Project Runway Forums

Thursday 9:00 PM on LifetimeIn Season

Seasons 1 - 3 (by the numbers)

  • Avatar of tafj73

    tafj73

    [1]Jan 31, 2008
    • member since: 07/17/06
    • level: 30
    • rank: Anchorman
    • posts: 3,875
    OK, the geek is back again. LOL Using the Project Runway links in Wikipedia and the Designer Challenge charts on them, I figured who was technically the best to the worst in each of the three seasons, compared to the actual results.

    Season 1:
    1. Jay - 4.60 (Jay)
    2. Kara Saun - 4.40 (Kara Saun)
    3. Alexandra - 3.83 (Wendy)
    4. Robert - 3.75 (Austin)
    5. Kevin - 3.57 (Robert)
    6. Vanessa - 3.50 (Kevin)
    7. Austin - 3.44 (Alexandra)
    8. Wendy - 3.20 (Nora)
    9. Nora - 3.00 (Vanessa)
    10. Mario - 2.50 (Starr)
    11. Starr - 2.00 (Mario)
    12. Daniel - 1.00 (Daniel)

    Season 2:
    1. Chloe - 4.66 (Chloe)
    2. Daniel V. - 4.5 (Daniel V.)
    3. Zulema - 3.87 (Santino)
    4. Andrae - 3.77 (Kara)
    5. Kara - 3.63 (Nick)
    6. Emmett - 3.57 (Andrae)
    7. Nick - 3.40 (Zulema)
    7. Guadalupe - 3.40 (Emmett)
    9. Santino - 3.33 (Diana)
    10. Diana - 3.16 (Marla)
    11. Daniel F. - 3.00 (Guadalupe)
    11. Raymundo - 3.00 (Daniel F.)
    13. Marla - 2.83 (Raymundo)
    14. Kirsten - 2.50 (Kirsten)
    15. Heidi - 1.00 (Heidi)
    15. John - 1.00 (John)

    Season 3:
    1. Keith - 4.33 (Jeffrey)
    2. Mychael - 4.16 (Uli)
    3. Uli - 4.08 (Laura)
    4. Jeffrey - 4.00 (Mychael)
    5. Laura - 3.92 (Kayne)
    6. Alison - 3.83 (Vincent)
    7. Bonnie - 3.50 (Angela)
    8. Kayne - 3.40 (Robert)
    8. Bradley - 3.40 (Alison)
    10. Robert - 3.28 (Bradley)
    11. Vincent - 2.90 (Bonnie)
    12. Angela - 2.80 (Keith)
    13. Katherine - 2.66 (Katherine)
    14. Malan - 2.50 (Malan)
    15. Stacey - 1.00 (Stacey)

    It's interesting what happens when you let the numbers speak for themselves. LOL For example, even though Malan was voted off second in season 3, he is very successful as a designer. And Keith - even though he was disqualified, he did the best job on average. Seasons 1 and 2 are interesting results too.
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.
  • Avatar of tafj73

    tafj73

    [2]Jan 31, 2008
    • member since: 07/17/06
    • level: 30
    • rank: Anchorman
    • posts: 3,875
    So for all three seasons, from technically the best to the worst, here they are:

    1. Chloe - 4.66
    2. Jay - 4.60
    3. Daniel V. - 4.50
    4. Kara Saun - 4.40
    5. Keith - 4.33
    6. Mychael - 4.16
    7. Uli - 4.08
    8. Jeffrey - 4.00
    9. Laura - 3.92
    10. Zulema - 3.87
    11. Alexandra - 3.83
    11. Alison - 3.83
    13. Andrae - 3.77
    14. Robert P. - 3.75
    15. Kara - 3.63
    16. Kevin - 3.57
    16. Emmett - 3.57
    18. Vanessa - 3.50
    18. Bonnie - 3.50
    20. Austin - 3.44
    21. Nick - 3.40
    21. Guadalupe - 3.40
    21. Kayne - 3.40
    21. Bradley - 3.40
    25. Santino - 3.33
    26. Robert B. - 3.28
    27. Wendy - 3.20
    28. Diana - 3.16
    29. Nora - 3.00
    29. Raymundo - 3.00
    31. Vincent - 2.90
    32. Marla - 2.83
    33. Angela - 2.80
    34. Katherine - 2.66
    35. Mario - 2.50
    35. Kirsten - 2.50
    35. Malan - 2.50
    38. Starr - 2.00
    38. Daniel F. - 2.00
    40. Heidi - 1.00
    40. John - 1.00
    40. Stacey - 1.00

    Since Daniel F. was in two seasons, I took the average of his two scores: (3+1)/2 = 2.00. So, Chloe is technically the best one!
    You must be registered and logged in to post a message.