TV.com

One Tree Hill

You And Me And The Bottle Makes Three Tonight

Season 6, Episode 17, Aired Mar 16, 2009

Next
Episode Previous
Episode

Episode Summary

EDIT

8.6

EPISODE RATING: Great

182 votes

Your Rating: 10

"Perfect"
Your Rating: 9.5

"Superb"
Your Rating: 9

"Superb"
Your Rating: 8.5

"Great"
Your Rating: 8

"Great"
Your Rating: 7.5

"Good"
Your Rating: 7

"Good"
Your Rating: 6.5

"Fair"
Your Rating: 6

"Fair"
Your Rating: 5.5

"Mediocre"
Your Rating: 5

"Mediocre"
Your Rating: 4.5

"Poor"
Your Rating: 4

"Poor"
Your Rating: 3.5

"Bad"
Your Rating: 3

"Bad"
Your Rating: 2.5

"Terrible"
Your Rating: 2

"Terrible"
Your Rating: 1.5

"Abysmal"
Your Rating: 1

"Abysmal"

Rate Now!

Tree Hill's romances face more trials: Peyton and Lucas receive shocking news about the pregnancy, Brooke's relationship with Julian comes to a crossroads, and Mouth and Millie try to pick up the pieces and move on. Meanwhile, Jamie spends the night with his grandparents while Nathan and Haley celebrate their anniversary.moreless

WRITE A REVIEW

Cast & Crew

See All EDIT

Chad Michael Murray

Lucas Scott
James Lafferty

Nathan Scott
Hilarie Burton

Peyton Sawyer
Sophia Bush

Brooke Davis
Bethany Joy Galeotti

Haley James-Scott
Paul Johansson

Dan Scott

Watch Online

Fan Episode Reviews (14)

See All

Couples!!

10

"Perfect"

By GilmoreFan86, Mar 29, 2012

This was a good episode. It was done differently which was great. I loved that it started with showing us all the couples that were going to be featured and then each couple had their own segment of the show. It was very nicely done.

Lucas/Peyton: Apparently more then the month between episodes has passed because Peyton is really showing now and she wasn't showing in the previous episode. This thing with the baby is really scary. When they first came home I was scared she had lost it, but was so glad to hear she hadn't. I love the room. And I love that even though it will be hard and very risky they decided to keep the baby.

Nathan/Haley: Love them!!! That's really all that needs to be said. I can't believe they've been married for seven years. I loved them this whole episode. It was just so sweet and perfect and drama free.

Brooke/Julian: I can't believe he said he loved her so quickly, but she is Brooke Davis. It's hard not to love her. They are great together. They'll work it out. I like them!! It's got to be hard on Julian though that Brooke really hasn't been in love since Lucas. The poor guy already had to deal with that with Peyton.

Mouth/Millie: Eh...don't really care. I'm glad Mouth finally admitted he screwed up with the whole flirting and everything with Gigi.

Dan/Deb: A little weird seeing them together again, but I liked it. It was good to see them finally having it out over Keith's death. We already knew Deb blamed herself, but to hear Dan say it was her fault was just mean.

Overall, great episode!!moreless
DO YOU AGREE?
0 0

Flag
Share Hide
The episode was basically broken into acts with each couple doing something.

10

"Perfect"

By Nyfiness, Jun 12, 2011

I loved the episode and to me some parts were boring. My favorite part was Lucas and Peyton I thought they did the best with the acting.Then Julian and Brooke was so sad and Dan and deb were exciting. Mouth and his relationships were pointless and took up time. Nathan and Haley needs and I mean definitely needs to be shaken up. Yeah this episode had a lot of drama but that is not a bad thing. As for Brooke they should did something with that I Love you stuff. Now it just seems unresolved and left open. I feel for Julian.moreless
DO YOU AGREE?
3 4

Flag
Share Hide
Worst episode so far.

4.0

"Poor"

By saracen7, Sep 26, 2010

I really hated the episode, it really was the worst OTH episode so far. What's with the writers still focusing on a lousy couple: Milicent and Mouth? It really is the worst couple in the history of tv shows. They are hanging on to dead pieces of their love story and still think there's a way to get back together, all of that told on a slow pace. I really like the season so far but this episode was really bad, I hope there won't be anymore episodes like this one. I found it was empty, something was missing and the focus on the three couples was not necessary, it was missing a sub-plot.moreless
DO YOU AGREE?
2 4

Flag
Share Hide
Haley and Nathan spend time together in Charlston, Julian wants to commit to Brooke but Brooke is scared and doesn't want to and she uses Sam as an excuse, Mouth and Millie finally have it out as does Deb and Dan while watching Jamie. Payton has troule.moreless

10

"Perfect"

