One Tree Hill

Season 4 Episode 14

Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers

2
Aired Wednesday 8:00 PM Feb 14, 2007 on The CW
9.4
out of 10
User Rating
493 votes
58

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
Haley confronts Brooke regarding the stolen calculus test. Lucas and Peyton consider taking their relationship to the next level as Peyton and Brooke grow closer. In Deb's absence, Nathan throws a senior party at the Scott House where a sex tape from Nathan's past surfaces.

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Tuesday
No results found.
Wednesday
No results found.
Thursday
No results found.
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • Party!

    9.5
    Typical of Tree Hill to throw a spanner in the works just as Peyton and Brooke inch towards getting closer. Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers was an entertaining hour to say the least.



    Lucas and Peyton do get closer and nearly take the next step. I like how they're just happy and have normal couple problems now. They are good together. Likewise with Nathan and Haley. So they had to screw things up by revealing that sex tape with Brooke and Nathan. It was certainly shocking and loved how it ended with everyone at the party just staring at Brooke thinking what the hell did you do. Drama, drama. And nice foreshadowing with Brooke and Nathan playing outside in the sprinklers.



    I loved that Haley slapped Rachel and threw the drink in her face. Even though she was wrongly accused, it was a long time coming after all the stunts she pulled with Nathan. Classic feisty Haley! Love her. Mouth and Shelly was pretty awful. Why should I care? They literally got together last episode so this love thing was pretty bull. Too soppy and OTT for words.



    Rachel taking the fall for Brooke was actually quiet sweet in a way, I even feel a little sorry for her. How awkward was it when Brooke walked in on Peyton and Lucas? But at least she and Peyton were on talking terms...not for long.



    Who doesn't love a party?



    9.5/10moreless
  • Party!!!!!!

    9.5
    Rachel takes the fall for taking the calculus test after Turner has them take a retest to find out who cheated. It was really nice of Rachel to take the fall for this since it was her idea to begin with so that group wouldn't get in trouble. It sucked that Turner fired Haley though. It's not like she let Rachel have the key. She stole the key and the test. It was ridiculous to include Haley in the blame. But I did love when Haley attacked Rachel. That slap was brilliant and well deserved!!



    Lucas and Peyton are so perfect!! I just absolutely love them!! I love that they ended up back in a bedroom at the Scott house just like in season 1. So cute!!



    Haley is awesome! It's so sweet that she decided to move into Deb's house so she won't be alone. And I love that they decided to throw a big party with all the alcohol they found hidden around the house.



    And that tape...oh wow!! Never would have imagined Nathan and Brooke hooked up like that.moreless
  • Season 4, Episode 14.

    10
    Wow. Great episode! This was really a series classic. It was so well written! I loved it! Nathan has a party, where Mouth ends up losing his virginity to Clean Teen Shelley. I couldn't believe it! I loved that Brooke almost got caught cheating. I can't believe Rachel did that for her! That was so sweet! I loved when Haley threw the drink in Rachel's face for getting her fired, and then slapped her for trying to sleep with Nathan. They almost fought. I thought it was nice when Brooke and Nathan had that friendly moment under the sprinklers. I never knew they were together! The sex tape thing rocked! 10/10.moreless
  • Haley finds out that Brook is the one who stole the exam, then she confronts Rachel at the party, A tape from Nathan's and Brook's past comes up threatening Payton's and Brook's friendship once again. I loved the seen w Nathan and Brook.moreless

    10
    Ok let me just start by saying wow to Mark Shawarn for this episode! I thought it was amazing! anyways cudos to James Laffery and Sophia Bush on that seen with the bench outside of the house. I felt really bad for Payton. I mean she just got her friend back then her friend went and did something like that... that must have sucked. and yes Chase is annoying the hell outta me.. i don't like him he was also annoying on "The Hills" if anyone remembers that. but I don't know maybe it's just me anyways I loved the Lucas and Payton seen in her room after Lucas tells Payton to back off then she gets pissed for taking her side. I would have gotten pissed as well. also i don't remember if it was this episode or the next episode but the catfight between Brook and Payton was halerious! YES finally we see some good old fashion fighting on the show between the two of them! but somehow over the years Payton let it go and they became friends again. well that's my opinionmoreless
  • I loved it!

