Brooke and Julian are waiting anxiously at the hospital in anticipation of seeing their baby. Haley and Nathan are also at the hospital about to have their baby girl. Brooke and Julian refrain from telling people that they are there for their baby because they did not want to steal Nathan and Haley's thunder. Clay and Quinn keep Jamie company in the waiting room and they decide to make a scrapbook.
Throughout the episode, we experience a series of flashbacks where we relive Nathan and Haley's first kiss, how Brooke and Haley's friendship started, and when Clay was in a coma. Haley and Julian discuss what to name their baby girl. Meanwhile Jamie, Clay, and Quinn talk about how Haley was named.
All of a sudden Chloe's boyfriend walks in holding the baby. He announces that he has decided to keep the baby. Brooke cries and says that it was a girl. Then we hear Nathan announce that he and Haley's baby is a girl. Brooke agonizes over her best friend getting a baby girl, while she does not. She has to try her best to act happy for Haley.