A Penny Dreadful Community
Showtime (ended 2016)
And so it begins. The eight-episode series Penny Dreadful premieres its first episode "Night Work" this Sunday (after an online preview release on 4/28). So what does it bring us, and how is it?

The episode starts with a young girl's mother being killed while on the toilet by... something. Then her daughter is killed. Then we're off to the Wild West transposed to Britain as actor/gunfighter Ethan Chandler put on a shooting and tall-telling display for a crowd. Vanessa hires Ethan to accompany her and big-game hunter Sir Malcolm Murray to an opium den to find Malcolm's daughter Mina (Harker or Murray - Dracula alert!). They go up against "familiars" as named in the end credits, and then a Nosferatu-style bald barely-human vampire (although the term "vampire" isn't used). They kill it (Ethan is not a lot of help), haul its corpse off to the mortuary, and end up meeting with an assistant Victor. They discover that the vampire has Egyptian hieroglyphs tattooed on its skin.



The name is Schreck. Max Schreck.

After that... not much happens. Vanessa, a psychic fortuneteller of sorts, has an enigmatic conversation with Ethan. Malcolm hires Victor to help them, since Victor likes cutting open corpses. Victor talks a lot about galvanic response and erasing the tissue between life and death, and needs money. Malcolm and Vanessa confront a quirky Egyptologist, Ferdinand Lyle, who says that the hieroglyphs are from the Egyptian Book of the Dead. He seems to know more than he's telling and insists they come to his party. Jack the Ripper seems to be alive and well, and disemboweling a mother and her young daughter.

In an odd scene, Ethan considers taking more work from Vanessa and Malcolm, goes back to Malcolm's house, starts to go in when he sees Vanessa at the window, but then turns and goes when he see Malcolm arrive. Hrrmm? Afterward, Malcolm's daughter Mina pays her father a visit and... does nothing? Reveals she's a vampire and leaves, I guess, followed by hints that Vanessa was someone responsible for Mina's vampirization.



Daddy?

It ends with Victor visiting his secret attic laboratory and meeting up with the nude corpse he's reanimating. It's alive! And very naked. And *ahem* has very low blood pressure, unsurprisingly, since it's dead and all. And Victor introduce himself as... Victor Frankenstein. Dum dum dum!!!

-----

So, that's what it is. How does it do? It's very murky, as to be expected, but that makes things a bit hard to make out. Everyone is suitably competent in their roles. The three principals--Josh Hartnett, Eva Green, Timothy Dalton--are all good. Simon Russell Beale is amusingly quirky ("Isn't that a delicious word, "papyri"? Sounds like something eaten by little Persian boys, doesn't it?)," and would probably make a good Time Lord in a certain British S.F. series.



When Peter Capaldi leaves Doctor Who, I'm ready!

Other than a couple of action sequences (in the murky cellar) that are a bit hard to follow, it's all set-up and ominous hints of things going on in those types of conversations writers use when characters explain things to each other that they already know, but not quite enough to spoil anything for the viewing audience. And everyone has dark secrets. Vanessa has the dark secrets of her childhood, her attractiveness to spiders (more of them mob-rush her near the end), and how she got Mina turned into a vampire. Ethan has dark secrets: it's why Vanessa offers to hire him full-time. Mr. Lyle has dark secrets. Victor is keeping a dark secret in his spacious attic laboratory. Malcolm's servant Sembene no doubt has a dark secret or two. One suspects even Malcolm's agenda is a bit more than he says.



I'll let you pretend you know my dark secret, if you let me pretend I know your dark secret. Deal?
Deal!

The writing is very witty (see Quotes), and it looks like series creator John Logan will be writing all eight episodes. It's a bit of a slog after the fight sequences, but first-episode exposition must be paid, and things move along well enough given that. It's not American network programming, so there's one mostly-clothed sex scene and full-frontal nudity from a very dedicated Alex Pryce. Rory Kinnear (the Creature), Reeve Carney (Dorian Gray) and Billie Piper (Brona Croft) are nowhere to be seen, clothed or otherwise.

There's some cute directorial touches. For some reason I found the scene where everyone in the audience is turning their heads tennis-style to watch Ethan shoot targets, while Vanessa never turns her head and focuses on Ethan, kind of amusing.

So if you like horror. Or you like horror in a period piece. Or you like a more adult tone to your TV viewing and a show in the S.F./fantasy genre. Then hey, this one's for you.

