Project Runway

Season 4 Episode 5

What's the Skinny?

Aired Thursday 9:00 PM Dec 12, 2007 on Lifetime

Episode Fan Reviews (2)

Write A Review
out of 10
32 votes
  • This best episode ever. I sad that Jack quit and I happy that Steven eliminated.

    this is best episode. Jack quit because he receive medical treatment for a MRSA infection. Chris last designer eliminated replaced Jack. I agree with judges. Top three is Jillian, Christian and Kevin and bottom three is Steven, Chris and Elisa and bottom two is Steven and Elisa and eliminated is Steven yaaaaaaayyyyyyyy!!!!!!!!!!!!! best elimination in history of reality tv show! this is so cool. I gave this A. . .. . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . ... . . .
  • This episode had twists and turns that made it worth watching. Chris was brought back to replace a designer who had to leave due to health problems.

    I have not been watching the series this year because I was dissatisfied with last year's winner. However, this episode brought me back into the fold. I loved the concept of redesigning a favorite outfit for a woman who had lost a significant amount of weight. Excellent! This was such a better competition, and infinitely more practical, than taking trash for example and making an outfit. Some of the ladies, who acted as the designer's models, had lost more than 100 pounds. Christian's outfit won, and it was for a lady who was now a size 2/4. I loved his outfit, and it definitely looked like him. The other one that I liked a lot (actually better) was Kevin's two piece. The lady looked really sexy, and she was loving walking the runway in that new set. Steve was the designer who lost. He hardly used any part of the wedding dress that he was supposed to have remade into an everyday outfit. He should have lost.