    9.5
    Principal Turner finds out that Rachel is the one who stole the test because Rachel switches hers and Brooke's quizzes for calculus. Skills, Nathan and Mouth decide to throw a party after finding tons of booze at the house. Deb is in rehab and is now allowed to have visitors. Nathan visits and gives her tough love. Haley loses her tutoring job because she was tutoring Rachel. Shelly breaks up with Mouth. At the party, they hook up and Mouth loses his virginity to her, but she says that they can't see each other. Peyton and Lucas decide to have sex. Dan wants to be in Lucas' life more. Brooke gets an invitation for Victoria's Secret to franchise Clothes Over Bros. Dan asks Karen to the prom as chaperones. There is a sex tape of Nathan and Brooke from the year before and many people are shocked and hurt.



    This episode was great! I can't believe Nathan and Brooke! I never pictured them together. I love Mouth and Shelly together, but I wish that Mouth would've waited until marriage and Shelly would've waited too. I love the idea of Clean Teens, but I wish they stuck to their principles. This episode gets a 9.5 out of 10!moreless
Shontelle Thrash

Shontelle Thrash

Nurse

Guest Star

Mick Walker

Mick Walker

Salesman

Guest Star

Joy Yascone

Joy Yascone

Girl #1

Guest Star

Stephen Colletti

Stephen Colletti

Chase Adams

Recurring Role

Amber Wallace

Amber Wallace

Glenda Farrell

Recurring Role

Bevin Prince

Bevin Prince

Bevin Mirskey

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (4)

    • Goof: When Nathan and Brooke's sex tape is played at the party, Nathan's appears to be the same length that it is in this episode. However, when the tape was supposedly made, in the earlier seasons, Nathan's hair was much shorter.

    • In the scene where Haley is telling Nathan about getting fired from the tutor center, the camera angle is shot from a distance, and she is laying back against some pillows. But in the middle of Haley's sentence, the angle switches to a close-up, and she falls back against the same pillows she was already laying against.

    • In the past footage of Nathan playing, we see him wearing the black Ravens uniform but they said that those uniforms were new and in honor of Keith after the school shootings.

    • We find out that Rachel has been to four other high schools before becoming a student at Tree Hill High.

  • QUOTES (31)

    • (Throws a drink in Rachel's face)
      Haley: That's for getting me fired.
      (Slaps Rachel)
      Haley: And that is for trying to sleep with my husband.
      Rachel: Bitch you are lucky you're pregnant.
      Haley: Honey you're lucky that I'm pregnant. I think it's time you get your insecure, cheating, skank ass out of this house, right now!

    • (Mouth and Shelly getting dress after sleeping together)
      Mouth: Shelly, are you ok? I mean was, was that ok?
      Shelly: Yea... I just have to find my shirt.
      (Skills walks in)
      Skills: Oh, my bad. (shuts the door) Nice work though!
      Mouth: Shelly..
      Mouth: Hey, hey don't cry. Skills won't tell anyone, I promise.
      Shelly: You don't understand, I gotta go.
      (She finds her shirt)
      Mouth: But tonight, this I mean, this was the start of really good. This was the start of us. Can't you feel that?
      Shelly: I'm a clean teen. I'm THE clean teen. I could love you, I know I could, but I can't.
      Mouth: Then what was this?
      Shelly: (sighs) This was good-bye.
      Mouth: Shelly please don't go.
      Shelly: Mouth, don't call me. If you really like me, just let me go.

