TV.com

Private Practice

Best Laid Plans

Season 3, Episode 12, Aired 1/21/10

Next
Episode Previous
Episode

EDIT

Episode Summary

Maya shocks Sam and Naomi, while Pete and Fife disagree on patient care.

8.5

EPISODE RATING: Great

97 votes

Your Rating: 10

"Perfect"
Your Rating: 9.5

"Superb"
Your Rating: 9

"Superb"
Your Rating: 8.5

"Great"
Your Rating: 8

"Great"
Your Rating: 7.5

"Good"
Your Rating: 7

"Good"
Your Rating: 6.5

"Fair"
Your Rating: 6

"Fair"
Your Rating: 5.5

"Mediocre"
Your Rating: 5

"Mediocre"
Your Rating: 4.5

"Poor"
Your Rating: 4

"Poor"
Your Rating: 3.5

"Bad"
Your Rating: 3

"Bad"
Your Rating: 2.5

"Terrible"
Your Rating: 2

"Terrible"
Your Rating: 1.5

"Abysmal"
Your Rating: 1

"Abysmal"

Rate It

Watch Online

Cast & Crew

See All EDIT

Audra McDonald

Dr. Naomi Bennett
Taye Diggs

Dr. Sam Bennett
Chris Lowell

William "Dell" Parker

Fan Episode Reviews (4)

See All

'Best Laid Plans'; reflected the uncertainty with outcomes, when the best of plans are made.

9.5

"Superb"

By lexacliche, Jun 03, 2011 Report Abuse

The most moving plot in this episode for me, was probably Maya's conflicting thoughts about abortion and keeping a child. Unfortunately she did not have the necessary guidance to make the experience easier for her, but according to Addison; Maya did an adult action and she is now forced to deal with an adult decision. No teenager should be forced to make a decision like that.

I believe that this was the most moving episode for Naomi and her turn to shine. In the line of highly qualified actresses, Audra McDonald took her slice of the cake this round. Shonda Rhimes made a tough decision implementing 'The Abortion' themed up with the 'Teenage Pregnancy' storyline, because it has been executed many times before on television. At the risk of coming of cliche and redundant, Rhimes pulled it off beautifully. I know her cast is what brought the script to life, but they all work well together as a team.

I applaud Addison for taking the risk of swaying Maya's final decision, because at that very point, she was taking a stance against Naomi. Maya's life is changed forever and it was nice to include the fact that the father of the child loved Maya and it wasn't just a 'fling' or so. Addison managed to show a level of maturity, that hasn't been most prevalent recently. Unlike Naomi who was not as mature with her decision and was more for action, without paying attention to the consequences. It only became clear that Maya based her decision to terminate the pregnancy, purely because of her mother's resentment.

It was actually deplorable watching the way in which Naomi dealt with the entire situation, like she was disappointed and somehow despised her daughter.
Naomi's parenting methods were so strict, that Maya only felt the need to go to her mother only when her life was going to change forever and not before the fact. Sam was the only one willing to be rational about everything. Naomi cannot run forever, so I am excited to have that situation unravel. Naomi obviously loves Maya, but feels betrayed as well, she also sees herself as a failed mother.

If I were to touch on a few other moments within this episode, it would have to be the dilemma Pete faced when dealing with Dr. Fife and the revolutionary guy with the bionic arm. Fife comes off as a huge ass. I have been trying to figure him out for weeks now, especially with what makes him tick and there is a question mark at that point. I was in awe of the moment he shared with Naomi, his attraction to her became obvious then, but I really cannot stand his attitude.

Speaking of bad attitudes, Cooper has officially lost it in my book. (To the Writers) I really need you to explain his paranoid character lapses, because Cooper has done a complete 180 on the sanity level. I don't believe he ever loved Charlotte, if he could treat her so horribly now. Charlotte herself was foolish to sell her apartment, she is not usually the type to completely trust in one thing and I believe that this is not the same Charlotte we met in Season one. That Charlotte would have reprimanded him a long time ago; according to Violet, his actions would only leave him alone.

Now that Violet has taken Charlotte in, I wonder if Cooper would have problems with that (who cares!). He had the gall to ask her to leave 'The Practice', he might work up the extra nerve and tell Charlotte to take a hike from his friends, especially since he and Violet have not been as close lately. I want to applaud Violet for finally accepting the absence from her son's life, even if it was to a complete stranger. I mean who was she kidding, it had to be done, she as a psychiatrist should know that her distance from her role of being a mother would cause more harm than good.

