Season 1 Episode 5


Aired Thursday 9:00 PM Nov 10, 2005 on FOX

Episode Fan Reviews (16)

Write A Review
out of 10
140 votes
  • I SO did NOT see that coming!

    I instantly thought that we wouldn't find out til that end of this episode who the killer was when I learned that it would happen in this episode. I was also leading to Jenna becoming the dead friend.

    So yes it was so easy for me to be fulled by this show into believing that Jenna was dead. Which then lead to the big shocker that Samantha was the one shot and killed! I thought for sure she had to live in order to complete the whole Joey-Rachel-Ross triangle question. (I'm a big Friends fan.) Even though Will since became a priest, my fingers were still crossed.

    Craig reconciles with Will who is about to go off to war in Kuwait. Which kind of makes up for the year they spent apart.

    Carla learns that the man she's been sleeping with, aka Amy's foster parent, Paul, is a rage-aholic. She first learns this through his ex Meghan, but then gets quite a bit of his wrath herself. It's a good thing he hasn't found out who else she's been taking Amy to see. Yet.