One Tree Hill

Season 2 Episode 22

The Tide That Left and Never Came Back (1)

2
Aired Wednesday 8:00 PM May 24, 2005 on The CW
9.5
out of 10
User Rating
389 votes
16

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
In the first part of the two-hour season finale, things heat up between Lucas and Brooke after they head to New York for an overnight stay with Haley. Peyton is elated when she gets Jimmy Eat World to perform at TRIC just in time for Jake's release from jail. Meanwhile, Andy invites Karen to spend the summer with him in New Zealand.moreless

Who was the Episode MVP ?

Saturday
No results found.
Sunday
No results found.
Monday
No results found.
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • Set up for finale.

    8.5
    If last episode was a set up The Tide That Left and Never Came Back was more so.



    I really enjoyed seeing Lucas and Brooke visit Haley in New York. It kind of brought that storyline to the forefront and pointed out how much everything has changed. I liked Haley and Lucas's scenes and actually have missed their friendship. I still think Haley is acting strangely to not want to come back - and Lucas looked so sad when she revealed that - BUT it was great to see her having fans and them wanting autographs.



    Brooke blurting out that it's okay that Lucas likes Peyton was odd. She's blatantly falling for him and it's stupid to let this hold them back. But I know that this finale brings these two to a new place which I'm excited for it. Speaking of Peyton, she and Jake had to end in this episode. It was sad but maybe a little too soppy for me. It does suck that everybody leaves her though. Where will she go from here?



    Karen and Andy have always been likeable but I found myself not really caring that he has to leave. I know it's horrible and I hate how Dan is doing it but I'm kind of over their relationship now. But Andy does have dirt on Dan now though and that's interesting!! Nathan should go to High Flyers. Haley did it to him, he deserves it. Mouth and Erica - am I meant to care? I don't mind them but it seems very rushed and misplaced in a finale.



    Bring on Part 2!



    8.5/10moreless
  • Season Finale

    9.5
    Okay, since this episode and the next aired back to back and were put together on the DVD I'm going to write one review for the whole thing and post it on both.



    The kids are all working on an English final about tragedy. About whether the George Bernard Shaw quote "There are two tragedies in life. One is to lose your hearts desire, the other is to gain it," is true or not and their interpretation of what it means. It's a perfect topic for the kids in Tree Hill as they've each had to deal with some form of loss and tragedy over the past year.



    Peyton has gotten Jimmy Eat World to play at Tric. Jake gets out of jail after they find out Nicki lied in court, but it's too late because Nicki found Jenny and has taken off with her. So Jake leaves to go after her. I feel so bad for Peyton She finally got Jake back and now he is leaving again. And then on top it all she has this woman coming in and saying she is her mother which is creepy since her mom has been dead for years. She also has someone with a weird screen name sending her messages.



    Andy has to go to Australia and asks Karen to come with him. I was really glad that she did. They are great together, but I just wish Dan would stay out of it all and leave them alone, especially Lucas and Nathan. What kind of father screws around with his sons emotions and in Lucas' case his health like that. How dare he blame Nathan for Deb's addiction and "test" Lucas like that if that's really what it was. I still don't think it was a real college fund. I just can't see him ever paying for Lucas to go to college.



    I loved that Lucas and Brooke went to New York to see Haley. Lucas is such a good friend and a good brother. He just wants his friend back and wants to see his brother happy again. I also loved how he was with Chris. And when Brooke said she couldn't breathe because there was no room with Chris' ego!! Nathan decides to go to High Flyers and I'm glad. He deserves it. Haley comes home!!! I just wish Nathan would have been more accepting of her return.



    Deb comes home and wants her and Nathan to be a family again and wants them to get away from Dan. They almost have a way with the scam Dan has been running until Dan announces that the business is in Deb's name so instead of bringing down Dan it would bring down Deb.



    Nathan finds out Lucas continued to go after Dan after he asked him not to and that he went to go see Haley behind his back and decides they are no longer friends or brothers. When the season starts they are teammates and nothing else. This seems a bit far to me. Haley is Lucas' best friend and sister-in-law. He didn't have to tell Nathan he went to visit her. They were friends long before Nathan ever went out with her.



    I am still a full on Leyton fan, but I did love when Lucas told Brooke how he felt. They are cute together, but I'm not a big fan of them as a couple.