This was actually an exceptionally brilliant episode, I really enjoy how all the story-lines mesh together so well. It doesn't seem like there was much continuation from the Mark and Addison theme. Maybe all that would be taken care of in Grey's Anatomy, but still his daughter's condition with her baby was not officially dealt with. This may be out of the blur, but whatever happened to Noah? I don't want Addison to have anymore drama in her life, but that was another unresolved issue. Noah is presently residing in Cougar Town with Courtney Cox, so I wonder if that had any impact on his absence this season - probably.

Anyway, it was good to have Melissa McCarthy guest star as the pregnant Lynn McDonald. She gave Maya the incentive she needed to make her final decision about her pregnancy. I sympathize with Maya though, it's not going to be an easy road, especially with a mother like Naomi. Not to mention her school life filled with complications and loss of essential classes. Boy did Sam make the mistake of confronting the father in public, her entire school would find know because of the quick texter that over heard the newsworthy gossip. What a way to deliver a punchline.

Lexa Reviews

http://lexabuti.blogspot.com

______________________

Four and a Half Stars

Grade A
______________________moreless

DO YOU AGREE?
4 2
Brilliant episode.

9.0

"Superb"

By stewie1423, Jun 03, 2011 Report Abuse

I loved this episode, it could be my favourite of the season so far. The way Naomi and Sam reacted differently to Maya being pregnant was very engrossing and entertaining. This should be a great storyline if it continues to be as emotional as this. Naomi really stood out in the episode, the acting was pretty flawless.

I also liked Addison's part to play in the storyline. The talk she gave Maya before the planned abortion was great. I also really enjoyed Violets storyline with the man who just lost his wife. We finally saw some emotion from her about her son Lucas...I hope we see more of that. I still think Cooper is being a jerk so I'm glad that Violet isn't being horrible to Charlotte, them living together should be interesting.

Strong episode.moreless

DO YOU AGREE?
0 2
It's the perfect show

10

"Perfect"

By phoenixobia, Mar 17, 2011 Report Abuse

This show is really great , even better than the original, I hope people don't see it only as a spin-off from grey's anatomy. This show has many good qualities, acting is superb. just when u think u know what's gonna happen, there's a surprise. it's not something totally unpredictable but it avoids stereotypes as much as possible and yet believable. the story and the plot is deep , and it gets better.It is more realistic & less humorous than grey's anatomy.Actually it's taken all the great qualities of the original and turned it into something more sophisticated. this episode was one of the best of the show , the acting was perfect.U could actually feel what the characters felt. the story touched me. oh god i just can't get enough of it. I'm so upset that people don't care enough for this show. believe me u should give it a chance. this should be among the top 10 shows. it's the only show among all the others that I'm actually pleased by every second of it.moreless

DO YOU AGREE?
2 2
Maya must tell her parents something.

7.2

"Good"

By thefanof, Jan 23, 2010 Report Abuse

Another episode showcasing just how talented Audra McDonald is as she was at the forefront tonight dealing with a shocking confession by her very young daughter. The Naomi character has been up and down this series, and I hope she goes back to the practice at some point in the near future. But McDonald gave another stellar performance from start to finish and with Chloe Sevigny winning a Golden Globe, maybe there is a chance she might win an Emmy as the aforementioned Big Love star's victory shows that traditional actors and actresses are not the only ones getting award recognition these days.

But I digress as there is just an aura surrounding this show that prevents it from getting any nominations. Why, I'll never know because this is a great medical drama.moreless

DO YOU AGREE?
2 0

Write a Review

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

See All

Trivia
- Help by adding trivia to this episode. Add trivia
Notes
ADD NOTES
- International Airdate:
  Australia: March 30, 2010 on Channel 7
  Latin America: May 9, 2010 on Sony Entertainment Television (a.k.a. Canal Sony)
  Norway: May 25, 2010 on TV2
  The Netherlands: May 31, 2010 on Net5
  Germany: July 21, 2010 on ProSieben
  United Kingdom: September 2, 2010 on Living TV
  Finland: October 23, 2011 on MTV3
  Edit
- Featured Music: "Berkeley Girl" by Harper Simon "What You're Supposed To Do" by Matt Kanelos & The Smooth Maria "Silver Revolver" by Lady of the Sunshine "Magic View" by Diane Birch "The Old Days Are Gone" by Gary Jules and The Group Rules Edit
Quotes
- Help by adding quotes to this episode. Add quotes
Allusions
- Help by adding allusions to this episode. Add allusions