Gretchen, Valerie and Andy were in top three. Andy made a dress from black party ribbons and won this challenge.
Sarah, A.J. and Casanova were in the bottom three. Sarah was eliminated.
Peach: (as Tim looks at her design) I wanted it to be subtle... no?
Tim: Really? This is a 'Party Store' Challenge! With subtlety and nuance?!
Peach: I'm so afraid of...
Tim: You're so uptight, it's like you have a piece of coal up your rear end. I mean, honestly, make it into a diamond, and pull it out!
Casanova: (when criticized for using "safe" materials) We are not making a pinata, we are making a dress!