    And once again we end the series with a cliffhanger about Dan. This time instead of a heart attack he is in the middle of a fire. And once again I hoped he would die and it sucks he didn't. And addition to whether Dan lives or dies we are also left with the cliffhanger of how or who started the fire.

    moreless
  • this was a good ep

    9.0
    in this ep of the show one tree hill its the first part of the two hour season 2 final and lucas and haley go to new york to spend time with haley to get her to come back to tree hill. and andy asks karen to come and spend time with him in new zealand spend the summer time down there. and payton is tring to get a gig and she does and she gets jimmy eat world and she is happey because jake will be getting out of jail tonight. this was a really good ep i thoughtmoreless
  • Loved it!!!

    10
    I love every thing about this episode but my favourite part is when jimmy eat world play hear you me the whole part of that song is amazing when andy leaves and then they all do voice overs i think that was an amazing idea. i was nearly crying when jake left it was so sad i feel sorry for peyton and jake but oh well now with jake out of the way peyton and lucas can get back together all peyton has to do is kill brooke and hide her body in her back garden but i no that doesn't happen because i have seen all the episde so i no shes still there in season 6. OMG jake is in bride wars how good is that =]moreless
  • Season 2, Episode 22.

    9.5
    In the first part of the two-hour season finale, things heat up between Lucas and Brooke after they head to New York for an overnight stay with Haley. Peyton is elated when she gets Jimmy Eat World to perform at TRIC just in time for Jake's release from jail. Meanwhile, Andy invites Karen to spend the summer with him in New Zealand. I loved the beginning narration! :) Hehe, Brooke and Lucas walk in on Chris tickling Haley. Andy asks Karen to go to New Zealand! I still can't stand Whitey, though. He should marry Dan or something. Otherwise, cool episode. =]moreless
Joe Inscoe

Joe Inscoe

Teacher

Guest Star

Eric Hissom

Eric Hissom

Guard

Guest Star

Jennifer Pena

Jennifer Pena

Girl #1

Guest Star

Bryan Greenberg

Bryan Greenberg

Jake Jagielski

Recurring Role

Kieren Hutchison

Kieren Hutchison

Andy Hargrove

Recurring Role

Emmanuelle Vaugier

Emmanuelle Vaugier

Nicki

Recurring Role

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

  • TRIVIA (1)

    • About a half hour into the episode, you see Nathan shooting baskets. There is a quick cut to a board with the Ravens roster. It says Lucas is a sophomore, and Nathan is a senior, which doesn't make sense. First of all both boys are supposed to be juniors and secondly, Lucas was born just a few months prior to Nathan - if anything, Lucas is the older of the two. Also, show creator Mark Schwahn's name inexplicably appears at the bottom.

  • QUOTES (37)

    • Brooke: (starts breathing shallowly) I can't breathe. There's no room in Chris' ego! Can we go?

    • Mouth: So Mr. Shaw thinks that getting your heart's desire is a tragedy? I say he's wrong. I mean, clearly Shaw never kissed Erica Marsh.

    • Whitey: I came to say I'm sorry. Dan, you were a great player. Maybe I was a lousy couch. Maybe I should have listened to you more and eased up a little bit. But we can bury all that now and do what's best for Nathan.
      Dan: And you think High Flyers is what's good for him?
      Whitey: I think he needs to get away and bathe himself in the game that you taught him to love. The game that gave you all the hopes and dreams it gave me. If saying I'm sorry will help your son, a kid who, by the way, I think the world of, then I'm sorry. I was wrong. And I mean that sincerely.
      Dan: You know what, Whitey? You're right. I was a great player, and you were a lousy coach. Still are.

    • Nathan: Whitey thinks he can get me back into High Flyers.
      Dan: As much as I love hearing you talk about basketball again, I really don't think camp is a smart play for you right now.
      Nathan: Dad, it's High Flyers.
      Dan: Exactly my point. You're injured Nathan. You don't want the scouts to see you like that. Plus, there's your mother to consider. Listen, I don't like to burden you with these things, but you're a man, so I'm gonna be honest with you. Your mother's pill addiction started when you moved out. Now in no way does that mean you're to blame, cause you're not. But she's gonna be vulnerable when she comes home, and she's gonna need you more than ever.