    • Shelly: Mouth? Are you ok?
      Mouth: No.
      Shelly: I know it's my fault. (whispers) I'm sorry.
      Mouth: It's just hard, you know. I look at you, and it hurts so much to know that we can't be together.
      Shelly: Mouth...
      Mouth: And, I know you're a clean teen Shelly, but what do you want me to say? That I don't want to sleep with you? That I don't want the my first time to be with you? Well, I can't say that 'cuz that would be a lie. From the moment I saw you, I was hooked and then I got to look into to those beautiful eyes and kiss you. And now, that's all I want to do. I could kiss you forever, but I know I'm not good enough.
      Shelly: (Tearfully) No...
      (Shelly begins kissing Mouth)

    • Nathan: I don't feel like such a good guy right now.
      Haley: why?
      Nathan: I went to see my mom this morning and I think I was kinda hard on her.
      Haley: Babe, if anybody's needed tough love, it's your mom.
      Nathan: I know. But she's gonna be released in a few days and she told me she's scared to be alone in the house. She's gonna slip Haley, I can feel it!
      Haley: Oh, then why don't we do something about it?
      Nathan: Like what?
      Haley: I don't know... we need to save money, she needs help. We could let the apartment go and we could move in to her house. Yeah! Look, it'd be perfect! We'd save a ton of money, we'd be there to watch her 24/7, and everybody wins!
      Nathan: And Peyton thinks I'm a martyr
      Haley: Well, you know, she's your family, she's a train wreck but she's your mom.
      Nathan: You'd do that for her?
      Haley: No, but I'd do that for you.

    • Bevin: (To Haley) I thought you and Nathan were married.

    • Haley: Uhm, have you guys seen Rachel?
      Chase: She was holding court in the living room
      Haley: Clothed or unclothed?
      Brooke: Clothed, but it was about ten minutes ago, so you never know.
      (Haley seems annoyed and is set out to find Rachel to kick her out.)

    • (Nathan walks in on Lucas holding a picture of Keith)
      Nathan: Luke, you gotta help me find some booze, man, or it's going to get ugly down there. You gotta let this go man. (Nathan takes the picture of Keith) Keith's gone, Luke. Jimmy's gone. Nothing's going to bring them back. But you got a ton of people that love you out there and in a few months, most of those people are gonna go their seperate ways. So what do you say big brother? Let's have some fun.
      (Nathan pats Luke on the back, and Lucas smiles)

    • Skills: Don't look now, Mouth, but Shelly all up in here right now.
      Mouth: Where?
      Skills: 12 o'clock and closing fast.
      (We see Shelly rushing over to talk to Mouth)
      Mouth: Okay, on the count of three we're out of here. ready? Three.
      (Skills and Mouth split.)

    • (Haley enters the principal's office and knocks on the door)
      Haley: Hey principal Turner, you wanted to see me?
      Principal: Yes, please have a seat, Haley.
      Haley: Okay. (sighs and takes a seat)
      Principal Turner: We discovered who stole the calculus exam and unfortunately, it's someone you know. Rachel Gatina.
      Haley: Oh, uhm. It's not... Are you sure it's rachel?
      Principal Turner: Well, I've spoken to Miss Gatina, I'm quite sure. Haley you were tutoring her and access to that test was under your direct supervision.
      Haley: I know. I didn't give her the...
      Principal Turner: I'm sorry. But I'm afraid I have no choice but to resign your position at the tutor center effective immediately.
      Haley: No. Principal Turner, listen!
      Principal Turner: My decision is final. I'll need your key.
      (Haley goes in her purse to find the key, and puts it on his desk and gets up to leave)
      Principal Turner: Sorry it came to this, Haley. Word of advice, you might take a good look at who your real friends are.