By DjMusicKc7443, Sep 03, 2010

Payton starts having troule with her pregnancy, Mouth and Millie finally have it out as to why they broke up, Deb and Dan finally duke it out and confront eachother about the past. It is revealed that Haley got suspended for distrubiting Sam's report to the school paper which sucks in my opinion. Lisa Goldstine returns and it seems to me that she doesn't regret what she did I don't know it also seems to me that this couple got way too much air time in my opinion I would've liked to see more of Payton and Lucas in this episode considering what they showed in the coming attractions for this episode I don't think this episode should've focused on Mouth and Millie this ways more of a Lucas and Payton episode. now to Deb and Dan WOW !! it's about time this was the arguement that I've been waiting for!!!! Barbara Alyn Woods did a fantastic job I loved seeing them together on screan again lol Paul Johanson's reaction when he walked in the house was priceless! "wow Deb you look old" lol sorry that was great. loved it... now to Payton and Lucas I noticed that they were only in for two seens! what the hell! that was mark's mistake this week... I hope they have more airtime next week and hopefully we'll see less of Millie and Mouth there just getting annoying now Skillz wasn't in this episode and neither was Sam and that just sucked because they add some humor into the show in my opinion. now when Grandpa Dan's beeper when of as Deb says "I Can't wait for you to die" or something to that effect that was just a little freaky... anyways great job Mark!moreless
DO YOU AGREE?
4 0

Flag
Share Hide
This was a great episode and it dealt with several of the character couples beginnings, endings, and what is in store for some of them.

10

"Perfect"

By becky677, Sep 03, 2010

First of all Lucas and Peyton are two of my favorite characters and I loved the way Peyton stood up for her baby.Lucas does not want to lose Peyton but she is bound and determined to bring a part of them in this world because they have been through so much together and this love is timeless. I am happy to see that they both agreed in the end. Nathan and Haley share a romantic anniversary in Charleston. This is another great couple who has endured a great deal of tragedy yet have come out on top and I see these two together for a long time, hopefully forever. Julian and Brooke would make such a great power couple with the romance blended in it would be a love that could last. I just have a feeling that Brooke still loves Lucas or she is so scared of being hurt. Brooke is such a strong person for all she has dealt with in her life but she is a good person and deserves happiness. I hope that she will give Julian a chance before it is too late. Marvin and Millicent need to get over the past and move on but I do not think Millie can forgive herself although she should give it a chance if she truly loves Marvin. Jamie is such a cutie. He is an adorable little boy with so much intelligence for his age. If only life could be so simple. Deb and Dan hash out some pent up anger but I really feel like Dan deserves a second chance to live his life and be able to spend time with Jamie and maybe one day the truth can be known to Nathan and Lucas. He has done his time for what he did and he will have to live the rest of his life with the pain of shooting Keith but I believe if he is allowed to live and see Jamie he can be a good influence in his grandson's life as well as another grandchild on the way.moreless
DO YOU AGREE?
3 0

Flag
Share Hide

WRITE A REVIEW

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

See All

FILTER BY TYPE

TRIVIA (2)
ADD TRIVIA
- Brooke says that the last boy she loved was Lucas. But in Episode 4.20 she tells Chase she loves him.
  EDIT SHARE
- Although credited, Antwon Tanner (Antwon "Skills" Taylor) does not appear in this episode.
  EDIT SHARE
QUOTES (4)
ADD QUOTES
- Nathan: Happy anniversary, Haley James Scott.
  Haley: George Bailey, I'll love you 'til the day I die.
  EDIT SHARE
- Lucas: I can't accept that our story doesn't have a good ending. Peyton: Our story already has the greatest ending, no matter what... because we're together.
  EDIT SHARE
- Brooke (to Julian): It sucks being the footnote in someone else's love story.
  EDIT SHARE
- Peyton: I'm going to have this baby. Lucas: No, we're going to have this baby.
  EDIT SHARE
NOTES (3)
ADD NOTES
- Original International Air Dates: Norway: Saturday, October 31, 2009 on TVNorge
  EDIT SHARE
- Featured Music: "One Of Those Days" by Joshua Radin "A Piece For You" by Meaghan Smith "Are You Lightning" by Nada Surf "Low" by Josh Auer "Save A Place" by 1969 Feat. Butch Walker "Sea Song" by Lisa Hannigan "After Afterall" by William Fitzsimmons "Lost Forever" by Guggenheim Grotto
  EDIT SHARE
- Matthew Caws, a musician from the band Nada Surf, composed some of the music that is included in this episode.
  EDIT SHARE
ALLUSIONS (2)
ADD ALLUSIONS
- Deb: Since it's just you and me tonight, I am going to let you stay up past bedtime and watch Thomas & Friends. Jamie: I'd rather watch Gossip Girl, it's so bad for me. Gossip Girl is another show on the CW network that debuted in 2007. Starting with the last few episodes of the show's first season, Gossip Girl has aired in the time slot immediately preceding One Tree Hill on Monday nights.
  EDIT SHARE
- Episode Title: You and Me and The Bottle Makes Three Tonight A song by Big Bad Voodoo Daddy from the album The Millennium Collection: The Best of Big Bad Voodoo Daddy.
  EDIT SHARE