    • Jake: I need you to forget about me, and move on, okay? You're too amazing to carry this around. You're too full of greatness... and I love you too much. (They cling to each other). I have to go.
      Peyton: No!
      Jake: I can't have Jenny be with Nikki.
      Peyton: Jake. Thank you.
      Jake: You know I could've held you in my arms forever? It still wouldn't have been long enough.

    • Haley: Oh yeah, sorry about today with the fans, earlier. We were talking and, I just, I'm sorry.
      Lucas: It's OK. It's OK; actually, it was kinda cool to… see how far you've come. You know, I'm proud of you.
      Haley: But?
      Lucas: It's killing him, Haley. I guess I just don't understand why it has to be one or the other: music or Nathan. I noticed you weren't… wearing your wedding ring.
      Haley: It's not because of the record label. And it's not because I don't love him. I just… I feel like I don't deserve to. Things were so much simpler when it was just the two of us.
      Lucas: But it's not.

    • Andy: (Smirks and walks to the yet again destroyed window) You know, leave all this. I plan to redecorate when I buy this place, anyway.

    • Chris: How's Nathan doing, anyway?
      Lucas: Don't go there!
      Chris: Oh, come on, man, you don't think I think about the guy? I'm a song writer; I carry all that crap around.
      Lucas: Well, then you should know how he's doing! He's terrible!
      Chris: Well, he should be. Haley's a great girl. It would suck to lose her.
      Lucas: And you don't feel the slightest bit guilty about that?!
      Chris: No, and I'll tell you why: this is a one in a million chance we're taking here. You gotta be selfish as hell; you're either all in… or you're out. You don't think I've tried to talk to her about it? In the middle of the night on some random bus ride? Hell, man, I've talked to her a lot more than you have these past few months. Listen, Luke, I know she's your friend, so… you can hate me for helping her chase her dream, but… I'm just trying to help her, now. You know? That same way you are. The rest, it's up to her.

    • Chris: Wow, yo-you angry or you just hitting on me?
      Lucas: You ever tried singing with you jaw wired shut?
      Chris: I guess you're angry.
      Lucas: Do you think this is a joke? Because it's not. You're messing with people's lives; people I care about.
      Chris: Messing how? You mean having sex with Haley? Cause I never did that. OK? Is that what you needed to hear?

    • Haley: I'm guessing you're here because of Nathan.
      Lucas: Kind of.
      Haley: You know that he told me not to come home, right? You know that?
      Lucas: … Look, mostly, I'm here because of us, Haley. You know, I was… sitting in class… and… I looked over and saw your empty seat… and it struck me; that not too long ago, it was just you and me.
      Haley: Yeah.
      Lucas: Suddenly, it felt wrong; that you weren't there.
      Haley: You think I was wrong for leaving.
      Lucas: Here's what I think: you stood by me when I left the Rivercourt because a voice in my head told me that it's what I had to do. So I'm here for you, Hales. And I always will be. Even… when I don't understand it.
      Haley: Thanks, Luke. Thank you. Because… sometimes I don't understand it either.

    • Nikki: (At the jail) Hi Jake, how's your sex life in there?
      Jake: What do you want, Nikki?
      Nikki: I just came to say goodbye.
      Jake: You're leaving before the hearing?
      Nikki: Yeah. This game's gotten old.
      Jake: Well, I guess it's just as well. Once the judge hears my side of things it's not gonna matter if you're there or not. You know it.
      Nikki: Do you know how it feels, Jake? Knowing that you'll never see your daughter again? Knowing that she'll never be a part of your life? You'll never see her walk… hear her laugh, or watch her grow.
      Jake: Goodbye, Nikki.
      Nikki: Goodbye, Jake. Oh, one more thing.
      Jake: Yeah.
      Nikki: The next time you wanna hide my daughter,… you've gotta do better that Florida. (She picks Jenny up and shows her to Jake.) Do you know how it feels, Jake? Never to see your daughter again? Because you will.
      Jake: Nikki.
      Nikki: Say goodbye to daddy, bunny. Forever.
      Jake: Nikki. (Nikki gets up and starts leaving). Guard! Nikki! Somebody stop her! She's got my baby! Nikki, come on! Nikki! Nikki!

    • Brooke: (to Lucas and Haley) Um,… I'm in New York City and my parents have resumed allowances; I would be crazy not to shop right now so I'm gonna leave you two alone. OK? Good luck, see ya, bye.

