When a youth shoots Father Barrett during confession so they can rob the church, Judge Bone has problems trying to be objective with the youth responsible. Meanwhile when the mayor announces her decision to continue planning the spring pageant it causes problems with some of the townsfolk.
Jimmy's father visits and causes problems in the Brock household when he announces that he wants Jimmy to take over his law practice. But the generous offer angers Jimmy and a troubled relationship resurfaces.
Max gets into serious trouble when she shoots a man dressed in a bratwurst costume. Meanwhile Jill grows suspicious of Kimberly when she goes to Dr. Joey and tries to cover it up, jumping to the conclusion that she is pregnant.