's bringing out another side of Brooke which I like. The dares on a whole were fun and entertaining except I'm not sure how exactly someone steals an animal from the zoo without being caught... but maybe I'm just underestimating Mouth and Skill's skills...

    I loved Mouth in his karaoke scene, and the sexual tension between Felix and Brooke made me smile.

    I know I've already said it but I loved this episode. Maybe that was just because there was less "Naley" (I despise coupley names but I couldn't help myself) than usual.moreless
  • This is one of the best One Tree Hill episodes!

    This episode has everything. Is is extremely funny but it can be serious at times, especially with Peyton and Brooke's respective story lines. The dunny parts are absolutly hilarious! Nate and Tim are very funny in this epidode. They go in girl scouts outfits trying to sell cookies! Even if you dont want to watch the whole episode watch their scenes! Lucas has a funny story line to, running through the mall returning all his clothes! Lucas also runs into Felixs' sister Anna. She helps out of a situation with a mall cop! They spend the night going around town getting to know eachother! All in all this is a classic One Tree Hill episodes and it's well worth a watch!moreless
  • Bring on the dares,the new couples and the surpries. One Tree Hill has it all !

    Mouth and Skills sing karaoke and steal a turtle. Brooke eats dinner and then dosen't pay for it. Lucas walks around in leather pants an a bra. Tim gets a full body wax and then sh!ts in a hole. Peyton eats five eggs and then cofesses that she took coccaine. Brooke also falls into an empty grave. What's going on ? Felix's dare night. Lucas meets a girl named Anna. He likes her ( It would be wrong for a girl and a guy to meet each other and not date on One Tree Hill :P ). Keith meets a strange woman whom he was attracted to. This woman wants to buy a car. Karen goes on a date with her teacher. Another hilarious episode with great dialogue. I am starting to like Felix's character. He certainley is charming. Anna's character is alright. She would make a nice girlfriend for Lucas. A well written episode which combines comedy with romance and does it in style ! I liked this episode. I saw that there was lack of drama in this season until the previous episode but what this episode proved was that it's all about fun now. The writers are just inventing storylines to make the viewers laugh and one emotional Peyton scene in the church will not fill our needs for delecious dramatic twists. You know, twists like the Lucas/Peyton/Brooke storyline. It's kind of stupid that the love triangle that was so huge is being igonored and turned into something so unexistant. Tim annoys me so much. I think his character should just get killed off in any sort of way. Good episode, but One Tree Hill needs to tone down the fun and bring in some tears.moreless
Sallie Hedrick

Sallie Hedrick

Sales Girl

Guest Star

Mark Scarboro

Mark Scarboro


Guest Star

Chuck Kinlaw

Chuck Kinlaw

Security Guard

Guest Star

Antwon Tanner

Antwon Tanner

Antwon "Skills" Taylor

Recurring Role

Lee Norris

Lee Norris

Marvin "Mouth" McFadden

Recurring Role

Kieren Hutchison

Kieren Hutchison

Andy Hargrove

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions


  • TRIVIA (5)

    • Goof: When Lucas is in the store returning the pants and goes to snap the picture, you can clearly see that no picture is being taken. The phone screen is white.

    • Daniella Alonso plays the character of Anna, who is Felix (played by Michael Copon)'s little sister. In real life, Daniella is actually 4 years older than Michael.

    • When in the confessional, Peyton reads "Bless me father, for I have sinned" then turns the card over to see the side where this is actually written.

    • This is the second time that Switchfoot's "Dare You to Move" has been played on One Tree Hill.

    • Haley is holding the cell phone to take a picture of Peyton eating the eggs and her hands move up and down between shots.

  • QUOTES (38)

    • Mouth: You know, Skills, you could always keep him. He could be your first pet.
      Skills: Man, I'm not bout to keep some creepy looking turtle, dawg. Besides, caged up ain't living. He need to be free.
      Skills: There you go.
      Fergie: You realize that was a saltwater turtle right?

    • Keith: Well I'd, uh, point out the safety features but I think that fact that uh, you know, we got back in one piece speaks for itself. Look Jules, you picked a good car. But um, the price you offered me was a grand too high and uh I couldn't take a penny more.
      Jules: Is this some new car selling trick?
      Keith: How would I know? I'm just a mechanic.
      Jules: How bout if I think about it?
      Keith: Was my counter offer too low?
      Jules: No, I just figured that if I wait a few days, then you'll have to call me. You have my number.
      Keith: Wow.

