Looking back at this episode during a rerun on SoapNet, I felt the need to comment on it. This was Season 5, when One Tree Hill was struggling to find its footing right after the 4.5 year time jump. They wanted to have Peyton and Lucas together again, but they gave us a mediocre reason to keep them apart and the typical rebound girl in Lindsay, who we knew had no chance of being the one.
This is where Bethany Joy Galeotti really shined and established herself as the best actress on The CW, but even she could not save some of the awful Mia, Nathan/Carrie and Brooke storylines. Luckily the show has improved upon this right now.moreless