    • Haley: Well, so what're you guys doing here?
      Lucas: We bought your English assignment.
      Haley: My- Oh my gosh, finals! Oh, god, that just feels like a totally different life.

    • Haley: Lucas! Oh my gosh. Hi.
      Chris: Oh, well, it's about time the tribal leaders came to collect their squaw.
      Haley: Oh, shut up, Chris.
      Lucas: Yeah, shut up, Chris.
      Chris: Alright, I'm going. (Stands and walks to Brooke.) Oh,… I see you couldn't stay away from me.
      Haley: Out. I'm sorry. Oh, it's good to see you too, Brooke.
      Brooke: Yeah, you too, fugitive girl.

    • Brooke: So it's kinda weird, us living under the same roof.
      Lucas: It's not that weird.
      Brooke: Yes it is. I mean, who would have thought this could have happened, back when we were together. You been talking to Peyton much?
      Lucas: Little bit. I wish I was in her life more, you know?
      Brooke: I guess I know what loss you'll be writing about for your essay.
      Lucas: I lost myself this year, Brooke. And when I did, I lost the people I truly care about. Oh, by the way, um,… when we get to New York,… I hope you'll understand if we spend most of our time with Haley. It's just… important that I focus on her today. You know?
      Brooke: Of course. Everything else can wait.

    • Whitey: (In his office.) Come in, Nathan.
      Nathan: How'd you know it was me?
      Whitey: I could smell the confusion. Pause. That was a joke, by the way. Nobody ever laughs at my jokes.
      Nathan: That's cos they're not funny, Coach.
      Whitey: A little bird told me you were moving back home.
      Nathan: That little bird's name Lucas?
      Whitey: He cares about you, and so do I. You've come quite a distance this year. I think moving out of that house has been good for you.
      Nathan: Coach, look at me. I'm a mess.
      Whitey: Nah, you're just a little bit broken. But it's nothing that a summer at High Flyers couldn't fix.
      Nathan: Could have fixed.
      Whitey: Still can. Dan Scott's not the only one with pull in this town. The only thing that held you back as a player last season was heart. Now, I've watched that change over the past year, and I've been so proud of you. That camp has world-class trainers. They can mend the physical part. I have a hunch, once that happens, the game will heal your heart.
      Nathan: I dreamt about it, in the hospital, about going to that camp. But I don't know. My mom's coming home soon. I gotta think about it.
      Whitey: Promise me you'll do that.

    • Peyton: Jake…
      Jake: You've been calling my attorneys a lot.
      Peyton: I thought I could help.
      Jake: Well, you just pissed them off… at first. Then, you clearly weren't going away, so they went over Nikki's testimony line by line. And they found something. She lied, Peyton. She said that she'd been away at college but she wasn't. She hadn't been there in months.
      Peyton: Well does, does that even matter, you know? Is that enough?
      Jake: Well, yeah, any lie is a lie under oath. Once my attorneys get ahold of her transcripts, the judge is gonna lift the court order; I'll have sole custody of Jenny for a new hearing, and a chance to testify against all her other lies.
      Peyton: That's so great, Jake. When do you get out?
      Jake: A day or so, probably. And I'm gonna come find you as soon as I do. You did this, Peyton. You've given me hope. And I love you so much for it. (Peyton starts crying.) Hey, hey, come on. Don't cry.
      Peyton: Haven't you ever cried when you're happy?

    • Karen storms into Dan's office
      Karen: Deported!! What is wrong with you? Why can't you simply stay out of my life?
      Dan: Why can't you?
      Karen: Please, I've been ignoring you for the last 17 years.
      Dan: Have you? Becuase you've been coming around quite a bit, Karen. I mean, with all your anger and outrage. Some would call it... passion.
      Karen: Don't flatter yourself. Just back off Andy and Lucas and leave my world alone.
      Dan grabs Karen as she walks away, and kisses her, she pulls away.
      Dan: Isn't that what this is really about?
      Karen: God!
      Dan laughs evilly. Karen wipes her mouth and stomps out of the office. Dan adjusts his tie. Karen stops and considers what he just did. She rushes forward, grabs a steel chair and spins around, throwing it forcefully through his glass office window. Dan cowers away, trying to fend off the glass. He looks up at her.
      Karen: Next time,… that'll be your face.