    • Felix: OK, I think they're gone. Gimme a boost.
      Brooke: Are you kidding? Your shoes are muddy.
      Felix: It's either you give me a boost or be buried alive girly girl.
      Brooke: Huh! Fine! OK. Get me out. Stupid dare night. Where did you come up with this ridiculousness anyway? I mean, what is the point!
      Felix: The point is simple, see how far you'll go. You face your fears. And sometimes you'll do things you wanna do because calling it a dare makes it OK for a night.
      Brooke: Things like what?
      Felix: Like spending time with me.

    • Lucas: How much do I owe you for the pizza?
      Anna: Nothing. I took a little extra from the fountain. This is weird. Isn't it? Oh I mean, people don't just meet and hang out like this. Unless it's a hook-up. And it's not?
      Lucas: I didn't think it was. Besides, not doing that anymore.
      Anna: Anymore?
      Lucas: Long story. Trust me.
      Anna: Do you think two people can get to know each other, without ever going into their long stories?
      Lucas: Sure.
      Anna: But isn't who you were a part of who you are?
      Lucas: Maybe, but I guess I'm saying that, I don't really need to know the person that you used to be. As much, as the person that you're trying to be.
      Anna: Yeah, me too.

    • Andy: You have a son? Nice.
      Karen: Yeah.
      Lucas: Well he's got a tough mom. I think it's so great that you went back to school in your late twenties you know. Early thirties?
      Karen: Hmm.
      Andy: My god, how old are you?
      Karen: Old enough to have never heard of that band, The Constantines.
      Andy: Ah, but you see, now you're one of the hip kids.

    • Skills: Hey yo, Fergie, what's the next dare?
      Fergie: Karaoke.
      Skills and Fergie: Mouth!

    • Brooke: Oh, you are such a jerk!
      Felix: Come on, it was just a dare. You got us big points for that one. Lock it up!
      Brooke: You should be locked up!
      Felix: Brooke, I'm sorry! Don't go. It was just part of the game. I promise. I didn't know you'd be so upset. OK? How bout you read the next one?
      Brooke: Go to the cemetery. Hm! And take a photo in an open grave! That's perfect. Since I plane on killing you, anyway!
      Felix: I think we get bonus points for that.
      Brooke: Great!

    • Keith: So, um where was I?
      Jules: You're trying to force me to get the CD changer!
      Keith: I wasn't forcing you. It's just an option I thought you might like. There's um, also the leather interior, the optional touring package and option to pause at stop signs!
      Jules: OK, that wasn't my fault. The thing just jumped out at me.
      Keith: The stop sign?
      Jules: It practically pounced!
      Keith: OK! Um, I think maybe I should drive us back.
      Jules: No, I'll be fine. I just get a little nervous. I only have so much money and this is a big decision for me. Besides, car sales men are always such jerks. Why are you smiling at me?
      Keith: My brother owns the dealership, I'm just helping out. I'm actually a mechanic.
      Jules: Oh. I like mechanics.

    • Nathan: Sell a box of cookies.
      Tim: Great. I get my crack waxed and you get cookies.
      Massuese: Felix left this for you.
      Nathan: You know, I really don't like this Felix kid.

    • Anna: Ha, mission accomplished. You want the locker key back?
      Lucas: No thanks! Look, I'm sorry about all of this. I, just, dare night thing. Just didn't wanna back down.
      Anna: Oh yeah. I saw you earlier and I figured it was something like that. I didn't want you to get busted for just having a little fun.
      Lucas: Thank you. So what's your name?
      Anna: Anna.
      Lucas: I'm Lucas. You from Tree Hill?
      Anna: Yeah, but we wouldn't have met.
      Lucas: Why not?
      anna: Oh, I tend not to roll with guys in bras and leather pants.
      Lucas: You're funny.
      Lucas: Oh sorry. Anyway, I owe you one.
      Anna: Well how bout you pay me back by letting me play too.
      Lucas: OK.
      Anna: So? What's next?
      Lucas: Um I don't know. Lets find out.

    • Brooke: Hello?
      Felix: You know, you shouldn't be answering my phone.
      Brooke: Where the hell are you?
      Felix: I'm at the café.
      Brooke: What!
      Felix: Flip the dare card over, and read it.
      Brooke: You did not just leave me here! Look, I don't have the money to pay for this and I am not walking out on the cheque!
      Felix: Why not? I've seen you steal before. Besides, I dare ya.

    • Skills: Come on Mouth, toughen up dawg!
      Mouth: It's gonna hurt!
      Skills: So what? Be a warrior.
      Fergie: Yeah, take one for the team Mouth.
      Mouth: But what about you guys?
      Skills: Man, I'm takin the pictures.
      Fergie: I'm helpin him.
      Skills: Dang! Man I missed that one. You gonna have to do it again. Come on, back on the plate.