-----

The question in many people's minds seems to be, "This doesn't suck as bad as the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen movie, does it?" Alan Moore, author of the original graphic novels, probably doesn't think so (if you can find him behind his beard to ask).
It's a hard question to answer, because a) I kinda like the movie, b) this show doesn't set out to be what the movie is: a summer action-adventure blockbuster, and c) it doesn't take much to beat out LoEG, or LXG, or whatever acronym they came up with for it.



More terrifying than anything in Penny Dreadful so far...

That said, it does have a fair number of similarities. Number one is that instead of a James Bond actor playing a big-game hunter out for revenge, it has... umm, a James Bond actor playing a big-game hunter out for revenge. Still, PD is unlikely to drive Dalton out of the entertainment business the way that LoEG allegedly caused Connery to stop making movies.



Sean Connery learns that Timothy Dalton got to play a legendary African explorer in a good production, and reacts with his usual restraint and aplomb.

Let's see, instead of a loud-mouthed American sharpshooter, we have a... loud-mouthed American sharpshooter. Instead of a dark-haired vampiress with superhuman abilities, we have a dark-haired woman with psychic abilities (foretelling the future, quelling a vampire with a good stare). One suspects Brona Croft may be a werewolf, making up the other half of the character matching up with Mina's violent nature and transformative powers from the movie. (Weren't we promised werewolves?)

The Creature appears to be the superstrong occasionally uncontrollable Hyde, and Victor manages to bring in the science of Nemo, the medical skills of Jekyll, and the general "Hey, I'm a dick" attitude of Skinner. And although we don't see Dorian Gray, presumably he'll be kind of like Dorian Gray in the movie. Hopefully not the Highlander-ish immortal swordsman, but odds are he'll have some kind of supernatural ability relating to Wilde's novel, his portrait, and so on. Otherwise... why use him?

So yes, this all seems a bit too deliberate on John Logan's part to be accidental. Kind of a "Yeah, you don't like the movie? See what I can do with it!" on his part. And it's all much better written then what James Robinson pulled off for the movie. And yes, it's that James Robinson of JSA and Starman comics. How he managed to mess that up, who knows?

-----

Anyhoo, if you hated LoEG, you won't run screaming away from your TV. Given they only have eight episodes to play along with, I would have maybe liked to see them move it along a little faster. It's odd to omit two of your major stars. But we'll see how it plays out.

Penny Dreadful - Episode 1: airing "for real" Sunday, May 11, on Showtime at 10/9 central.
Comments (31)
Submit
Sort: Latest | Popular
My last name is schreck, wonder if max is my great great uncle...I do enjoy gravy.
1
Reply
Flag
So Ethan is a totally a werewolf right?
Reply
Flag
I think he's an incarnation of Jekyll & Hyde. There's a nod to it at the beginning of episode two. not sure if i should mention anything but i presume you watched them online already. it's not a big spoiler anyway but ethan wakes up not remembering the night before but with marks on the palm of his hand. i think that's his "other" side letting him know how many he killed that night.
Reply
Flag
Hmm, I'd prefer werewolf I think, maybe with shades of Jekyl/Hyde as Marburg66 suggested below. But it is possible. I also agree that the marks on his palm were self inflicted while asleep. That the killer switched from a mom and child to a prostitute though does suggest some consciousness though.
Reply
Flag
or, it could simply be fingernails digging into his palms from stress of dreamlike nightmare like memories in lieu of specifically keeping physical score of a bodycount
Reply
Flag
just sayin' but when I fist noticed those theories floating around the net a few weeks ago, I scoffed up blood & said meh!...but after a brief, passing moment that happened in this Sunday's episode, I admit I don't discount the idea anymore.
...I specifically remember chuckeling & thinking to myself: "Oooh! An American Werewolf in London after all!"
::shrug::
Sucks having to wait to talk about it freely
grrrr
Reply
Flag
We can't talk about it? How about we just talk about the signs that I saw in episode 1.

American Werewolf in London - exactly LOL, plus he was on his way to Paris. (An American Werewolf in Paris)

1. Vanessa tells him that his clothes (specifically shoes) have been fixed time and again - from him tearing out of them.

2. When everyone is standing around the crime scene he looks incredibly guilty, like he is responsible.

3. When he sees all the dead and dismembered bodies killed by the vamps he doesn't flinch. I mean he's amazed, but not horrified.

4. At Sir Malcolm's he draws the Lovers tarot card. Which is the symbol of Gemini the twins. The duality to his nature. Man and Beast.