    • Chase: Maybe you passed the test this time. I mean, stranger things have happend, like Brooke Davis is dating a clean teen.
      Brooke: Maybe. I mean it didn't feel that bad. Oh, who am I kidding? There is no way I passed that test.
      Chase: Brooke, this could be the change you need to start over. Think about it, if you pass this time, you did it all on your own.
      Brooke: Yeah, and if I didn't pass, I'm going to get expelled from school and my life as I know it is over.
      Chase: I believe in you.
      (Over the intercome "Brooke Davis please report to the principals office, immediately.")
      Brooke: Well, okay then, dead girl kissing.
      (Chase and Brooke kiss)
      Chase: Good luck.
      Brooke: Thanks.

    • (Nathan is going to visit his mom in rehab)
      Deb: Nathan.(Deb stands up)
      Nathan: Hi.
      Deb: Uhm, I-I wasn't sure you'd want to see me.
      Nathan: To be honest i wasn't sure I was coming.
      Deb: Oh, honey, I'm so sorry.
      Nathan: Suicide? Nice one mom, and thanks for the note, by the way
      Deb: Please nathan don't, you can't begin to understand this disease.
      Nathan: Disease? Is that what you're calling it now? Peytons mom, Ellie, had a disease, cancer, that's a disease mom. What you have is a weakness. And when the hell are you going to start fighting it.
      Deb: I know. I know I've been weak. But I, uh, I'm scared.
      Nathan: Of what? Your terrible life in that big expensive house cause I'm not seeing it, mom. What are you so scared of?
      Deb: Myself. Itds easy in here. I have a support team to stay sober, but out there, a lone, I'm not sure I can trust myself.
      Nathan: Mom, you better figure it out because if things don't change soon you're not going to have anything to come home to. (walks out)

    • Lucas: (voiceover) Do you ever wonder if we make the moments in our lives, or if the moments in our lives make us?

    • Principal Turner: As some of you may know, it has come to my attention that one of you cheated on the last exam. So today we're all going to take a pop quiz, and I asure you when I discover who that cheater is they will be dealt with in the harshest possible way.
      Rachel: (To Brooke) Didn't see that one coming.

    • Rachel: (To Brooke) So I like reading your mail, guilty pleasure.

    • (About Glenda)
      Peyton: What book?
      Lucas: Oh, I uh loaned her a copy of The Great Gatsby. She`s never read it. Can you believe that?
      Peyton: Well I took her as more of an Edgar Allen Poe kinda girl.

    • (Nathan feels Haley's stomach - Baby Scott is kicking)
      Nathan: I can feel it! That's our boy!
      Haley: Yeah!
      (Nathan and Haley hug)

    • Nathan: Haley! I heard you were fighting Rachel. You punched her?
      Haley: It was more of a b*tch slap...
      Skills: Yeah, that was after she threw the drink at her.

    • (Mouth and Shelly making out in the A/V Room)
      Shelly: We should slow down.
      Mouth: Feels like just the right speed to me.
      (They keep making out)
      (The bell rings)
      Shelly: Really. I have to go. Saved by the bell.

    • Dan: You don't wanna be the guy looking back at blue ruffles.
      Lucas: Ah, good point. So what'd you wear to prom?
      Dan: Blue ruffles.

    • Skills: There he is. Big night dawg, big night. So how you feel?
      Mouth: Well I lost my virginity, my prom date and the girl I could`ve really loved. All in one Night. To Tell you the truth Skills, I've never felt worse.

    • Lucas: You`re buying me a tuxedo?
      Dan: Every man owns his own tuxedo. And every father should know what it feels like to buy one for his son.

    • Chase: Maybe you passed the test this time, I mean stranger things have happened. Like Brooke Davis is dating a clean teen.

    • Peyton: (About Lucas) You know I love him. I really do! But I never meant for my love for him to hurt you.
      Brooke: Thank you, Peyton.

    • Skills: [to Haley] I told ya I got the kid's back.

    • [Splashes Rachel in the face with water]
      Haley: That is for getting me fired.
      [Slaps Rachel in the face]
      Haley: And that is trying to sleep with my husband.

