Sam and Brooke are getting along, and they plan to make peace with all the girls. In the new feminine studies class, Mr. Bennet asks the girls to write down their deepest secrets and throw it out after, but Nicole takes all of them. The girls all got their period together, and so the boys decide to lock them in the bathroom so they solve their issues without destroying the school. Nicole decides to play the truth game. The six secrets are revealed: Mary Cherry used to be called quack for her deformed hands and feet; Lily had doubts about her sexuality and kissed Carmen; Brooke did it again with Josh; Sam made out with Josh too; Carmen is dating Josh; and last but not least, Nicole, who slept with Josh! Mary Cherry, in a desperate cry for attention, says she too slept with Josh, and not only that, but also with Joe and Lily! But that's a lie. So all the girls start fighting, but they realize they all should be mad at Josh, not at each other. Nicole locks Harrison and Josh in the bathroom after Brooke tells her never to speak to her again.