This show is a slow burn for sure, but I'm really starting to love it. I almost forgot how amazing it is for characters to actually be mysterious and not just be described as such.
Reply
Flag
Well, strictly going by clues left in ep 1, I'd say the biggest one is in the intro. It shows a flash of fur, then a big 'ol slobbery wolf maw. Then the next flash is Ethan. I think the wolf facing to the right while Ethan faces left is more suggestive of duality than the tarot card...speaking of, I think the tarot card is much more a clue towards Ethan & Brona meeting.

About his clothes & shoes: Naw. He's just poor. I don't imagine he would have a habit of tearing out of 'em...that's just too hollywood. If he's a wolfman, he knows when the change happens & would most likely have a habit of preperation for it

Oh, also, speaking of wolfman: (just roll with me here) If there does end up being a wolfy aspect to Ethan in the show, I think it could be a subtle nod to "Werewolf Of London" from 1935 which drew its major inspiration from Stephenson's Jekyll & Hyde. Thing is, I'm not aware of any go-to popular werewolf stories in the old-school dreadfuls...so, I'm just goin' with a theory that since Jekyll & Hyde aren't a part of the show & "The Wolfman" is an American thing in the Dracula/Frankenstein/Wolfman common knowlege trinity, I think it's possible the writer may simply be attempting to mix those two aspects together in one character...I know it's a big stretch, but it's still an interesting notion for me to entertain until the story unflods more

...& yeah, that moment when the bodies were being carted off by the cops, I couldn't agree with you more...that woman had a definate look of fear in her eye when she saw Chandler. Wolfman or not, Ethan definately has something to do with the murders somehow :)
More +
Reply
Flag
Cool, I didn't notice that in the intro. I'm not convinced that Ethan has control over his change, but I suppose it's possible. I do agree with the Jekyl and Hyde comparison though, of course after episode 2, that similarity may also be applied to Vanessa.

I don't think the tarot card was simply about Brona, that seems too straightforward. I think it was a clue to his connection to Vanessa and their similar inner demons. One she hoped to use to bring him into Malcolms employ. When he turned it it was on it's side, but if we look at it as being reversed (upside down) then the meaning applies. Reversed the card symbolizes inner conflict, inability to achieve inner harmony or union, and avoiding responsibility for the consequences of your actions. It symbolizes running away from your problems and blaming your situation on fate. I think that applies to Ethan.

Very disappointed to have to wait a week for episode 3.
Flag
This show is really promising...
It's weird, I know and tolerated(partly even liked!) the movie LoEG and know and love the comic books LoEG but I was totally unaware of the similarities until now. But they are there, without question.
I already posted it on Marburg's post but since you mentioned the scene, here you go, Gislef:

2
Reply
Flag
Isn't it amazing how clean Victorian London apparently was? I expected to see the roads covered in horse shit but no...
1
Reply
Flag
Well, that, and all the people on the streets not suffering of consumption and smallpox. And all the little Ethans and their mothers chasing after him. :)
Reply
Flag
And everyone had American teeth!
Reply
Flag
Thread needs more posts!
Just wanted to say Mr. Lyle was really fun to watch in his scene. I wanna see more of that guy
2
Reply
Flag
I noted as much. Like i said, it's a very quirky performance, very theatrical. Which makes sense, as he seems to be primarily a theatrical performer. He was in Spooks, and has worked with executive producer Sam Mendes in the past, too.
Reply
Flag
You might want to rewatch that episode, seems like you missed a few things.
Reply
Flag
Such as...?

It wasn't intended to detail every scene.
Reply
Flag
Sorry, maybe I should have written you misunderstood a few things. Like the woman and child where both killed and it wasn't years before but probably the same night they where in the opium den since we saw Ethan watching the bodies get carried out later in the episode.
2
Reply
Flag
I'm not sure if that was entirely made clear. I'll check it later.
Reply
Flag
Actually, Atreukjm is right. It was made clear in two spots. The first, in the scene where the photographer was snapping shots of the crime scene. They showed the hallway the corpses were in & it was identical to the hallway in the beginning of the show. Then, the second as Atreukjm mentioned, was as the corpses were being carried away by the police. One of the two women talking in the scene was specifically mentioning not only the mother & the daughter, but also that the mother was pregnant and was starting to choose names
2
Flag
FYI, although it's been up for a week or two, the recap is up.
Reply
Flag
I enjoyed the pilot, it wasn't spectacular, but I'm intrigued enough by some of the characters (Vanessa Ives, Victor Frankenstein, and Ferdinand Lyle were particularly compelling) to continue watching in spite of the fact many of the characters/ stories have been done to death.
2
Reply
Flag
Follow this Show
Members
4,808