    • Lucas: (voiceover) Do you ever wonder if we make the moments in our lives, or if the moments in our lives make us?

    • Lucas: (voiceover) If you could go back and just change one thing about your life, would you? And if you did, would that change make your life better? Or would that change ultimately break your heart? Or the heart of another? Would you choose an entirely different path? Or would you change just one thing? Just one moment. One moment that you've always wanted back?

    • Nathan: (coming towards Brooke) Where's the new boyfriend?
      Brooke: Taking a break. When all you do is kiss you gotta come out for air once in a while.
      Nathan: He seems like a really good guy...Chase.
      Brooke: (nodding) Yeah,he is. I really like him.
      Nathan: Good.
      Brooke: Listen, I'm really sorry about Haley and all tutor center thing.
      Nathan: Don't be sorry. It's not like it was your fault.
      Brooke: Yeah. So how come you're not in there, enjoying your big party?
      Nathan: Well, Skills broke out the old "Ravens Game" footage.
      (Brooke chuckles)
      Nathan: I swear, when I watch it, it doesn't even feel like me.
      Brooke: I should hope not! You were such a jerk! You were dating Peyton... you guys fought all the time...
      Nathan: Hey! look who's talking. Are you ever gonna let Peyton off him yet?
      Brooke: Yeah. I guess it's about time, isn't it?
      Nathan: (Looks at his watch) Yeah. Actually, it is. Don't move.
      Brooke: (Puzzled) Why? Nathan, what- what's going on?
      Nathan: The sprinklers.
      Brooke: What?!!!
      (sprinklers go off)
      Brooke: Oh! Oh! You think you're funny?! You are so dead!
      Nathan: Ahaha!
      (both wrestle)

    • (In a bedroom at Nathan's house)
      Lucas: I thought you said you wanted to wait.
      Peyton:Do you remember what you said the last time we were here? You said you wanted it all and... I walked away. I made a big mistake that night because all I wanted was sex.
      Lucas: What do you want now?
      Peyton: Now I want what you want. I want everything with you.
      (They kiss)

    • Peyton: Your mom is gonna come in any second.
      Lucas: She's working at the cafe, nobody's gonna walk in.
      (Brooke walks in on Lucas and Peyton kissing on Lucas' bed)
      Brooke: Okay, my discomfort meter is pretty much pegged.

    • Skills: Damn, Nate's mom is like the easter bunny of booze

  • NOTES (4)

    • There are two unaired scenes on the season 4 DVD set.

      The first is with Peyton and Glenda and they are talking about Lucas' book.

      The second is with Bevin and Nathan.

    • Although credited, Barry Corbin (Whitey) didn't appear in this episode.

    • Original International Air Dates:
      Italy: Friday, November 9, 2007
      Latin America: Sunday, November 25, 2007
      Greece: Saturday, February 9, 2008 on Star
      Australia: Sunday, June 29, 2008 on TEN HD

    • Featured Music:
      "Great Companion" by Landon Pigg
      "Close Your Eyes" by Young Love
      "Sewn" by The Feeling
      "About Today" by The National
      "Crash Sounds" by Blackpool Lights
      "About You" by Loops
      "Do You Want To Party With Me?" by Bosshouse
      "Well Here We Go Again" by Bosshouse
      "From The Last Last Call" by The Ataris
      "Into The Light" by The Chemistry Set

  • ALLUSIONS (3)

    • Skills: Nathan's mom is like the easter bunny of booze.

      This refers to the tradition of hiding eggs for children to find on Easter which also features the Easter bunny, just like the way Nathan's mom hid liquor all over her house.

    • Peyton: I know there is no tenth chapter in Great Gatsby.

      This refers to F. Scott Fitzgerald's book, which is about a tragic romance between a man and the woman he cannot have. In fact, it does only have nine chapters.

    • The title alludes the 2003 album by The National.

More
Less