    • Lucas: You wanna go on a road trip this weekend?
      Brooke: OK, where?
      Lucas: New York, to see Haley.
      Brooke: Alright, odd I know, coming from me, but we do have finals. The essay.
      Lucas: I'll bring my laptop. Whoever sits shotgun can do the typing; whaddaya say, huh?
      Brooke: And why Haley? Why now?
      Lucas: Because we started the year together… and I can't end it without seeing her.

    • Erica: Hey sexy. What's wrong?
      Mouth: I'm dead. I tanked my calculus final.
      Erica: Are you sure? Maybe you did OK.
      Mouth: Erica, we hung out all week and I was totally unprepared. And you can't exactly bluff your way through math, you know? God, my parents are gonna kill me.

    • Lucas: Look, I know you don't wanna hear this, but if you blow off this English final, you're not gonna even be eligible to shoot the… 'weak-ass jump shots'. It's about loss. I can help you if you want.
      Nathan: You don't think I can write about loss?

    • Brooke: (to Lucas): I guess Haley's not coming back after all, huh?

    • Peyton: Jake.
      Jake: You've been calling my attorneys a lot.
      Peyton: I thought I could help.
      Jake: Well, you just pissed them off.

    • Brooke: Jimmy Eat World, that's a great idea!
      Peyton: Brooke, it'll probably never happen.
      Brooke: Peyton Elizabeth Sawyer, you got The Wreckers and Pelthead to come and play, you can totally land Jimmy Eat World. And when you do, I promise I won't break up with you to run off and join their tour.
      (Peyton's face drops and she looks into her locker sadly.)
      Brooke: That's it, isn't it? That's why your heart's not totally in to finding a great band for the end of the school year. Haley and Nathan.
      Peyton: Yeah, that and... (Has a flashback to her and Jake in the jail)

    • Brooke: (Talking to herself, nervously as she practices what to say.) Tree Hill student council is pleased to welcome- (Inhales) No. As president of the student council, I promised you guys a good time… (Pauses as she frowns, annoyed) I'm Brooke Davis and I'm an idiot, but, please welcome-

    • Peyton: Yes, losing your heart's desire is tragic... but gaining your heart's desire... it's all you can hope for. This year, I wished for love. To immerse myself in someone else and to wake a heart long afraid to feel. My wish was granted... and if having that is tragic, then give me tragedy. Because I wouldn't give it back for the world.

    • Haley: This year, I got everything I wanted and everything I wished for but, in a way, I lost even more.

    • Nathan: As far as I'm concerned, Shaw was a punk, 'cause you know what? Tragedies happen. What are you gonna do? Give up? Quit? No. I realize now that when your heart breaks, you gotta fight like hell to make sure you're still alive. Because you are... and that pain you feel, it's life. The confusion and fear, that's there to remind you that somewhere out there is something better... and that something is worth fighting for.

    • Brooke: George Bernard Shaw once wrote, "There are two tragedies in life. One is to lose your heart's desire. The other is to gain it." Clearly, Shaw had his heart broken once or twice.

    • Mouth: Because sometimes we have to step outside the person you've been, and remember the person you are meant to be. The person you wanted to be. The person you are.

    • Brooke: And once you lose yourself you have two choices: find the person you used to be or lose that person completely.

    • Peyton: The journey lasted eight months. Sometimes I travelled alone. Sometimes there were others who took the wheel... and took my heart. But when the destination was reached, it wasn't me who arrived... it wasn't me at all.

    • Nathan: And losing your way on the journey is unfortunate, but losing your reason for the journey is a fate more cruel.

    • Brooke: I can't breathe!
      Haley: What?
      Brooke: There's no room with Chris's ego!

    • Chris: (playing guitar as Brooke walks by his hotel room) Lucas and Haley aren't back yet, but you can come on into the devil's lair, put down your things, have sex with Chris Keller... whatever.

    • Lucas: And Hansel said to Gretel, "Let us drop these breadcrumbs so that together we find our way home, because losing our way would be the most cruel of things." This year, I lost my way.

    • Lucas: Shaw was right. As we strain to grasp the things we desire, the things that we think will make our lives better---money, popularity, fame---we ignore what truly matter--the simple things-- like friendship, family, love--the things we probably already had.

  • NOTES (5)

  • ALLUSIONS (1)

    • Episode Title: The Tide That Left and Never Came Back

      The Tide That Left and Never Came Back is a song by The Veils in their album The Runaway Found.

More
Less