    • Masseuse: OK! Full body treatment.
      Tim: The special. We want the special.
      Nathan: What exactly is the special?
      Massuese: Oh the special is very nice. Who's first?
      Tim: Me!
      Massuese: OK I'll just peel back your sheet.
      Tim: Oh yeah!
      Nathan: So this is legitimate right? This is like a massage?
      Tim: Dude, shut up! I am concentrating.
      Nathan: Yeah, you know what, I really don't think I need to be here for this.
      Massuese: Oh, it won't take long.
      Nathan: Yeah, I'll bet.
      Massuese: OK, one special full body wax!

    • Brooke: So what, you can't get a date. Move to new towns and trick people into eating with you?
      Felix: Wow, you totally exposed me. Seriously, I mean mostly naked here. How bout you? What's your story?
      Brooke: Bored and ignored.
      Felix: Bored maybe, but you never been ignored by a guy in your life.
      Brooke: I meant at home genius. Guys are easy. They usually fall for me over the first pathetic little dinner.
      Felix: Yeah? What do they fall for first? The shoplifting or the eating disorder?
      Brooke: Excuse me! Hi. Just curious, what's your most expensive entrée?
      Waiter: Well, we have,
      Brooke: Sounds great. I'll take two. I'm really hungry.
      Felix: Nicely played. I'll be right back.

    • Mouth: It says we have to get a hit on the fastest pitching machine.
      Skills: Oh man, this all good, back up.
      Mouth: Using your head.
      Skills: Well come on man, get in there. We aint got all day. Let's go.

    • Keith: Can I uh, help you?
      Jules: Forty one thousand four hundred and sixty seven dollars.
      Keith: OK
      Jules: I know exactly what the dealer invoice on this car is. MSRP, tax, freight. I don't wanna haggle over scotch or, floor mats or anything. Take it or leave it.
      Keith: And you're sure you want this car?
      Jules: Absolutely!
      Keith: Hmm. Well maybe you wanna test-drive it before you over-pay me.

    • Waiter: Table for two. Right this way sir.
      Brooke: How did you do that?
      Felix: I made a reservation for two last week. Come on team mate.

    • Brooke: OK, so all I have to do is get a table?
      Felix: With no waiting. It's the hottest restaurant in town.
      Brooke: If you insist on wasting my time, at least come up with better dares. Hi, I was wondering,
      Waiter: Name?
      Brooke: Brooke Davis.
      Waiter: No.
      Brooke: You didn't even check your list.
      Waiter: Perhaps there's another name.
      Brooke: Angelina Jolie.
      Waiter: No.
      Brooke: The Queen of Sheeba.
      Waiter: No.
      Brooke: The Queen of Hearts.
      Waiter: No.
      Brooke: How about Queen Latifah?
      Waiter: I'm afraid not.

    • Nathan: Well this is it. Massage and Spa.
      Tim: What's the back say?
      Nathan: Ask for the special.
      Tim: It's the Happy Ending.

    • Lucas: I'd like to return this shirt. Oh, I happen to have the receipt. Here it is, yeah.
      Cashier: Can I ask you why you'd like to return it?
      Lucas: Um, wrong size?
      Cashier: Can't we get you another size?
      Lucas: No, thanks, no I'm good.

    • Andy: You like The Constantines?
      Karen: Sure. I mean as much as anyone can like a band they've never heard of.

    • Tim: Come on! I wanna play. I didn't get invited.

    • Tim: All anybody does in this town is brood, pout or get married.

    • Nathan: Tim, come with me.
      Tim: I'm in it to win it!
      Nathan: Just say yes, Tim.

    • Lucas: (after Felix hands him a key) What's this?
      Felix: That, my friend, is your first dare.

    • Felix: It's called dare night. One night, two teams, multiple dares.

    • Brooke: (After looking at her first dare) Please! I can do that in my sleep!
      Felix: Great. Prove it!

    • Tim: Don't you miss your Tim time?
      Nathan: Do I miss hanging out with you? Yes. Do I miss you saying things like Tim time? No.

    • (Peyton has to eat five pickled-eggs on Dare Night)
      Haley: Alright. You doing this now?
      Peyton: Here we go.
      Haley: Do it, do it. Go, go, go!
      (Peyton reluctantly eats half of one of the pickled-eggs and Haley takes a picture)
      Haley: Four-and-a-half more to go! (Peyton gets a napkin and spits it out) Oh, make that five. Mmm, not cheating tastes good. (Peyton shoves the napkin in Haley's face) Ew, get that away from me! Are you crazy?

    • (Haley and Peyton are doing the pickled egg dare)
      Haley: So I have an idea. Why don't we get a picture of you eating on egg, and then tell them you ate five?
      Peyton: Haley James Scott. We don't cheat.
      Haley: Well you did with Lucas.
      Peyton: Don't make me smack you!
      (Haley laughs while drinking soda)
      Peyton: Here!
      (Peyton hands Haley the phone)

    • Andy: So, how are you? Is everything alright?
      Karen: You've stopped in for coffee every day this week. I mean, I enjoy seeing you, but, it's just, I don't think it's appropriate...
      Andy: Well, ya know, in some countries, you can buy coffee without actually having to have sex with the cafe owner. Those countries aren't nearly as much fun for me, but what are you gonna do?

    • Lucas: Anna? I dare you to call me.

    • Mouth: What do we win?
      Felix: You, Mouth, win an excuse to be out 'till midnight.

    • Felix: Well, well. With the other dares, it appears to be a tie.
      Tim: Oh no, oh no, wait. Don't forget this. (Shows Felix the picture from the golf course)
      Felix: Dude! What the hell are you doing?!
      Tim: It says it right here on the dare card.
      Felix: Man, that's a typo. It's supposed to say, "Take a shot in the second hole."

    • Tim: Dude, check out Part 2. Get it? Dude, the hole's #2.
      Nathan: There is something wrong with you, you know that, right?
      Tim: What? I didn't write the dare card. Hey, give me the camera and give me some leaves, all right?

    • Peyton: Bless me Father, for I have sinned. You see lately I've been having impure thoughts about- Actually, I haven't been doing very well lately. This is the first time I've been in a church since my mom died. I think about her everyday. I just- I wonder what she would say to me right now if she could see me and see how I've been living. I wonder if she knows, on most days I fall short of being the person she wanted me to be, or I wonder if she saw me do that line of coke last week. And the thing is, I don't even know why I did it. You know, my life is pretty good... it is, but I was just searching for something to make it great... something to make it matter. So, I don't know, I guess last week when I had the chance to change that, and it was right there in front of me. I guess I was just scared to let that go. But I know it was wrong and I want my mom to know that and um, I want her to know that I am not that person... and I'm not going to be.

      (Peyton turns her dare to a real confession.)

    • Peyton: So we never really talked about the wedding, like how you got there.
      Haley: I told you, I got dressed, I threw up at my parents' house, brushed, flossed and went to the beach.
      Peyton: Okay, hard image to forget, but I meant more like, um, I don't know, how your heart got there. Marriage is big. I don't know how you trust somebody for your whole life. I can't even date somebody without an escape hatch.
      Haley: I don't know if it was so much about trusting Nathan, which I do. It was more about trusting myself.
      Peyton: Yeah, my old friend, self-doubt. I don't know, sometimes everything seems really simple, and then...
      Haley: ... it's not?
      Peyton: Yeah.

    • Nathan: Good evening, Mr. & Mrs. Tree Hill Resident. We're selling these delicious cookies to raise money for Lady Leprechauns, an organization that empowers us girls to become strong, beautiful, independant women of tomorrow.

  • NOTES (2)

    • Although credited, Paul Johansson (Dan), Barry Corbin (Whitey) and Barbara Alyn Woods (Deb) didn't appear in this episode. Not only is this Johansson's first abscence in the show, but it's also Woods's, at least since she became a regular.

    • Featured Music:
      "16 Below" by Light FM
      "Endless Shovel" by Rogue Wave
      "Welcome To the Movement" by Dee
      "The Keys To Life Vs. 15 Minutes of Fame" by Atmosphere
      "Everything Is" by Nectar
      "Funny Little Feeling" by Rock-N-Roll Soldiers
      "Good Time" by Walkie Talkie
      "Baby Got Back" by Lee Norris
      "Somersault" by Zero 7
      "Dare You To Move" by Switchfoot
      "Hey Sugar" by D'Lovely
      "Collide" by Howie Day


    • When the two teams are split up, Felix says to Peyton, Haley and Brooke, "Well, hate to break up Charlie's Angels..." The reason he said this is because Charlie's Angels was a tight threesome just like Peyton, Haley, and Brooke are.

    • Episode Title: I Will Dare

      I Will Dare is from the band The Replacements off the album, Let It Be.

    • When Mouth is in the club with Fergie and sings it's an allusion of the movie Charlie's Angels (2000). Cameron Diaz is dancing on the same song and everybody's mocking at her.